New Deal Essay

Total Length: 1358 words ( 5 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 3

Page 1 of 5

New Deal

Politically-motived objections to President Roosevelt's "New Deal" would long outlive FDR himself. In 2003, when Nobel Prize-winning economist Paul Krugman was looking for a term to describe the ideologically-driven motivations of President George W. Bush and his administration, the phrase he selected was "the great unraveling" -- Krugman's image saw Roosevelt's New Deal programs (above all Social Security) as having become the very fabric of the society in which we live, and the simpleminded libertarianism of the GOP attitude toward the social programs of the New Deal was a mistaken . Yet I think it would be easiest to answer the question of whether Republicans' libertarian objections to the New Deal are genuinely based on the New Deal's curtailment of actual liberty. I hope an examination of campaign speeches by both FDR and Roosevelt from the 1932 Presidential election will elucidate the relationship between individual freedom and the government that would be offered by the New Deal.

Certainly it was a form of libertarian ideology on Herbert Hoover's part that marked his unwillingness to invervene effectively in the wake of the Great Depression. One of the tremendous ironies of Hoover's long life (he would outlive JFK) and ideological career is that before his Presidency, when he was merely a private citizen and charitably-motivated Quaker in the wake of Europe's devastation during World War I, he was widely credited with having saved all of Europe from starvation after the Armistice: that, more than anything else, made Hoover's willingness to preside over starvation in the United States all the more outrageous in the eyes of the public. Yet Hoover objected to the social welfare programs of the New Deal more or less on principle. As he would say in his 1932 campaign speech,

This question is the basis upon which our opponents are appealing to the people in their fears and distress. They are proposing changes and so-called new deals which would destroy the very foundations of our American system. Our people should consider the primary facts before they come to the judgment -- not merely through political agitation, the glitter of promise, and the discouragement of temporary hardships -- whether they will support changes which radically affect the whole system which has been builded up by 150 years of the toil of our fathers.


From Hoover's perspective, the laissez-faire capitalism which had turned the U.S. Senate into a "billionaire boys' club" by the end of the nineteenth century, and was deemed to be sufficiently exploitative for Alexander Berkman to fire a bullet into the skull of Henry Clay Frick, was somehow the necessary essence of the American system. As Hoover put it:

It is founded on the conception that only through ordered liberty, through freedom to the individual, and equal opportunity to the individual will his initiative and enterprise be summoned to spur the march of progress…It is by the maintenance of equality of opportunity and therefore of a society absolutely fluid in freedom of the movement of its human particles that our individualism departs from the individualism of Europe. We resent class distinction because there can be no rise for the individual through the frozen strata of classes, and no stratification of classes can take place in a mass livened by the free rise of its particles. Thus in our ideals the able and ambitious are able to rise constantly from the bottom to leadership in the community.

Hoover's surreal rebuke to Marxist analysis here -- which swallows the myth of a class-free America whole -- surely could not have persuaded many Americans in 1932. The only way whereby Hoover could have employed this rhetoric with a straight-face is if he himself believed it, which indeed he did: Hoover's training as a mining engineer and his vast global success in the period immediately preceeding World War I had persuaded him of the reality of the American Dream (or day-dream) that he prefers to the New Deal.

But to compound the ironies of the 1932 campaign, Franklin Delano Roosevelt was precisely the opposite from Hoover: he was the….....

Show More ⇣


     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


Related Essays

President Roosevelt New Deal Era

FDR’s Approach President Roosevelt took a proactive approach to the Great Depression, immediately proposing the New Deal programs as practical steps towards rebuilding the nation’s economy. When he was elected, Roosevelt also demonstrated understanding of the need for emotional messages to help the American people remain calm and confident. For example, one of FDR’s most famous quotes was delivered in his inaugural address: “the only thing we have to fear is fear itself.” Roosevelt capitalized on the power of the radio to deliver his message of hope and inspiration to the American public. Starting in 1933, Roosevelt delivered the “Fireside Chats,” which informed the public… Continue Reading...

American History During Early 20th Century

The progressive era in American political culture set the stage for President Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal. Starting in the 1890s, the Progressive Era drew upon Marxist theory of labor exploitation to help balance unbridled capitalist growth during the Gilded Age of industrial development. Progressivism welcomed social and technological progress both by suggesting reforms in both government and business to reduce corruption and ensure a higher quality of life for all Americans. Two of the progressive political party movements during the turn of the century included the Populist Party and the Bull Moose Party. Progressive values then later became embedded in the platform of the… Continue Reading...

History of Government Intervention in Tobacco Markets

Tobacco industry has seen significant government intervention since at least the New Deal. Tobacco farmers have typically received subsidies for their crops and the benefits of marijuana prohibition but in more decent decades they have also faced increasingly strict controls on the sale of tobacco products. Prior to the era of restrictive cigarette sales, and buoyed by subsidies, tobacco was one of the more lucrative products to farm in the United States, a situation that has changed of late. The most recent move on the part of the government was the Transitional Tobacco Payment Program, which as the name implies was… Continue Reading...

To Kill a Mockingbird Essay

government. Jim Crow senators and representatives ensured that racial restrictions and inequalities limited ever important government program established during the Great Depression, from the New Deal job programs to Social Security to the minimum wage legislation of 1938. Social security excluded coverage for every category of employment in which African Americans made up a significant part of the U.S. workforce. (Tischauser 84-85) Jim Crow laws gained ground during this time and many lynchings took place harking back to the red summer of 1919. Into the early twentieth century, lynchings continued to average two to three a week with marked increases during the Red Summer race riots of 1919 and during the Great Depression. (Kirchmeier… Continue Reading...

Affordable Care Act and Marijuana

protection they had which was established and improved by the New Deal as well as the Great Society. The House of Congress agreed to allow certain states have a significant level of command on the way federal programs such as Medicaid were implemented on the condition that it would be free to set up and enlarge its planned national entitlement schemes (Brown-Nagin, 2013). A huge disagreement in the beliefs of federalism has been bared for all via the suits contesting the Obamacare mandate. A school of thought believes that the government should get involved even constitutionally in situations when certain… Continue Reading...

A Brief History of Medicare and Medicaid

President T. Roosevelt was among the pioneers in making the health insurance issue a campaign matter. The Second New Deal crafted by President Roosevelt involved including the Social Security program in the laws (Piatak, 2015). The act tried to reduce the extent to which such factors as poverty, old age, widowhood and children without known fathers were seen as dangers. The New Deal had a chunk of its content expunged by the Supreme Court because they were either seen as unconstitutional or simply not within the jurisdiction of the federal government. Some of the acts such as the National Industrial Recovery Act and the Agricultural Adjustment Act were ordered… Continue Reading...

Marbury V Madison Impact

The claims had also started in the second half of the 1800s and further developed during the 1930's New Deal jurisprudence. During the 1960s and 70s, the authority of the Supreme Court under the two Chief Justices, Warren Burger and Earl Warren, became more clear, contentious and had more global influence. Be the time it… Continue Reading...

sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"New Deal" (2011, April 06) Retrieved May 18, 2024, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/new-deal-120152

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"New Deal" 06 April 2011. Web.18 May. 2024. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/new-deal-120152>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"New Deal", 06 April 2011, Accessed.18 May. 2024,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/new-deal-120152