Meaning of Life Term Paper

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document

Total Length: 1661 words ( 6 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 5

Page 1 of 6

strong issue with the ideas of David Benatar and James Lenman (1997), which I regard as simply absurd, or more likely a case of academics striking a pose and writing in a sarcastic and cynical manner in hopes of getting a rise out of their readers. If the latter is true, they certainly succeeded with me, since I cannot accept the notion that non-existence is always preferable to existence or that it does not matter if the human species becomes extinct. In fact, I assert that such theories run contrary to the basic survival instinct and self-regard that most humans have, even under conditions of extreme suffering and brutality. For whatever reasons, even in the worst situations, something in the human species drives its powerful desire to survive. People may not always be loving and humane with themselves or others, but most of them do have a strong sense of self-interest, which is usually not compatible with death except perhaps in some cases of great suffering, illness or disability. In addition, I claim that the future of humanity may well be an improvement over the present, and that science may even eliminate old age, death and illness and our species gradually takes control over its own evolution and becomes a space-faring civilization.

David Benatar claims that non-existence is preferable to being born, since pain, suffering and death are inevitable for every person who lives, but those who never existed will have no experience of these. All life is full of suffering and hardship, so "being brought into existence is not a benefit but always a harm" (Benatar, 2004, p. 155). This is especially true for the majority of people in the world who live in poverty, experiencing wars, genocide, epidemics and famine. Using the famous utilitarian calculus and cost/benefit analysis, the absence of pain is always good but the absence of pleasure is not always bad unless someone who exists is deprived of it. Those who never existed are deprived of nothing for they are nothing. Non-existence is never bad, but there is always something bad about existence, simply because of the prospect of death at the end. A positive utilitarian would also say that "there is a duty not to bring suffering people into existence," and if pain is unavoidable then no one should have children (Benatar, p. 157). From the negative utilitarian viewpoint, however, the only duty is not doing harm without any guarantee of bringing happiness, nor would such a guarantee even be possible.

In the past, most people had children because they were ignorant of birth control or regarded their offspring as economically useful, but parents in modern society have more free choice. Their motives are still self-centered, such as creating heirs or passing on their DNA, and they "do not regret having brought into existence a child with an unhappy life" (Benatar, p. 158). Of course, parents have no way of knowing in advance whether their children will be unhappy or to what degree, and a positive utilitarian would affirm that even an unhappy child can still be useful just by bringing pleasure to others. For Bentar, though, because of the inevitability of pain and death "there can be no duty to bring people into existence" (Benatar, p. 164). Carrying this argument to its 'logical' conclusion, "it would be preferable for our species to die out," thus eliminating suffering forever, not to mention philosophy (Benatar, p. 167). An alien from an advanced civilization would look down on this world as a relatively backward place, full of misery and pain even for those who consider themselves healthy and happy.

James Lenman argues that death is always viewed as bad, for both individuals and species, especially if it occurs prematurely. Nevertheless, the ultimate extinction of humanity in a million years from now might not be an evil in any objective sense, although if it happened tomorrow the present generation would definitely regard it as such. Death at age twenty-five or twelve "is of a different order from the tragedy of not living to be five hundred" and is not tragic at all for elderly persons whose quality of life is "irrevocably bad" (Lenman, 2004, p. 136).

Stuck Writing Your "Meaning of Life" Term Paper?

View All Our Example Meaning of Life Term Paper

Have A Custom Example Essay Written

All species will die out just as the dinosaurs and saber-tooth tiger did, as will humans unless they discover some scientific or technological means in the future to overcome death and the aging process. Humanity may be wiped out in a sudden catastrophe or become gradually extinct, and in either case the harm would be great for the people concerned. Lenman also rules out all religious and philosophical theories about life having intrinsic value, leaving only theories of rational calculation and utility. He also makes the incorrect assumption that few people today "have some large philosophical vision of human history," since for good or ill there are obviously billions who do, even if they view the end of the world in apocalyptic terms (Lenman, p. 142). Nor is Lenman convinced that the human species is going to make progress in the future, and in any case only a few great minds are really on the cutting edge of science, technology and culture. To us, it does matter "that we have a posterity" or that our species becomes extinct, but we have no such kind regard for generations that will only exist long after our deaths (Lenman, p. 148).

My first thought was that these writers were simply crackpots, while my second thought was to wonder how they got the idea that life was supposed to be easy or free from pain and suffering. Perhaps it really is for some people, but I have never encountered them. If they did indeed have pain-free lives then they must have been completely insulated from the realities of existence in this world. For the most part, people have managed to endure these, perhaps because their expectations are not so high or their religious faith or sense of duty comforts them. These absurd theories lead to a kind of nihilist dead-end in which nothingness is preferable to existence, even though nothingness is simply a vacuum or an absence of being, intelligence, life and purpose -- a black hole from which even light cannot escape. If this could actually be considered a positive good rather than an evil makes nonsense out of these terms.

Even people who are seriously ill or disabled do not always choose suicide over continued existence, which is even true of these in extremely miserable conditions like prisons, battlefields or concentration camps. Indeed, human beings will often take heroic, extreme or ruthless measures to ensure their own survival and that of their families and loved ones. We share this survival instinct with other animals, and also have a self-regard that often "prompts us to 'stick to life', to try hard to stay alive for better or worse, to resist and fight back against whatever may threaten the premature or abrupt termination of life" (Bauman, 2003, p. 79). Among the survivors of the Nazi camps, for example, where conditions were as terrible as the most sadistic human minds could devise, and entire literature exists on how prisoners managed to stay alive and even fight back against a system whose only purpose was their degradation and destruction. From the time he was arrested in 1938 and sent to Dachau and Buchenwald, Bruno Bettleheim wondered how the prisoners "could endure so much without committing suicide" (Pollak, 1997, p. 62). Some did, of course, while others became merely apathetic, indifferent or infantilized, no longer caring whether they lived or died.

Bettleheim did what was necessary to survive, though, bribing the S.S, guards to obtain more food and better working conditions, manipulating the system in any way he could, and using his connections in Britain and….....

Show More ⇣

     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


Related Essays

The Meaning of Life

Life A number of literary, philosophical, psychological, religious and other writers are of the view that the subject of 'the meaning of life' forms one among the most central issues experienced by people. Tolstoy (Rowlands) claims that science is unable to provide assistance in this regard. While it can describe what life is, it is incapable of describing its meaning. It is able to explain the things in this world and what's possible; however, it is unable to explain their meaning and importance. Tolstoy states that faith provides an answer to this question. Hence, he asserts that irrespective of the answers provided by faith, it accords the finiteness of humanity's… Continue Reading...

Death and Meaning of Life in Tuesdays with Morrie

found in accepting life for what it is rather than wishing it could be something else. The meaning of life can therefore be best understood by appreciating what we have now instead of wishing we were different or that things were different. Second, and following from this, the meaning of life is located in the small details, things we can frequently overlook -- finding beauty and joy in every day, even on bad days and in situations that are painful or uncomfortable. Meaning is especially found in friendship, caring for others, and love. Letting go of selfishness and embracing acceptance, one can discover the meaning of life.… Continue Reading...

Life's Meaning Defined by Viktor Frankl

62). Frankl mainly refers to the "super-meaning" or to the ultimate meaning of life from a general existential or cosmological perspective -- not the personalized meaning in one individual's purpose in life, which is a different question (p. 74). A state of meaninglessness is the inability to move forward and progress through pain, not just in spite of pain and suffering but because of it. Meaningless is a "feeling of emptiness," and an "existential vacuum," (p. 143). Meaninglessness is the inability to learn from suffering, and thereby transform suffering into something that is meaningful. According to Frankl, meaningfulness cannot be located… Continue Reading...

Important Historical Documents of Independence

meaning of life might be. In these lines from “An Essay on Man,” Pope urges greater humility with regards to the human position. Human beings might not actually have the capacity to ever understand the meaning of life, or why evil exists. “One truth is clear,” claims the speaker: “whatever is right, is right.” In other words, if something exists, it exists for a reason and that reason might be far bigger than the human being can understand at this point in time. Pope urges acceptance and a willingness to… Continue Reading...

Assessment Process

Referrals for Client Instances of grief are commonly associated with regret, guilt, anger; among other similar symptoms. While some people can't make meaning of life, others experience a feeling of relief. Grieving individuals can oscillate between different contradicting thoughts as they try to make sense of their loss. A client may be sent to the health providers listed below for management of their condition: Psychiatrist: for the management of chronic and severe issues. A psychiatrist can review a case and prescribe medication. They can also diagnose a patient and manage other complications that are co-occurring. Clinical Psychologist: Psychologists have the skills to assist a client to lead a normal functional life in… Continue Reading...

sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Meaning Of Life" (2011, July 14) Retrieved May 4, 2024, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/meaning-life-118070

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Meaning Of Life" 14 July 2011. Web.4 May. 2024. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/meaning-life-118070>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Meaning Of Life", 14 July 2011, Accessed.4 May. 2024,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/meaning-life-118070
   

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document
order custom essay example