Criminal Behavior Article Review

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document

Total Length: 2273 words ( 8 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 3

Page 1 of 8

Video Game Violence

Criminal behavior

Criminal behavior literature review: Video game violence

One of the most controversial contentions in the recent debate over the causes of violence in American society is that violent video games give rise to violent behavior. After the recent shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School, the Arizona Sun reported that local organizers in the community of Southington, Arizona held a violent video game buy-back, much in the same way that other communities had buy-backs of firearms. "Although the organizers are careful to note there's no evidence violent games contributed to the Sandy Hook shooting, the implication is nonetheless clear. So too, the organizers claim that research links video games with other aggressive acts and desensitization" (Ferguson 2013). The head of the National Rifle Association (NRA) likewise made a link between criminality and video game violence -- but not the presence of guns in American society -- in a much-maligned press release.

However, according to the American Psychology Association, the link between criminal behavior and watching video games is far more dubious. "The American Psychological Association declined to participate in the 2011 Supreme Court case on video games, citing inconsistencies in the literature. Most studies of media violence have historically employed weak and dubious measures of aggression. Those few that actually examine youth violence have generally found little evidence for concern" (Ferguson 2013). The link between real life violence and playing violent video games is a subject of continuing debate, even amongst research psychologists.

Controversies in psychological research correlating what people watch with how they behave actually predate the existence of modern video games. There is over forty years of extant research about media and violence, including "laboratory experiments, field experiments, cross-sectional correlation studies, and longitudinal studies" (Anderson 2003). Perhaps the earliest studies regarding the phenomena of how viewing violence causes the imitation of violent behavior are those of the 'Bobo' studies of researcher Albert Bandura. Bandura would eventually become an exponent of what he called 'social learning' theory, or the idea that many human behaviors were learned or acquired through observation of others, rather than due to inherited traits, "The Bobo Doll Experiment was performed in 1961 by Albert Bandura, to try and add credence to his belief that all human behavior was learned, through social imitation and copying, rather than inherited through genetic factors" (Shuttleworth 2008).

The Bobo experiment demonstrated that children who witnessed adults interacting with an inflatable punch-bag doll in a violent fashion were far more likely to copy that behavior than children exposed to passive role models or no role models at all. Boys were found (as predicted, despite Bandura's insistence that he believed that 'nature' had minimal influence on human behavior) to behave more aggressively in general. But while "male subjects exposed to non-aggressive role models were less likely to use the mallet to hit the Bobo doll. Strangely, male subjects placed with non-aggressive female models were more likely to use the mallet than the control group," perhaps in an effort to prove their masculinity (Shuttleworth 2008)

The much-criticized Bobo study is still often used as proof that nurture rather than nature causes youth violence. But critics quickly noted that "the Bobo doll springs back upright when it is hit and there is a strong possibility that the children saw it as a game rather than anything else," and the toy seems to suggest that 'punching bag' behavior is acceptable, given its very design (Shuttleworth 2008). Also, " there was a follow up experiment, in 1963, which used the same methodology but showed the subjects violence via video; this had a much less defined response than the initial experiment," which further argues against using the Bobo studies to justify the regulation of violent video games in an effort to curtail real world violence (Shuttleworth 2008).

While it is true that some people who engage in violent behavior do watch violent video games, another psychological phenomenon may be at play called confirmation bias. "When events like Sandy Hook happen, as a society we tend to experience what psychologists call 'confirmation bias.' If the perpetrator is a young man, it is often assumed video games contributed. But when a perpetrator doesn't fit the stereotype, such as 62-year-old William Spengler, who killed two volunteer firemen in New York this December, media is not mentioned. Nobody bothers to point out that Spengler didn't play video games" (Ferguson 2013). Correlation does not imply causality.

Stuck Writing Your "Criminal Behavior" Article Review?

View All Our Example Criminal Behavior Article Review

Have A Custom Example Essay Written

While violent persons may enjoy consuming violent media, this does not necessarily mean that the violent media is the root cause of the behavior, given that many violent people do not consume such media, and many nonviolent persons do play video games.

The perpetrator of the Sandy Hook killings was a young man, and many young men watch violent video games, but his youth rather than his status as a killer is likely the reason for his video game consumption, contend naysayers to the social learning thesis. However, defenders of the link between consumption of violent media and real-life violence, stress that video games are unique by their interactive potential and to some extent 'invite' a blurred line between reality and fiction. "Two features of video games fuel renewed interest by researchers, public policy makers, and the general public. First, the active role required by video games…it also may make violent video games even more hazardous than violent television or cinema. Second, the arrival of a new generation of ultraviolent video games beginning in the early 1990s and continuing unabated to the present resulted in large numbers of children and youths actively participating in entertainment violence that went way beyond anything available to them on television or in movies" (Anderson 2003).

Many aspects of adolescent media from rock n' roll to comic books has been blamed for an escalation in teen violence (Ferguson 2012). However, video game's critics state that the interactive nature of the medium makes it even more noxious and potentially dangerous in terms of how it impacts the reward sector of the brain, thus having a desensitizing effect. Evidence that such 'desensitization' occurs has not been established, and research on exposure to television programs indicates that there is an empathetic, cognitive ability to discriminate between 'real' and fictional violence. Ramos (et al. 2012) "found that exposure to violence on screen had no influence on viewer empathy for victims of real violence" (Ferguson 2012). The Ramos study involved 238 young people exposed to either violent or nonviolent TV show who were then exposed to mages of fictional and non-fictional shows depicting violence. "Participants were significantly more empathic of victims' suffering when they knew they were watching real violence rather than fictional violence. Previous exposure to a violent or nonviolent TV show did not reduce empathy" (Ramos 2012).

In a literature review conducted by the Australian government when contemplating the enacting of legislation to more heavily regulate violent video games, the ensuing report divided the two sides of the debate into two camps: that of the causationists and their critics. Causationists "have consistently argued that playing VVGs increases the risk that participants in laboratory and survey-based studies will behave, think and feel, more aggressively. They also argue that VVGs may have a host of other related negative effects such as desensitization and lower levels of empathy" (Literature review on the impact of playing violent video games on aggression. 2012, Commonwealth of Australia: 6) But critics of causationists "focus on the impact of VVGs as being determined by context. They tend to look at the player's interpretation of game content and a range of social, economic, cultural and even biological factors" (Literature review on the impact of playing violent video games on aggression. 2012, Commonwealth of Australia: 6).

In general, causationists have focused more upon scientific, experimental data conducted in laboratory settings when drawing their conclusions about the impact of video games on violent behavior. Some experiments assessing the short-term impact of video games on human behavior under laboratory conditions have found a demonstrable increase in aggressive behavior amongst young people even after brief exposure to more violent media than the members of a control group. But "the extent to which such actions are meaningful in assessing long-term behavior" is not clearly established (Literature review on the impact of playing violent video games on aggression. 2012, Commonwealth of Australia: 18).

For example, a recent study found that "the use of a light gun controller, higher amounts of blood, and more 'real world' violence tended to make players more aggressive" in their language and attitudes in post-game interviews (Literature review on the impact of playing violent video games on aggression. 2012, Commonwealth of Australia: 18). But this seemingly disturbing conclusion "was drawn from subjectively-graded evidence… [which] used responses to 'story stems' involving judges sentencing criminals and parents punishing children to measure aggressive thoughts" that were then graded by.....

Show More ⇣

     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


Related Essays

Criminal Law and Psychopathy

studies have in the past indicated that there is a high correlation between violence/criminal behavior and psychopathy. This would largely be expected given that psychological studies into the character and disposition of psychopaths has demonstrated that the need for control (or power) as well as egocentrism, which also happen to be the dominant character traits of psychopaths, are predictors for deviant or antisocial behavior. The debate on whether or not psychopaths should be held criminally responsible for their acts, and thus be subjected to criminal punishment, has been raging for a long time. On one side of the debate are legal scholars, lawmakers,… Continue Reading...

Criminal Justice Bias

1999). There is no doubt that a crime was indeed committed. The Theory of Criminal Behavior Related to the Selected Case Crime, its practice and existence is perceived through the social construction of criminality and the factors that make it happen. According to the traditional theories in sociology, crime was caused by lack of norms. This was immersed in a feeling of lacking the desired social connectedness. The term anomie was commonly used to refer to this scenario. It was further popularized by Emile Durkhein (1897). He also used the term to describe suicide. Sociologists refined the definition of the term to refer to… Continue Reading...

Reforms Needed for Three Strikes Law

even though they will soon “age out” of criminal behavior. Indeed, men in their 60’s are not able to crawl through windows, run and jump fences like someone in their 20’s or 30’s (Besemer, Ahmad, Hinshaw & Farrington, 2017). In short, there is an obvious pattern and prevalence whereby people are being incarcerated for non-violent offenses. There is also a pattern of some prosecutors “stacking” charges so as to coerce a defendant into a plea bargain (Gocha, 2016). It is not unreasonable for someone that presents a risk to the public to be incarcerated after the commit multiple… Continue Reading...

Analysis of Murderers Alex and Derek King

and the cumulative age-crime curve, thereby corroborating a key crime career theory assumption. A salient feature of their findings is heterogeneous adult criminal behavior. The theorists revealed that criminal activity decreases as the offender ages, even in case of active offenders. Moreover, desistance paths are not prospectively identifiable on the basis of individual differences and typological accounts engrained in childhood. Although childhood projections are fairly correct when it comes to forecasting crime levels between offenders until their twenties, discrete categories, probably valid throughout the course of life, cannot be generated (Sampson & Laub, 2004). Theorists and Year of Theory Formulation Laub and Sampson put forward the age-graded informal social control theory in… Continue Reading...

Prison Psychologists and Biases in Corrections

their disposal access to subjects for research into the endogenous and exogenous factors that may cause or contribute to criminal behavior. Prisoners have long been viewed as a relatively dispensable part of the human population and the lack of attention given to their treatment remains a major ethnical infraction (Magaletta, et al., 2016). The psychological make-up of offenders, whose behavior may be symptomatic of underlying preexisting conditions ranging from mood disorders like anxiety and depression to personality disorders to psychoses, presents unique problems and challenges for prison administrators and correctional officers alike. Because criminal behavior can be the means by which mental illness first becomes recognized, it makes sense… Continue Reading...

Court Process, Judicial Process, and Constitutional Issues

criminal behavior or ask for mercy. The right of allocution is granted to the defendant as an opportunity for him/her to show remorse or explain motivations behind the criminal acts. During this process, the defendant seeks to influence the judge to be lenient in his/her sentence. The judge then issues the sentence, which varies depending on the severity of the crime since a sentence is a formal legal consequence relating to a conviction. Some of the most common criminal sentences include probation, short-term imprisonment, life in prison, and long-term incarceration.… Continue Reading...

Second Chance Act of 2008

criminal justice. The concept refers to an ability of an individual relapsing into criminal behavior. Typically, the recidivism has been measured by a criminal act, which led to reconviction, re-arrest, or return to prison. According to data released by the National Institution of Justice (2015), approximately 67.8%, which is about two-third of the released prisoners are rearrested within three years of their released. Within five years, 76.6%, three- quarter of the released prisoners are rearrested. Moreover, property offenders and those sentenced for drug crimes are in the top lists of the released prisoners likely to be rearrested. The SCA (Second Chance Act) is… Continue Reading...

Elder Abuse

shows how otherwise normal, functioning, law-abiding citizens can commit crimes such as abuse by using rationalization tactics to justify their criminal behaviors. By engaging in rationalization tactics, persons can remove any sense of guilt or regret from their minds and consciences. It is a rationalization of corruption that, in the case of elder abuse, can become a two-way street as the victims may rationalize or justify the behavior of the perpetrator, especially if the perpetrator is a loved-one such as a son or daughter, or if the victim senses that he or she really is a burden and deserves to be neglected. Baer, R. A. (2003).  Mindfulness training as a… Continue Reading...

Social Bonding Theory

Social Bonding Theory The theorist, Hirschi, asserts that those who exhibit deviant behavior desire to do so and that criminal behavior is seen among people with weak social bonds. In his social bonding model, he delineated four elements which make up social bonds, namely, attachment to partner/spouse, engagement in conforming behaviors, holding conventional beliefs and values, and dedication to conventionality (Wolfzorn, Heckert & Heckert, 2006). The theorist indicates that with increased attachment of a person to fellow human beings, their belief in conformist social values will increase. Furthermore, with increased investment and involvement in conventional activity, their propensity to deviate will decrease (Chriss, 2007).   Four Elements of Social… Continue Reading...

Dark Web, Darknet, Deep Web Essay

Dark Web- While the dark web may be known as a marketplace for criminal behaviors and ideas, it originated as a government project. This paper would explore why the government felt like a dark web was an important element for communication, how that origin differed from the deep web, which already permitted people to go below surface exploration of the internet, and whether there are any constructive government uses of the dark web. Morality and Marketing- While many people focus on the users of black market exchange venues, particularly on the internet, the people who have been prosecuted for those markets tend to… Continue Reading...

Dark Net Essay

as a marketplace for criminal behaviors and ideas, it originated as a government project.  This paper would explore why the government felt like a dark web was an important element for communication, how that origin differed from the deep web, which already permitted people to go below surface exploration of the internet, and whether there are any constructive government uses of the dark web. Morality and Marketing- While many people focus on the users of black market exchange venues, particularly on the internet, the people who have been prosecuted for those markets tend to… Continue Reading...

Drug Addiction

the required outcomes. It will definitely not destroy the drug seeking tendencies and involvement in illegal drug-related activities. The treatment of drug offenders will offer a rare opportunity for the alleviation of criminal behavior and reduce drug abuse instances. Although… Continue Reading...

The Housing Crisis and Insecurity and Poverty in America

than address the root causes of criminal behavior. Therefore, the coping mechanisms used to mitigate the deeply damaging problems of systemic poverty are complex and interconnected. Hopelessness and despair are social and psychological precursors to antisocial and violent behaviors: a sense that nothing matters and nothing works. Some people simply lower their expectations gradually, until they tolerate intolerable living conditions. As living conditions deteriorate, the person also learns from experience that complaining to the landlord leads to potentially disastrous consequences. Getting on the landlord’s bad side could lead to sudden evictions at short notice and the… Continue Reading...

Fast Food Restaurant Security

The current perimeter is empty, dark, and exposed. These weaknesses open the possibility for criminal behavior, as the access points are “obscured by low light,” (Locknet, n.d., p. 1). Darkness is the criminal’s best friend, which is why the fast food restaurant needs to upgrade its lighting to cover the entire grounds including the outer perimeter. The restaurant does, however, keep on interior lights after hours to prevent property crimes including break-ins and vandalism. Additionally, the owner is advised to plant hedges around the perimeter to strengthen the outer barrier to entry. The hedges serve as additional boundaries that reduce opportunities for criminals to… Continue Reading...

National Security Impact of Immigration Policy

Immigration Policies as a Tool for National Security Of late, societal apprehension towards immigrants, criminal behavior, and terrorism have intensified, giving rise to concerns regarding the American migrant system’s efficacy in maintaining the safety of the nation’s people. Recent events revolving around crimes, weaponry crossing national boundaries and foreign- born people has triggered a series of reactions with the most intense ones demanding a sealing of borders, barring migration for individuals hailing from high- risk foreign territories, and putting a stop to refugee resettlement. Theory of Migration Migration represents mankind’s story from the outset to the current age. It has its roots in mankind’s adventure- seeking… Continue Reading...

sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Criminal Behavior" (2013, January 11) Retrieved May 18, 2024, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/criminal-behavior-104758

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Criminal Behavior" 11 January 2013. Web.18 May. 2024. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/criminal-behavior-104758>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Criminal Behavior", 11 January 2013, Accessed.18 May. 2024,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/criminal-behavior-104758
   

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document
order custom essay example