Great Recession Essay

Total Length: 1541 words ( 5 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 3

Page 1 of 5

Monetary Policy

Many observers have critiques the U.S. Federal Reserve for its monetary policy leading up to the Great Recession. There were many causal factors to the Great Recession. These range from deregulation of the banking industry with the passage of the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act of 1999, to financial institutions engaging in desperate yield-seeking in the years after the 9/11 terrorist attacks slowed the economy, to predatory lending, all resulting a surge of debt, much of it of lower quality than many realized, or at least were willing to admit (The Economist, 2013). One causal factor that has also been attributed was the flood of cheap credit on the global financial markets, courtesy of American monetary policy

"Monetary Policy in Ordinary Times"

The Federal Reserve Bank conducts monetary policy in the U.S., as the central bank. It has argued that in the years leading up to the financial crisis, it conducted normal monetary policy for ordinary times, phrasing to distinguish from the extraordinary measures it was forced to undertake in the recession to combat the liquidity trap with minimal fiscal policy assistance. Hill and Wood (2014) outline what the Fed means when it says monetary policy in ordinary times. Monetary policy reflects any policy that the central bank undertakes to influence the money supply. The Federal Reserve relies on three primary instruments of monetary policy -- reserve requirements, the discount rate, and open market transactions. Reserve requirements are the amount of deposits that banks need to hold. The Fed can change this rate, and the banks need to either tighten lending or they can loosen it. Open market transactions reflect purchases or sales of short-term Treasury securities, as a means of either pulling money out of the economy or injecting money into it. The discount rate is literally the cost of money to financial institutions. When this increases, they pass that increase along to their customers, which should reduce borrowing.

In ordinary times, Hill and Wood (2014) note, the Fed is reticent to use reserve requirements as an instrument because of the burden this places on banks. Further, the discount rate is "passive in ordinary times, in that the discount rate only reflects other Federal Reserve policies." Thus, the primary monetary policy instrument in ordinary times is open market transactions. The Federal Reserve Open Market Committee (FOMC) guides the market through the use of open market transactions, which will be used to price money to a target interest rate, the Fed funds rate. These OMCs are carried out on a daily basis and affect the amount of money in the banking system (Hill & Wood, 2014). Expansionary policy, used to spur economic growth, would be to buy Treasury securities, which injects money into the system. Contractionary policy, typically used to fight inflation, involves selling Treasury securities, taking money out of the financial system.

Ordinary Times

The terrorist attacks on 9/11 were the catalyst for an economic downturn. The economy contracted briefly -- not enough to be a recession -- but there was considerable uncertainty in the markets, and economic performance was suboptimal in the ensuring quarters (BEA, 2014).

At the beginning of September, 2001, economic conditions were basically normal, and the Fed funds rate was 3.5%. This rate was reduced rapidly, in three stages, to 2.0% by early November of that year. More cuts ensued, down to a low of 1.0%, before the Fed funds rate began to increase in June of 2004 (NY Fed, 2014). By this time, the economy had recovered strongly. Thus, the Federal Reserve was using expansionary monetary policy at a point in time when the economy was healthy, and the GDP was growing.

This expansionary monetary policy during this 2002-2004 period has been attributed as a causal factor in the economic crisis, because it flooded the economy with low cost money. Credit was cheap at those rates, banks were lending, but there was no yield out there, because of the low rates. There were many manifestations of what went wrong at this point. First, the housing market was heating up because mortgage rates were low. New borrowers entered the market, and the low rates provided an opportunity for predatory lenders to seek out low-income earners for mortgages.

Second, major financial institutions were flush with cash, and were seeking yield.
They found it in all sorts of investments -- European real estate was a popular one, and another was in collateralized mortgage securities. These were bundled products containing a range of mortgages, in complex structures. They were marketed as having AAA credit ratings, but the reality is that they did not. A simple explanation is that any they were diversified against default risk on any individual mortgage, but were not built to withstand systemic risk associated with the entire mortgage market. This despite the fact that the entire mortgage market is subject to interest rate risk, and rates were abnormally low. Free from Glass Steagall regulations, U.S. banks indulged in what looked like AAA products but carried interest rates much higher than that rating would imply. Nobody asked any questions -- they were playing with found money because the Fed had been flooding the market for two years to spur economic growth to offset the damage caused by the terrorists and perhaps to generate taxes to help pay for a couple of otherwise unfunded wars.

What Goes Down Must Come Up

Ordinary monetary policy is rather mundane -- when the market is doing well, there is the risk of inflation. When inflation starts to rise, the central bank steps in, increases the interest rates in order to reduce the inflation. As the flood money cause housing prices to spike, and created a glut of consumer credit as well, the U.S. economy began to heat up across the board. But the real asset bubble that was dangerous was in the housing market, where cheap credit facilitated not only predatory lending but rampant speculation.

The problem is that inflation was beginning to creep up, and the Federal Reserve, this being normal conditions, was going to raise rates. Many observers have criticized the Fed for raising rates too fast. The Fed funds rate increased from 2.0% at the beginning of December, 2004 to 4.0% a year later, and up to 5.25% by mid-2006. This spike in rates had a number of effects. First, it shifted consumer preference towards more savings and away from spending, because the cost of money was significantly higher (Lothian, 2009). Second, it set the stage for the bursting of the real estate bubble. While the policy was intended to cool the bubble, nobody seemed to realize how this would play out. Predatory lenders were selling step-up mortgages, with a low introductory rates that would float, and thus at this point would rise quickly in 18 months. When these mortgages came due for renewal, many were unable to afford these houses at higher rates. Worse yet, because the real estate bubble burst, they were underwater and couldn't sell either. This caused a systemic shock in the housing market. Any institution holding real estate assets, and this including collateralized debt obligations, found itself with securities whose value was uncertain, but quite likely dropping. Thus, the crisis in the financial markets.

Conclusion

The Federal Reserve is by no means "to blame" for the Great Recession, but its somewhat unorthodox approach to monetary policy during the 1990s, where it held onto stimulatory policy too long and then overcorrected like a teenager on an icy highway by ramping up rates more quickly than the market could handle contributed to the issue. A slower rate of increase, started much earlier, would have allowed for the market to adjust gradually to the increasing rates, but instead this was not the case. The market had to adjust quickly, and for many borrowers that was more than they could afford. Once the contagion of the toxic assets was in the market place, it did more damage than one might have expected because so many foreign financial institutions had purchased these assets, thinking that their low-cost money from the Fed would allow them to pay for these AAA securities with healthy interest rates. Yes, it was a flaw in their thinking to think that a AAA security would have anything other than a AAA rate attached to it, but too many financial institutions both in the U.S. And abroad felt that they had found cheap money and knew a good, safe place to put it. The cheap money is only part of the problem, but it is reasonable to believe that.....

Show More ⇣


     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


Related Essays

How to Grow the Economy

and recent example of this was the years during and after the Great Recession. Indeed, that massive financial valley started in roughly 2007 and the recession did not "end" until 2009. The economy grow at a consistent yet tepid pace despite very low interest rates that are just now starting to be raised. Even so, what was done in response to the Great Recession ran the gamut of Keynesian investment to lowering interest rates and taxes as a means to prop up the economy or perhaps even jumpstart it. Generally speaking, an economy that wants its people to invest and grow will… Continue Reading...

Non Credit Programs on Workforce Education

provide neutral and trustworthy information. Many Americans with various levels of education, occupations and job skills went through colossal economic turmoil during and after the Great Recession and adults possessing less tertiary education or lacking in job-relevant skills were hit the hardest. Job seekers in this category with low fundamental skills and education are more likely to require further education before they can return to work, this is partly because employers' skills and educational demands from workers are more than they were in the past. Another factor that may be an impediment to older job seekers is employers' requirements for staff possessing advanced computer and technology skills (Van Horn, Krepcio, & Heidkamp, 2015). 2. Who… Continue Reading...

Quantitative Easing

Easing was used to stimulate the economy following the "Great Recession." At the start of the financial crisis, the European Central Bank did not decrease its rates. However, when the Lehman Brothers' institution collapsed, the ECB cut its key interest rates to historic low levels. In the period between October 2008 and May 2009, the rate was reduced to 1%. In particular, the positive impact of this monetary policy was that it boosted economic activity by stimulating the banks and financial institutions to lend and also for the increase in spending by consumers (Fahr et al., 2011; Labonte, 2016).… Continue Reading...

Greek Debt Crisis

of having less than stellar fiscal discipline. It had a trade deficit and when the Great Recession struck Europe in 2009, Greece was in no condition to stabilize. Even well before the Recession, Greece's credit rating had been going down (before finally being junked in 2010). Thus, in 2010, it applied for aid to the IMF (along with the EC and ECB -- the three of which made up the Troika, promising Greece over 100 billion Euros in loans to "bail" the country out of its debt and pending sovereign default. The loan was to cover the country through 2013 and was meant to be… Continue Reading...

Unemployment Insurance Essay

off generally get at leats a few months of insurance. In times of higher economic strain such as the Great Recession, the length of the allowable benefits is often extended. While most people would not argue that unemployment insurance is not needed, there are many that say the length of the benefits and/or the strings attached to getting the money should be altered when the situation calls for it. Analysis A job loss can rock the finances of a family. Indeed, the bills do not stop just because the money stops coming in. Beyond that, many people lose their jobs due to factors out of their control such as… Continue Reading...

Credit Rating Agencies Essay

have an enormous impact on investor confidence. Following the 2008 subprime mortgage meltdown and the Great Recession of 2009 that resulted, there were growing calls for reform of the rating processes used by credit reporting agencies. To determine the facts with credit rating agencies, this paper reviews the literature to provide an overview of these for-profit organizations and a description of the purposes they serve. An examination of the regulatory environment in which credit rating agencies operate is followed by an analysis of current issues with credit rating agencies in the United States and abroad. Finally, a summary of the research and important findings concerning… Continue Reading...

How to Buy and Flip a House

price in Gwinnett County actually dropped a lot in light of the recession that happened in the late 2000's, that being the Great Recession that ran from 2007 to 2009 and that has really not been recovered from since in many ways. Indeed, the average home price in 2008 was a rather soaring $213,000. By 2012, that number had fallen by more than a fourth, all the way to $157,000. This number is even lower than where things were more than a decade ago in 2003, when they average was at $174,000. Prices are starting to edge back up but it will take some time for the area to recover (Young, 2014).… Continue Reading...

US Airways and American Airlines Merger Essay

reduce capacity and create larger, more efficient operations. This merger is just one of many in this consolidation process. The airline industry also saw several bankruptcies in the years leading up to American's. The 9/11 terror attacks, persistent high fuel prices, and then the Great Recession all took their toll on the profitability of airlines, with the result being that many sought the protection of bankruptcy in order to restructure their finances.… Continue Reading...

Foreign Debt and Debt Services in South Africa Essay

economic growth, the country experienced a downturn, like other major economies, after the Great Recession of 2009 (Selassie, 2011). The South African economy has languished with complete recovery being elusive (Selassie, 2011). GNI Growth As an annual percentage, GNI growth reflects the total of value from all domestic producers as well as any product taxes (less subsidies) that are not included in the valuation of output plus net receipts of primary income (compensation of employees and property income) that are received from other countries (GNI growth, 2014). The GNI growth for South Africa for the period 2010 through 2013 is set forth in… Continue Reading...

sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Great Recession" (2014, November 30) Retrieved June 5, 2026, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/great-recession-2152977

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Great Recession" 30 November 2014. Web.5 June. 2026. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/great-recession-2152977>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Great Recession", 30 November 2014, Accessed.5 June. 2026,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/great-recession-2152977