Nation States Descriptions Are States Still Relevant? Essay

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document

Total Length: 1309 words ( 4 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 3

Page 1 of 4

Nation States

Descriptions

Are states still relevant?

Realist, cooperative, liberal and critical theories of international relations

The realist theory of international politics views states as 'black box' actors. The possibly competing interests of citizens and bureaucrats within the state are ignored. Realism holds that "at its most fundamental level, the national interest is generic and easy to define: all states seek to preserve their political autonomy and their territorial integrity. Once these two interests have been secured, however, national interests may take different forms. Some states may have an interest in securing more resources or land; other states may wish to expand their own political or economic systems into other areas; some states may merely wish to be left alone" (Ferraro 2011). Another synonym for realism is 'rationalism.' States are assumed to be able to rationally pursue their own interests in the international community.

Of course, realists understand that the world does not always behave according to rational notions of behavior. Rather, realists contend that given the multiplicity of influences upon state behavior, focusing upon self-interest is the only really viable way to predict or understand how states act in a meaningful fashion. Only by studying externally observed facts can conclusions be reached, the rest is surmise. However, critics contend that the virtue of the philosophy is also its deficit: it is overly simplistic in explaining state behavior, and the influence of non-states upon the international community. It also tends to over-emphasize the virtues of having states as the main international 'unit' of interaction. Because of the demand for observable behavior as a mode of realist analysis, its theorists focus on formally-recognized states.

Without states, realists believe the world is an anarchical environment. "All states have to rely upon their own resources to secure their interests, enforce whatever agreements they may have entered into with other states, or to maintain a desirable domestic and international order. There is no authority over the nation-state, nor, for the realist, should there be" (Ferraro 2011).

Stuck Writing Your "Nation States Descriptions Are States Still Relevant?" Essay?

View All Our Example Nation States Descriptions Are States Still Relevant? Essay

Have A Custom Example Essay Written

According to realists, although irrationality may exist in the world, they "seek to paint a picture of foreign policy which presents the rational essence to be found in experience, without the contingent deviations from rationality which are also found in experience" (Morgenthau 2011). The world must be examined by state units, without 'contingent' irrational forces.

Realist philosophies can, in general, be divided into two camps -- realist and neorealist. Classical realists believed that because of the inherent aggressiveness of states, and their 'rational' search to be the most powerful entity on the map, it was best to have a balance of power amongst competing state units. Classical realists like Hans Morgenthau looked with nostalgia back on pre-World War I Europe, where power was 'balanced' between united state actors. In contrast, neo-realists like Kenneth Waltz believed that because weaker states, in the anarchic state system, tended to tie themselves to stronger states, as during the Cold War, this idea of multipolarity was effectively a fiction, and bipolarity was both more stable and inevitable (Walt 1998).

In contrast, cooperative or constructivist political theory views cooperation between state actors as possible, if mutual interests can be fostered. These theorists state that "economic interdependence would discourage states from using force against each other because warfare would threaten each side's prosperity" (Walt 1998). A good example of this philosophy can be seen in Thomas Friedman's idea that 'the world is flat,' or that the sharing of information and global interdependence creates enough common ground to encourage states to put old rivalries to the side. Cooperative theories stress the ability of international agencies to facilitate collaboration. The "theory argued that international institutions such as the International Energy Agency and the International Monetary Fund could help overcome selfish state behavior, mainly by encouraging states to forego immediate gains for the greater benefits of enduring cooperation" (Walt 1998). Another form of cooperative theory is institutionalism, or the idea that institutions,….....

Show More ⇣

     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Nation States Descriptions Are States Still Relevant " (2011, December 14) Retrieved May 7, 2024, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/nation-states-descriptions-states-still-85362

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Nation States Descriptions Are States Still Relevant " 14 December 2011. Web.7 May. 2024. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/nation-states-descriptions-states-still-85362>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Nation States Descriptions Are States Still Relevant ", 14 December 2011, Accessed.7 May. 2024,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/nation-states-descriptions-states-still-85362
   

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document
order custom essay example