Extrinsic Motivation Essay

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document

Total Length: 2217 words ( 7 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 5

Page 1 of 7

Extrinsic motivation refers to behavior that is driven by external rewards such as money, fame, grades, and praise. This type of motivation arises from outside the individual, as opposed to intrinsic motivation, which involves engaging in a behavior because it is personally rewarding; essentially, performing an activity for its own sake rather than the desire for some external reward (Ryan & Deci, 2000).

One of the primary theories associated with extrinsic motivation is the behaviorist concept of operant conditioning. B.F. Skinner, a well-known psychologist, suggested that behavior is a function of its consequences; thus, behavior that is reinforced tends to be repeated (i.e., strengthened), while behavior that is not reinforced tends to die out-or be extinguished (i.e., weakened) (Skinner, 1953). For example, when a student receives a reward (such as a gold star) for a high test score, this positive reinforcement may increase the likelihood that the student will study for future tests.

In the context of the workplace, extrinsic motivation is often used to motivate employees through monetary bonuses, promotions, status symbols like corner offices, or the threat of job loss (Pink, 2009). The underlying assumption is that employees will increase productivity or improve performance to obtain these external rewards or to avoid negative consequences such as demotion or dismissal.

However, it is important to consider the potential downsides of heavy reliance on extrinsic motivation. Research has shown that while extrinsic rewards can be effective at motivating certain types of task performance in the short term, they can sometimes lead to a decrease in intrinsic motivation (Deci, Koestner, & Ryan, 1999). This could manifest as reduced engagement or decreased creativity when the rewards are not available, reflecting a shift in focus from the enjoyment and satisfaction derived from the task itself to the pursuit of the rewards associated with the task.

Educational settings often serve as a natural laboratory for the exploration of extrinsic motivation. Grades, diplomas, and scholarships are common extrinsic motivators for students. The expectation of receiving these rewards can lead students to engage in behaviors such as cheating or rote memorization rather than truly engaging with the material and developing a deeper understanding (Kohn, 1993). This calls into question the effectiveness of extrinsic rewards in fostering genuine learning and underscores the need for a balance between intrinsic and extrinsic motivators.

The Self-Determination Theory (SDT) further explains the interplay between extrinsic and intrinsic motivation. According to Ryan and Deci (2000), external motivations can be internalized and turned into personally endorsed values, if they are presented in a way that supports an individual's sense of autonomy, competence, and relatedness. For instance, when students internalize the importance of learning for their future careers, the previously extrinsic motivation of grades may be transformed into an intrinsic desire to learn and grow.

Delving further into the nuances of extrinsic motivation, research has shown that the effectiveness of extrinsic rewards can be contingent on the perceived autonomy of the individual (Deci & Ryan, 1987). When extrinsic rewards are perceived as controlling or as undermining one's sense of self-determination, they are more likely to have a detrimental effect on intrinsic motivation. However, if rewards are perceived as informational and affirming competence without constraining autonomy, they may be less likely to have negative effects on intrinsic motivation and could even enhance it under certain circumstances (Ryan, 1982).

In the context of performance-contingent rewards, which are given based on the level of performance attained, there can be complex effects on motivation. On one hand, these rewards can provide clear standards and goals that may enhance certain types of task engagement. On the other hand, they can lead to an increased pressure to perform, which may undermine intrinsic motivation or lead to anxiety, especially if the rewards are seen as too challenging or unattainable (Eisenberger & Cameron, 1996).

Self-Perception Theory also provides insight into how external rewards might affect intrinsic motivation. Daryl Bem (1972) suggested that individuals come to know their own attitudes and feelings by inferring them from observations of their own behavior and the circumstances in which this behavior occurs. If people receive an external reward for an activity, they might infer that their motivation for the activity is the reward rather than any intrinsic interest, potentially leading to a decrease in their intrinsic interest in the activity once the reward is removed.

The concept of overjustification effect is related to this discussion. It postulates that when an external incentive is given to a person for an action they already find intrinsically rewarding, they may attribute their action to the incentive, rather than their own interest, thus decreasing their intrinsic motivation (Lepper, Greene & Nisbett, 1973). This suggests a delicate balance is required in using rewards to avoid overjustification.

Despite these concerns, extrinsic motivators are not universally detrimental to intrinsic motivation. Certain types of tasks and individuals may respond better to extrinsic motivators than others. For example, routine, monotonous tasks that are not inherently enjoyable might require external rewards to promote completion and persistence (Condry, 1977). Moreover, when individuals do not perceive an intrinsic value in a task or lack confidence in their abilities, extrinsic rewards can provide the necessary motivation for task engagement and skill development until intrinsic motivation potentially grows (Bandura, 1997).

Furthermore, understanding individual differences is crucial for the application of extrinsic rewards. Some individuals may perceive external rewards as affirmations of their competence and are thus motivated to achieve higher levels of performance, while others may view them as coercive and controlling, which could undermine their intrinsic motivation (Deci et al., 1999). Customization of motivational strategies to align with individual preferences and perceptions can be a more effective approach than a one-size-fits-all model.

Building upon this understanding, it's worth considering the role of feedback in extrinsic motivation. While feedback can function as an extrinsic motivator, when it is aligned with an individual's intrinsic goals and values, it can be particularly powerful. The key is that feedback should be constructive and aimed at helping individuals improve their skills or knowledge, rather than just serving as a mechanism to control behavior (Hattie & Timperley, 2007). When feedback is provided in a way that enhances an individual's mastery of a subject or task, it supports a more autonomous form of motivation, which can interact positively with intrinsic motivation (Ryan & Deci, 2000).

Stuck Writing Your "Extrinsic Motivation" Essay?

View All Our Example Extrinsic Motivation Essay

Have A Custom Example Essay Written



In organizational settings, the complexity of extrinsic motivation can be observed in the use of performance appraisals and incentive systems. Goal-setting theory complements the understanding of extrinsic motivation by suggesting that clear, specific, and challenging goals can enhance employee performance (Locke & Latham, 2002). However, if the goals are consistently perceived as too difficult or if the link between performance and rewards is unclear, it can lead to decreased motivation and even counterproductive work behavior (Cawley, Keeping & Levy, 1998).

An important consideration in the use of extrinsic motivators is the time frame of their impact. Short-term increases in motivation may be achieved through incentives, but for long-term sustainability, it's important for the reward system to be perceived as fair and for the rewards to be aligned with individuals' values and needs (Cropanzano & Mitchell, 2005). This is echoed in self-determination theory, where Deci and Ryan argue that the satisfaction of basic psychological needs, such as autonomy, competence, and relatedness, is essential for long-term motivation and well-being (Ryan & Deci, 2000).

The interplay between extrinsic and intrinsic motivation is also evident in educational settings. Gamification, which applies game-design elements in non-game contexts, can use extrinsic motivators like badges and leaderboards to engage students. However, the effects on motivation can be mixed. While gamification can increase participation and immediate engagement, it doesn't always translate to deeper learning or sustained motivation (Dicheva, Dichev, Agre & Angelova, 2015). Teachers and instructional designers therefore face the challenge of embedding such extrinsic elements in ways that do not undermine the intrinsic interest in learning (Sailer, Hense, Mayr & Mandl, 2017).

Similarly, in therapy and health promotion, external rewards can be used to initiate behavior change, such as in weight loss programs or smoking cessation initiatives. Yet, for lasting change, intrinsic motivation is usually necessary, highlighting the importance of moving individuals towards more self-determined forms of motivation over time (Teixeira, Carraça, Markland, Silva & Ryan, 2012).

The implications of these findings for practice are clear: extrinsic motivators can be effective, but their design and implementation must be thoughtful and considerate of the individuals involved. A nuanced approach—taking into account the type of task, individual differences in response to rewards, and the alignment between extrinsic rewards and intrinsic goals—can help maintain or even enhance intrinsic motivation. This delicate balance is the cornerstone of effectively utilizing extrinsic motivation without undermining the inherent drive and satisfaction that comes from engaging with a task for its own sake.

Continuing the exploration of extrinsic motivation, it's crucial to examine the differential effects of various types of extrinsic rewards on motivation and performance. Monetary incentives, for instance, have been a staple in many organizational contexts to drive performance. While financial rewards can be powerful, they can also lead to 'crowding out' of intrinsic motivation, particularly when the tasks are intrinsically interesting or when they require creativity and problem-solving skills (Gneezy, Meier & Rey-Biel, 2011). This can result in a paradoxical decrease in overall motivation if individuals perceive the reward as controlling or undermining their sense of autonomy (Deci, Koestner & Ryan, 1999).

Conversely, non-monetary rewards such as praise, recognition, and opportunities for growth and development can sometimes enhance intrinsic motivation by fulfilling psychological needs for competence and relatedness (Ryan & Deci, 2000; Gagné & Deci, 2005). This suggests that while extrinsic rewards can be effective for repetitive and uninteresting tasks that are not inherently motivating, for more complex and interesting tasks, non-monetary extrinsic rewards that support a person's needs for growth and recognition may be more effective.

Furthermore, the source of extrinsic motivation can also influence its effectiveness. When the source of the motivation is perceived as supportive, providing choice, and acknowledging feelings, it tends to be more in line with intrinsic motivation and is less likely to be experienced as controlling (Deci, Eghrari, Patrick & Leone, 1994). This is why programs that involve participatory decision-making and allow some degree of autonomy over how rewards are earned can result in better outcomes in terms of engagement and internalization of desired behaviors (Gagné & Forest, 2008).

Another aspect to consider is the role of individual differences in responses to extrinsic motivators. Self-Determination Theory posits that individuals differ in their propensity towards autonomy and therefore may react differently to extrinsic rewards (Deci & Ryan, 1985). For example, individuals with a high need for autonomy may find extrinsic rewards less motivating, or even demotivating, compared to individuals with a lower need for autonomy who may respond more positively to such rewards (Vansteenkiste, Lens & Deci, 2006).

Additionally, the cultural context can't be overlooked when discussing the impact of extrinsic motivators. Cultures that place a greater emphasis on collective goals and rewards might view extrinsic motivation more positively, seeing it as aligned with social harmony and group objectives (Iyengar & DeVoe, 2003). In contrast, cultures with a strong emphasis on individual achievement might respond better to personal rewards and recognition (Triandis, 1994).

As we consider these multiple dimensions of extrinsic motivation, it is evident that no one-size-fits-all approach exists for its application. Individual, contextual, and cultural variables all play crucial roles in determining the effectiveness of extrinsic rewards. Thus, the application of extrinsic incentives must be customized and dynamically-adjusted to fit the needs and perceptions of the individual and their socio-cultural environment. Using extrinsic motivators wisely requires a deep understanding of the individualized interplay between different types of motivation and the delicate balance needed to foster sustained engagement and satisfaction in a given activity.

Conclusion



To optimize motivation, it is critical to consider the nature of the task, the individual's underlying drives, and the potential for internalizing extrinsic motivations into a more self-determined form of motivation. A nuanced approach—taking into account the type of task, individual differences in response to rewards, and the alignment between extrinsic rewards and intrinsic goals—can help maintain or even enhance intrinsic motivation.

.....

Show More ⇣

     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


Related Essays

Early Childhood Education and Motivation

Mr. Cardot is doing a great job using extrinsic motivation, but what would really help his students to grasp the concept of setting in stories would be to increase the use of intrinsic motivation. Increasing intrinsic motivation requires Mr. Cardot to connect with this second grade class, understanding their needs and creating lessons that are responsive to their needs to be "competent, connected, and in control," (Chapter 12, p. 451). Being competent, connected, and in control simply means that the students need to be challenged just enough. As Woolfolk puts it, "Moderate difficulty provides a challenge, but not… Continue Reading...

Psychology of Motivation and Oxytocin

Self-determination theory also takes into account the importance of both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. The basic motivational goals people have include competency, relatedness, and autonomy (Deci & Ryan, 2008). Deci & Ryan (2008) also claim there are two main categories of individual difference regarding motivation: causality orientation and goals. By showing people what motivates them and why, therapists can help individuals create the cognitive and behavioral contingencies that lead to self-fulfillment. Self-determination theory is also solution-focused and positive, encouraging the person to remain mindful and to cultivate self-awareness. One area that self-determination theory can be used is with regards to losing weight… Continue Reading...

What Animal Shelters Can Do to Reduce the Gender Gap in Volunteerism

animal shelter when they were motivated by intrinsic and emotional factors than by the extrinsic motivations including social pressure and guilt. The limitations of this hypothetical study are clear. It uses a limited population sample, and there are some issues that could detract from both internal and external validity. While literature does reveal gender differences in volunteering, there is a gap of literature in animal shelters in particular. There is also a gap in the literature regarding the role of men in volunteering, and what motivates men. If animal shelters need more volunteers, and they do, then animal shelters do need to know how… Continue Reading...

Motivational Theories of Animal Shelters

(Oostlander, Guntert, van Schie & Wehner, 2013). Controlled motivation, on the other hand, entails extrinsic motivation such as pressure to engage in a volunteer activity, or guilt avoidance (Oostlander, Guntert, van Schie & Wehner, 2013). Research suggests that young people may be more apt to volunteer based on controlled motivation versus autonomous motivation (Markovitz & Queen, 2009). Volunteers in animal shelters tend to be motivated by "a need to act on important values relating to animals," suggesting intrinsic and autonomous factors, but that may also be due to the majority of shelter volunteers being female (Markovitz & Queen, 2009, p. 11). Moreover, Stroup, Dodson,… Continue Reading...

Single-Sex or Co-Ed Schools in England

attractive. On the other hand, co-ed schools also have their advantages: they can provide more diversity of environment which can give extrinsic motivations to students (Mujtaba & Reiss, 2013), they allow schools to focus on gender-relational issues so as to assist in the development of students and in the closing of the gender gap (Younger & Warrington, 2007), and they are generally freer of the type of ceilings that are found in single-sex schools (Malacova, 2007). First, co-ed schools offer more diversity, which is good for students who thrive on external motivations: the more diverse an environment, the more likely the right kind of stimulus or motivation is to be found.… Continue Reading...

Leadership Problems and Proposed Recommendations Essay

needed to ensure that with the changes and an increase in workload, there would be a commensurate remuneration to act as an extrinsic motivation to the employees. Joe Doss case study This short case study highlights the challenges that the gifted Joe, on technical issues, has in ensuring is team of researchers works cohesively with him as the head of that research team. Though in the technical aspects Joe outperformed everyone, he still finds it hard to manage his colleagues. At the individual level, Joe has serious problems with his interpersonal communication skills since he gives no attention to the opinions of other team members, not even his manager, instead he is… Continue Reading...

Various Issues of Organization Behavior

increase in workload, there would be a commensurate remuneration to act as an extrinsic motivation to the employees. Joe Doss case study This short case study highlights the challenges that the gifted Joe, on technical issues, has in ensuring is team of researchers works cohesively with him as the head of that research team. Though in the technical aspects Joe outperformed everyone, he still finds it hard to manage his colleagues. At the individual level, Joe has serious problems with his interpersonal communication skills since he gives no attention to the opinions of other team members, not even his manager, instead he is… Continue Reading...

Human Resources Management in Nonprofit Organizations

the organization,” (p. 5). In other words, HRM strategies do need to recognize the importance of extrinsic motivation, providing employees with rewards, bonuses, salaries, and opportunities for advancement. Using a similar regression analysis design as in the Brown & Yoshioka (2003) study, Kim & Lee (2007) found that “pay…[…… parts of this paper are missing, click here to view the entire document ]…Demographic data, including the amount of time an employee has been with the organization, will be collected in the interests of finding a possible link between demographic factors and the types of human resources strategies used, and the researcher will also take into account… Continue Reading...

sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Extrinsic Motivation" (2024, February 26) Retrieved May 5, 2025, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/extrinsic-motivation-2180078

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Extrinsic Motivation" 26 February 2024. Web.5 May. 2025. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/extrinsic-motivation-2180078>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Extrinsic Motivation", 26 February 2024, Accessed.5 May. 2025,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/extrinsic-motivation-2180078
   

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document
order custom essay example