Human Resource Management Term Paper

Total Length: 1343 words ( 4 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 1+

Page 1 of 4

Coaching as an Alternative to Reviews in Performance Appraisal

Human resources is an area fraught with the most complex issues facing corporations today. From the Americans with Disabilities Act to the Equal Employment Commission to sexual harassment training, human resources departments have gone from storing file folders with employees' remaining vacation days to the most critical wing of an organization.

Perhaps the oldest human resources duty that stays within the department today is performance appraisal. Human resources manages and selects the manner in which bosses evaluate employees at an organization. The procedures involved impact not only salaries and promotions, but form the very fabric of the organization. Are employees motivated, productive and happy? The answer to those questions most often lies within performance appraisal methods. In fact, it is not at all a stretch to comment that performance appraisal governs whether an organization is successful at all.

The problem lies in the history of performance appraisal. From eons ago, bosses simply called employees into their offices to accost them with their errors.

Sometimes, these conversations would encompass yearly salary increases, and not much more. Slowly, these conversations evolved into yearly reviews. Generally, reviews were held once a year, and again listed the errors made by an employee, although sometimes praise was thrown at the employee too. Salary discussions and benefits discussions routinely became part of the reviews.

The inherent problems with reviews were -- and continue to be -- numerous. First, the boss talks to the employee from on high: For instance, the rhetoric is quite similar to this dramatization: "I am your superior, therefore I will tell you what you are doing wrong, and you will simply accept my criticism sans comment." This is problematic for so many reasons. First, the boss often really does not know what the employee does on a day-to-day basis. Second, the employee is immediately on the defensive, and continues to be so throughout the review. This defensive posturing extends most often throughout the employee's relationship with the organization; if reviews are so one-sided, it is more than likely that the company's culture is one-sided too.

Perhaps the biggest issue that is missed in traditional reviews is simply the understanding that employees have a lot to contribute to organizations.
As foot soldiers who fight on the ground floor or on the front, depending on one's analogy, employees generally have the best ideas on how to improve performance, attitude, and bottom line results and financials for an organization. Moreover, they at least have a better idea than does the boss of their own strengths and weaknesses. They know best how they can contribute to the organization, and know even better how they are not, and cannot, contribute nearly as well.

Enter coaching. Coaching, in many progressive or frontier companies, replaces reviews entirely. Coaching begins with the premise that employees and bosses are equal on the plane of life; bosses simply have a broader position at a particular organization. Coaching occurs at least twice a year, rather than once a year for reviews, and maybe occur more frequently.

Each time a coaching session is begun, three steps are involved. All are written and recorded. The first step asks the employee herself to evaluate her performance. It starts with the question, "What have I done for you lately?" In other words, allow the employee to begin first with what he or she feels he or she has accomplished since the last coaching session: what he or she has contributed to the corporation.

The purpose of this particular way of starting is manifold. First, the employee is not at all on the defensive. The first opportunity the employee has to speak -- which is the start of the session, as in the first coaching session, the boss does not really speak but to encourage the employee to vent his thoughts -- the employee is forced to say something good about himself. Note that in a traditional review, the employee is forced to defend his least satisfactory performance immediately.

Not….....

Show More ⇣


     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


Related Essays

Review of Human Resource Management

Organization Brief Description International Human Resource Management (IHRM) can be delineated as a set of activities purposed at the management of organizational human resources at the global level to attain organizational aims and accomplish competitive advantage over rivals at national and global levels. It encompasses characteristic human resource management functions like training and development, recruitment and selection, as well as performance appraisal undertaken at the global level. So as to closely incorporate company operations across the globe, multinational corporations try to cultivate and instigate standardized human resource management practices by transmitting the practices being… Continue Reading...

Human Resources

resources refer to the people who comprise the organization. The practice of human resource management includes employee recruitment, hiring practices, employee development and retention, discipline, motivation, and to a degree, organizational culture and socialization. Human resource management also involves job or role definitions and clarifying hierarchies and relationships within an organizational structure. Ethical codes and codes of behavior may also be covered under the rubric of human resources management. Human resources departments often operate independently but in conjunction with other departments to create a cohesive strategy for management and organizational structure. Training for human resources management can vary, and often little more… Continue Reading...

Strategic Resource Management Hewlett Packard Enterprise

Activity 1: Human Resource Management (HRM) HP Corporate Objectives Profit: Recognizing that profit constitutes the single most effective measure of the organization's contributions to the community, in addition to being the most basic source of business strength. Attaining maximum possible levels of profit in line with other business goals is the aim. Striving for constant advancement in company offering (i.e., services and products) quality, value, and utility (Hewlett-Packard, 2016). Field of Interest: Focusing efforts and constantly pursuing fresh development opportunities, whilst simultaneously limiting participation to areas wherein the company possesses capability and… Continue Reading...

Johnson and Johnson Human Resource Value and Contribution

distinct sections. That is organizational structure, organizational strategy and human resource management. So, J&J organization structure will be explored, the various strategies that the company has pursed over the years will be elaborated and finally J&J human resource management practices will be discussed. Other sections in the paper include organizational design theory and emerging issues in HR management. Organizational Design Theory Organizational design (OD) theory is “the study of how organizations function and how they affect and are affected by the environment in which they operate” (Stanford, 2015). An organization is defined as the deliberate arrangement of people to… Continue Reading...

Diversity Management

implies recognizing diversity management as an important element of the overall strategy of an organization. Indeed, the notion of strategic human resource management (SHRM) has gained immense popularity in recent times. It has now become important… Continue Reading...

Conflict Management in the Workplace

nationalities, racial and ethnic backgrounds because of increased globalization and rapid technological advancements. As a result, human resource management practices in today’s business atmosphere have incorporated diversity as a crucial component towards promoting the wellbeing and success of the workforce. Diversity is seen as an important factor in enhancing the contributions of the workforce toward achievement of organizational goals and objectives. However, organizations are faced with the need to handle conflicts effectively because of the diverse nature of the workplace and workforce (Oni-Ojo, Iyiola & Osibanjo, 2014). Therefore, workplace conflict management has emerged as an important factor toward promoting the suitable functioning of the workforce. Effective… Continue Reading...

Changing Psychological Contract Implications for HRM

(Smissen, Schalk & Freese, 2013). The shifting psychological contract has consequently presented a significant challenge for organizations, specifically their human resource management (HRM) function. The challenge relates to maintaining and improving employee motivation, commitment, and job satisfaction, which tend to be crucial drivers of both individual organizational productivity and performance (Smissen, Schalk & Freese, 2013). It is imperative for organizations to acknowledge the shifting psychological contract, and create new contracts that are favorable to both the employer and the employee. With reference to literature in the area of organizational behavior and HRM, this paper explores the changing employer-employee relationship and its implications on HRM. First, a comprehensive definition of… Continue Reading...

IBM Supply Chain Concerns

operations, which the greater context of human resources, information system management and supply chain management. Human Resource Management Human resource management plays a valuable role in the overall operations of an organization. Moreover, it is inextricably linked to management information systems and supply chain management since it is ultimately an organization’s people which are responsible for its success (Gerstner Jr., 2008). There are a number of functions that human resources fulfills that are divided into two categories. The first pertains to sustainability; the second relates to competitive advantage. Compensation and benefits packages are required to keep the personnel working for an organization. Similarly, mandates for… Continue Reading...

Multinational Companies

and Harzing, 2003). One of the major complexities MNCs face relate to human resource management (HRM). Indeed, managing human resources in the international context can be a daunting task. This is particularly because of considerable cultural, institutional, economic, and political differences across countries (Thite, Wilkinson and Shah, 2012). National (country-of-origin) characteristics tend to influence how MNCs behave in the host country. They influence not only corporate strategy, but also the kind of HRM practices MNCs adopt in the host country (Sethi and Elango, 1999; Yu, Park and Cho, 2007; Cox, 2014; Chung and Furusawa, 2015). For their subsidiaries or overseas operations, MNCs… Continue Reading...

Pay for Performance

The Office of Personnel Management was created under the Civil Service Reform Act in 1978. Some of the functions of this office included: Overseeing the human resource management of the Merit Systems Protection Board and prevent abuse of office. (Eijkenaar et.al 2013) The act also had provision for performance appraisal for the employees, merit pay for different levels of employment, and ways to deal with poor performance. In addition, the act specified that employees would get only half of their normal normal salary increase. The other half would be shared… Continue Reading...

High Working Performance in Organizations

working” owing to its wide ranging and assorted usage. In spite of this aspect, Mkamwa (2010) argues that HPW can be defined as a distinct assimilation of human resource management practices, structures for the work setting and procedures which make the most of employee knowledge, competencies, dedication and flexibility. The conception of high-performance working assimilates practices that facilitate and encourage them to make the most of this greater empowerment. Furthermore, it affords the employees with a change to taking part in significant decisions, motivates the development and advancement of worker competencies and provides them with incentives to engage in making decisions. High Performance Culture Definition Culture determines the manner in which an organization conducts its operations on… Continue Reading...

Company Progressive Discipline Policy

and best practices in human resource management. Procedure Step 1 – Verbal Warning A manager, supervisor or human resource professional will issue a verbal warning to an employee privately in case of violation of company policy or in the event of an undesirable behavior/action in the workplace (Workable, 2017). When providing the warning, the employee will also be provided with necessary coaching or advice regarding the company’s progressive discipline steps. A written documentation will then be created by the supervisor within five working days of the verbal warning, which will then be signed by… Continue Reading...

HRM Leader

Sally is a proficient and experienced Human Resource Management (HRM) leader at ABC Bank. In the contemporary, Sally feels overwhelmed owing to the recent acquisition of the Local Bank by ABC Bank. There are various key aspects that present a HRM challenge for Sally. To begin with, the workforce at the new branch comprises of 40% of older workers that possess knowledge and wisdom. However, there is a need to instigate new technologies to provide additional consumer convenience and therefore a decision as to be made whether the current set of workers should be laid off… Continue Reading...

Factors Affecting Employee Retention in an Organization

crucial component of organizational success and has significant implications for personnel and human resource management as well as organizational behavior. A descriptive research design was utilized to conduct this study through a Likert scale survey instrument comprising of seventeen questions. The survey was administered to a group of participants from three military-affiliated organizations. The survey found that various factors impact organization’s ability to retain its employees including organizational culture, gender roles within the company, family conflict. However, female employees are more affected because of family and children issues such as sick children and daycare problems. Keywords: employee, organization, retention, company, work, absenteeism,… Continue Reading...

The Formation of Virtual Teams

mutual respect, and mutual empowerment. Purpose statement This study stands out to be significant and relevant to the businesses and human resource management departments in the contemporary business environment. The study will look into the in depth understanding of EI, the various measures of… Continue Reading...

sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Human Resource Management" (2004, November 13) Retrieved May 6, 2025, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/human-resource-management-59254

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Human Resource Management" 13 November 2004. Web.6 May. 2025. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/human-resource-management-59254>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Human Resource Management", 13 November 2004, Accessed.6 May. 2025,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/human-resource-management-59254