Analysis: Hurricane Sandy and Katrina Term Paper

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document

Total Length: 3679 words ( 12 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 1+

Page 1 of 12

Hurricane Katrina and Hurricane Sandy

Tropical cyclones can badly destroy settlements and structures along the coast. Recent destructive tropical cyclones such as the 2005 Katrina and the Sandy which happened in 2012 affirm that the destruction caused by a land-falling tropical cyclone is not merely dependent on its categorization on the Saffir-Simpson hurricane scale. The hurricane Sandy of 2012 caused a lot of destruction. Only the hurricane Katrina which happened in 2005 has caused more damage than Sandy. To reduce casualties from such calamities, the public needs to react promptly to any pre-storm decisions made by authorities (Kantha, 2013).

Government's Response to Hurricane Katrina

Hurricane Katrina was indeed an out of the ordinary occurrence that brought with it great tragedy. Destroying a vast area of land, approximately 90000 square miles, it is the natural disaster that has caused most destruction in the history of America. Consider the fact that the area covered is the same size as the United Kingdom and you begin to picture the extent of the destruction. Mississippi saw thousands of people left out in the cold after the coastal communities got destroyed. New Orleans experienced devastating floods. The result was that at least 1500 people lost their lives and thousands at the Gulf Coat were left stranded without essential commodities for nearly one week (Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental affairs, 2006).

It is important to note that failure by the government to plan and prepare and also to respond to the storm led to the people suffering longer than they would have had the government been more proactive. The Government's failures were all over the place. There were several contributing factors to these failures. The central ones were:

The government did not pay attention to long-term warnings and they negligently failed to prepare for a disaster that had been forewarned;

The government took inadequate action or came to bad decisions just before the landfall and immediately after;

The systems relied upon by the officials to support response to the disaster failed;

Government officials across all ranks did not provide able leadership (Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, 2006).

Hurricane Katrina was the single largest catastrophe that has befallen America in modern times. According to the Federal disaster declarations that President George W. Bush had signed, the affected area was at least 93,000 square miles and a total of 5 million individuals had been left without power. There are several contributing factors to the Hurricane Katrina disaster notably the lack of preparedness by Americans for a catastrophe of that magnitude as well as the federal government's disappointing failures (Cash, 2014).

Hurricane Katrina brought to light the cracks present in the emergency response mechanisms even after the transformation of the previously influential FEMA which previously reported directly to the president but is now under a different department. Also brought to light was the fact that key federal government leaders did not understand the National Response Plan (NRP) (Cash, 2014).

The disaster showed American citizens that the federal government as well is unprepared to manage some kinds of disasters. It was the first occasion where the new directives at Homeland Security such as the new DHS and National Response Plan and National Incident Management were put to test.

So what made the federal government fail during the Hurricane Katrina disaster? First, FEMA was not independent but was under DHS. This hindered communication between the White House and the officials at the agency. This ensured that information reaching the president was sometimes not entirely accurate but also that information arrived late. Had FEMA been independent, the disastrous result of the Hurricane Katrina could have been avoided. Of course there exist some other factors besides having FEMA being overseen by DHS, but when an effective communication channel is lacking between the White House and FEMA, how would the President be made aware of a catastrophe?

Following the Hurricane Katrina, FEMA has responded to such disasters as the Hurricane Rita, Joplin tornado and Super storm Sandy. None of these disasters has caused as much damage as Hurricane Katrina (Cash, 2014).

Role of Governors in handling Katrina

There have been accusations of personal and political overtones in the handling of the disaster that struck New Orleans in the form of Katrina. According to one of the officials of FEMA, the Governor, Kathleen Blanco was guilty of sending the request for aid and help late in the day. The request, for food, shelter and urgent necessities, he says, was sent only just before the hurricane struck the city; and that too, to the President, George Bush. Even in this reported, delayed request there was no mention of the need for evacuation support.

Stuck Writing Your "Analysis: Hurricane Sandy and Katrina" Term Paper?

View All Our Example Analysis: Hurricane Sandy and Katrina Term Paper

Have A Custom Example Essay Written

The explanation to this action was explained by an aide by saying that the Governor was under the impression that the local state government was already taking care of the evacuation need and help that was required at the site of destruction (ABC News, 2005).

However, people who are in the know of the action plans that emerge out of such situations assert that in such cases and especially so in the case of natural disasters, the onus is on the local and state governments and not on the federal government to provide for the immediate safety measures. The local government itself states that in the event of such disasters and calamities where evacuation is warranted, New Orleans will be undertaking the responsibility in full to make all possible arrangements with all resources at hand to afford the best possible safety measures. All those stranded and unable to fend for themselves will be provided best possible aid and help. That is the plan that the local government professes in its statement to respond in the face of such occurrences (ABC News, 2005).

However, when Katrina Struck, the city administration was found wanting in its efforts. All the points in the aforementioned plan to respond to calamities were not acted upon when this Hurricane hit New Orleans at its fearsome worst. The public were directed to reach the Superdome and the Convention Centre on their own, even where adequate support systems and amenities were not provided for adequately. What was planned and should have been done or was expected is that the city ought to have its own buses to the distraught and helped the people who were stranded out of the danger zone. (ABC News, 2005). So while both city and state governments were slow to respond, they did finally manage to regain control with the help of the federal government.

Ex-mayor of New Orleans, Ray Nagin states that it was only he who had fully anticipated the impact that the hurricane Katrina was going to have on the citizens and that he took it upon himself to help the residents reach safety, in "Katrina's Secrets: Storms After the Storm." His plans that described the rescue and rehabilitation in the aftermath of the hurricane happened had mysteriously disappeared. In a damaging statement Nagin accuses of deferring the decision to his request of rescue operations because of political animosity. Ray had sided with Blanco's opponent during her run for the Governorship. He also goes on to say that she had a running feud with the president himself; there was, he says, an ongoing power struggle between the two at the time the disaster struck New Orleans (Associated Press, 2011).

The riposte of the governor to this alleged political vendetta was answered by calling it a false accusation that arose out of the frustration that Ray carried. He had chosen to do it alone and in the process had isolated himself from the machinery and the powers-that-be. She retorted by saying that she could not believe that such a ridiculous statement that amounts to saying that relief operations weren't carried out of political considerations can even be suggested by him. It is false sense of pride that is making him dream up excuses as to why he was not there when he was needed most. He had isolated himself. He chose not to communicate. He did not make any statement for days after the incident. He is making only a belated statement out of sheer frustration (Associated Press, 2011).

Hurricane Sandy and Government's Response

Hurricane Sandy caused the second largest amount of damage in America's history. Sandy, as per the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's (NOAA) National Hurricane Center, was the single biggest storm of that kind to ever hit the East Coast. The effect was felt across many sectors in the region. Telecommunications as well as data access was halted thus affecting several businesses and people. The storm paralyzed the economy of the greater New York Metropolis (Hurricane Sandy - Rebuilding Strategy, 2013).

Hurricane Sandy hit the East Coast, causing major destruction in areas with dense populations such as New York, Connecticut and New Jersey. The storm was characterized by storm surges, heavy rains and strong winds. Millions lost power, roads got flooded thus restricting transport options and several people numbering….....

Show More ⇣

     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Analysis Hurricane Sandy And Katrina" (2014, November 19) Retrieved May 5, 2024, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/analysis-hurricane-sandy-katrina-2153328

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Analysis Hurricane Sandy And Katrina" 19 November 2014. Web.5 May. 2024. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/analysis-hurricane-sandy-katrina-2153328>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Analysis Hurricane Sandy And Katrina", 19 November 2014, Accessed.5 May. 2024,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/analysis-hurricane-sandy-katrina-2153328
   

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document
order custom essay example