Immigration Laws Essay

Total Length: 1012 words ( 3 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 3

Page 1 of 3

Logical Flaws Analysis: Immigration Laws and Policies

As has been seen in the recent debate regarding the issue of the separation of children of immigrants from their parents at the border, immigration is a fraught issue in America. America is a nation built, in part, upon immigration. Many individuals who have immigrated to America illegally form the backbone of a number of industries in the US, spanning from the restaurant industry to the landscaping and gardening industry as well as domestic service. Yet there have been repeated calls to curtail illegal immigration, making immigration reform policies very difficult to pass. One approach which has been adopted by the previous Obama Administration, in the face of Congress’ unwillingness to pass meaningful immigration reform, is “prosecutorial discretion,” according to Delahunty& Yoo (2013), which means selective enforcement of the law.

Delahunty& Yoo (2013) use the Obama Administration’s attitude towards immigration as a greater example of what the authors see as the Democratic administration’s hypocrisy in regards to executive overreach. The article “The Obama Administration’s Nonenforcement of Immigration Laws, the DREAM Act, and the Take Care Clause” from the Texas Law Review makes an extended argument by analogy, suggesting that Obama’s criticism of the Bush Administration for, among other acts, the Iraq War, was self-serving given that Obama did not enforce laws he disagreed with, such as the removal provisions of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA).

Argument by analogy is one of the most common techniques used in persuasion. It is, however, a very problematic one, given that there are seldom perfectly analogous situations in historical fact, in contrast to analogies made between words. Even if there are superficial similarities between the historical circumstances being analogically compared, that does not mean the most relevant and salient aspects of the analogy are valid. For example, in the case of the Obama versus Bush analogy, President Bush was later found to have misrepresented key aspects of intelligence to the US Congress, such as the existence of weapons of mass destruction, to encourage it to enter into a military conflict with Iraq. In the case of the Obama Administration, there was no fundamental misrepresentation of its failure to or concealment of its enforcement of aspects of the law.

Delahunty & Yoo (2013) accuse the former Administration of embarking upon an open borders policy, stating that “if a President can refuse to enforce a federal law against a class of 800,000 to 1.
76 million individuals, what discernible limits are there to prosecutorial discretion” (p.2). As well as making a false analogy, however, this also seems excessively hyperbolic. The Obama Administration did not forgo the enforcement of all reasonable immigration policy, as this sweeping claim seems to suggest but rather had argued that specific types of immigrants who had come into the country illegally might be worthy of certain protections. According to the nonpartisan Anti-Defamation League, an organization dedicated to fighting bias against Jewish people and other marginalized groups, “the DREAM Act (short for Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors Act) was a bill in Congress that would have granted legal status to certain undocumented immigrants who were brought to the United States as children and went to school here” (“What is the DREAM Act,” 2018).

In other words, the Act which the authors accuse President Obama of enforcing in actual fact, even if Congress did not enact a formal policy change, was not designed to improve the fact of all immigrant groups, but those who had been brought to the United States as young children. Many Dreamers might not even be….....

Show More ⇣


     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


Related Essays

Immigration in the United Kingdom

people living in the UK were given the right to stay. However, in recent years, immigration laws have become more restrictive, and it is now estimated that nearly 50,000 long-term residents in the UK are at risk of being deported—many of them elderly. This is particularly problematic for the Windrush Generation, as “many of the Windrush generation had arrived as children on their parents' passports. And although they have lived in Britain for many decades—paying taxes and insurance—they never formally became British citizens.” This paper will discuss the issue of the Windrush Generation from a historical and contemporary vantage point to show what happened and… Continue Reading...

Implementing Compassionate Immigration Reform

Identifying Optimal Immigration Policies In 1870, the United States had a population of about 39 million people with virtually no immigration laws in place (U.S. historic population, 2017). In fact, it was not until several individual states began passing various types of immigration laws after the Civil War that the federal government enacted any limitations on immigration to the United States at all (Early American immigration policies, 2017). Although the situation in America is far different today, these early immigration policies were based on the same exclusionary issues that they are today. For instance, the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 and Alien Contract Labor laws of 1885 and 1887 were… Continue Reading...

Latinos and Deportation Arrests

security? That is the question posed by the AP (2018)—and while enforcing immigration laws is certainly within the scope of ICE and its mandate, the worry that some communities have is that this crackdown on illegal immigration will upset a carefully crafted balance between whites and Latinos, one that has taken years to develop. In America, race is always an issue and one that many people seek to overcome in order to promote concepts of equality and fraternity. At the same time, the agenda of the Trump Administration is nothing new, as Hernandez (2008) shows: “as a critical enforcement practice within the… Continue Reading...

Strategies to Improve Collaboration and Cooperation Between the Homeland Security Agencies

offers resources and materials detailing information against human trafficking, private sector, NGOs, concerned citizens, and officers involved in law enforcement (DHS, 2018). DHS also deals with immigration laws enforcement during the facilitation and streamlining of the legal process of immigration. In many ways the DHS has reformed the enforcement of immigration. The priority has been the elimination and identification of aliens posing danger to the safety of the public. Some employers bleach the immigration laws knowingly (DHS, 2018). DHS also targets such unethical employers. The immigration department The U.S. ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement) aims at protecting Americans from illegal immigration and crimes across the border as well as from anything that might compromise the safety… Continue Reading...

Human Trafficking Essay

immigration laws, and to criminalize or otherwise punish the very people who anti-trafficking advocates purport to protect.” Notwithstanding the social assistance that prostitutes receive in the process, the fact remains that their primary source of income is disrupted when law enforcement authorities crack down on prostitution. Indeed, Brock points out that, “Much of what is pursued in the name of a war on trafficking has troubling consequences for poor people around the world. Women are of course disproportionally represented among the poor.” The other school of thought concerning prostitution maintains… Continue Reading...

Muslims As an Ethnicity in the United States

many Muslim Americans mobilizing in the face of bias and anti-Muslim immigration laws. Prior to 9/11 Muslim American communities had been targeted by authorities -- especially in the 1960s and 1970s when Muslim American leader like Malcolm X was assassinated, followed later by the assassination of Black Panther leader Fred Hampton. Mohammed Ali was targeted for his refusal to fight in Vietnam as well as for his outspoken criticism of the cultural and political Establishment in America. These individuals inspired the next generation of Muslim Americans led by such diverse men as Louis Farrakhan to Chuck D. of Public Enemy (Turner,… Continue Reading...

sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Immigration Laws" (2018, June 24) Retrieved May 12, 2024, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/immigration-laws-2169894

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Immigration Laws" 24 June 2018. Web.12 May. 2024. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/immigration-laws-2169894>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Immigration Laws", 24 June 2018, Accessed.12 May. 2024,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/immigration-laws-2169894