Moral Reasoning Essay

Total Length: 719 words ( 2 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 2

Page 1 of 2

Cultural Differences

Moral Reasoning

Moral reasoning: An intercultural comparison

Until recently, many Western developmental theorists tended to see morality as a transcultural phenomenon, reflecting their belief that all cultures shared certain common moral assumptions. Both Piaget and Kohlberg stressed that moral development passes through a series of stages, just like the child's ability to understand other complex subjects like mass and volume (Jensen 2008; Sunac n.d). However, this tends to assume that the individual is the primary moral decision-making unit and reflects an individualistic bias. American culture is defined by certain assumptions, such as the importance of individualism and material advancement, which are not necessarily shared by all cultures (or indeed all subcultures within America) (Humphries & Jagers 2009: 206). In America, an individual who 'stands up' to a crowd, or who goes against established ideas and makes a profit in the case of an entrepreneur like Steve Jobs or Bill Gates is upheld as a role model. Acting in an asocial fashion is validated; provided the individual translates his success into material terms.

In communitarian and traditional societies, however, this is not the case. In other societies, too much individualism is seen as dangerous and not necessarily useful or good, regardless of whether it profits the individual or results in material gain. When instilling moral ideas in children, American parents often stress the need to be moral for the sake of one's self.
'Even if no one else knows, you will know,' a parent might counsel his or her child. The Judeo-Christian ethic stresses that the individual's soul or self is a gift from God and all souls are equal. American law is a rights-based culture, and these rights are derived from a sense of 'inalienable' rights connected to the individual (Bedford and Hwang 2002: 129)

But within the Confucian ethos dominant in Asian cultures, " one's life is an inheritance from one's ancestors, just as one's children's lives flow from one's own" (Bedford and Hwang 2002: 129). A personal sense of self derives from one's position in the family, and thus something which might seem admirable to a Westerner, such as defying the values one was brought….....

Show More ⇣


     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


Related Essays

Arguments for and Against Physician Assisted Suicide

not all, arguments against physician-assisted suicide are based on moral reasoning. Those that are based on morality refer to the presumed sanctity of life, the belief that “purposefully helping a patient die is categorically wrong under any circumstances,”and the corollary that the role of the physician or healthcare worker is as healer (Quill & Sussman, 2018). A physician who believes that the ultimate objective of the profession is to preserve life will therefore believe that physician-assisted death is wrong and would instead ask that the patient use other methods to alleviate suffering. For example, Appelbaum (2016) claims that physicians… Continue Reading...

Business Ethics Practices Compliance Auditing

into account is one way organizations can shift their moral reasoning to better reflect the mission, vision, and values purportedly embedded in the company’s ethical code (Mason & Simmons, 2013). Corporate social responsibility and environmental responsibility are both becoming strategic business practices that improve relationships with stakeholders by demonstrating respect. Research shows how businesses demonstrating openness to change, flexibility and adaptability, and an ongoing commitment to innovation are in a position uniquely situated to promote environmental sustainability at all levels of business practice (Pedersen, Gwordz & Hvass, 2016). Stakeholders may also respond to ethical decisions by altering their own… Continue Reading...

Cognitive and Behavioral Development of an Adolescent

in their lives. Piaget proposed a theory of development where moral reasoning for children develops from what he calls a naive understanding of morality. This naive understanding is usually based on behavior and outcomes. However, as they develop, they can have a more advanced understanding that is based on intentions. This means that Riley is using his independence in the wrong way. The identity crisis as described in the theories of development is a serious issue that he is facing. As a football player, he interacts with the other adolescents and conforms to some of the activities that they undertake,… Continue Reading...

sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Moral Reasoning" (2013, January 07) Retrieved May 6, 2025, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/moral-reasoning-104816

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Moral Reasoning" 07 January 2013. Web.6 May. 2025. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/moral-reasoning-104816>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Moral Reasoning", 07 January 2013, Accessed.6 May. 2025,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/moral-reasoning-104816