One Person's View on the Ethics in Financial Management Term Paper

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document

Total Length: 3466 words ( 12 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 1+

Page 1 of 12

conflict of interest is at the core of nearly every ethical dilemma. A conflict of interest, simply put, is a situation in which the decision maker has two or more competing interests. Market timing, late trading, insider trading, illegal trading, fraud, partial disclosure, non-disclosure...the manifestation of conflicts of interest is seemingly endless. The business landscape today is a minefield of ethical disasters, some of which have already occurred, some of which wait quietly in the shadows to erupt into scandal.

In the summer of 2002, when Congress was attempting to decide how to clean up the shady financial practices of Corporate America, mutual fund company lobbyists convinced lawmakers to exempt their area of the financial services industry. As of September 2003, when the Attorney General for New York State, Eliot Spitzer, revealed his "stunning" charges of illegal trading in mutual funds, this industry has occupied center stage in the spotlight being shone on ethical problems in financial management.

There are a number of important ethical issues which have been ignored by mutual fund managers and their firms; these are issues that are of great concern to investors, and now legislators and regulators as well. The main areas of concern, which are addressed in detail in this paper, include conflicts of interest, director independence and transparency of fee and expense reporting. Investors are more and more likely to vote their conscience with their wallets. To accomplish that requires a clear understanding of all the issues. To acquire a clear understanding of all the issues requires shining the light much more brightly on the areas outlined in this paper.

One Person's View on the Ethics in Financial Management conflict of interest is at the core of nearly every ethical dilemma. A conflict of interest, simply put, is a situation in which the decision maker has two or more competing interests (Davis, 2003). Market timing, late trading, insider trading, illegal trading, fraud, partial disclosure, non-disclosure...the manifestation of conflicts of interest is seemingly endless. The business landscape today is a minefield of ethical disasters, some of which have already occurred, some of which wait quietly in the shadows to erupt into scandal. Clearly, something more than the conventional approach to ethics is needed. Enron failed to benefit from its own 64-page ethics code or an audit committee that included both the retired dean of a business school and the former chair of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (Davis, 2003). What was missing was a policy requiring board members to raise ethical issues whenever they had questions and to request the advice of independent third parties. Ethics is much more than simply obeying the law (Davis, 2003). An action can be technically legal, yet unethical. Lord Moulton, a 19th century English jurist, when asked to sum up the relationship between law and ethics, said ethics is "obedience to the unenforceable."

Laws grow out of the ethical convictions of the people who make and enact them. The very essence of human civilization has resulted from the combined experiences of mankind over the millennia, in which various laws have been recognized as being ethical and appropriate. According to Davis, the history of jurisprudence acknowledges a common law of this sort, established in social practices rooted in a dim and distant past but still significant enough to be a guide for positive law. However, because of the enormous cultural changes taking place in the world today, it becomes increasingly difficult to apply this ethical framework to new moral situations. Certainly ethical standards evolve over the ages, from one generation to the next and sometimes within the same generation. Therefore, as opposed to being an extension of the law, ethics is the law's very foundation (Davis, 2003). Ethical decisions have the power to change behavior, despite not being legally enforceable. Ethical behavior often exacts a high price.

The beginning of the 21st century is a skeptical time. The public's ability to trust is difficult to maintain with a pervasive and uncomfortable feelings that government leaders have been deceptive. Newspapers have apologized for misleading readers. Major corporations have filed false financial statements. Members of the clergy have abused parishioners. To preserve trust, business leaders and politicians must take the initiative to demonstrate a commitment to ethical behavior (Davis, 2003).

Nowhere is this clearer today than in the field of financial management. In the summer of 2002, when Congress was attempting to decide how to clean up the shady financial practices of corporate America, mutual fund company lobbyists convinced lawmakers to exempt their area of the financial services industry.

Stuck Writing Your "One Person's View on the Ethics in Financial Management" Term Paper?

View All Our Example One Person's View on the Ethics in Financial Management Term Paper

Have A Custom Example Essay Written

The funds' six decades of apparent scandal-free operation lulled Congress into obliging them, excusing funds from the more onerous provisions of the Sarbanes-Oxley corporate reform law; however, as of September 2003, when the Attorney General for New York State, Eliot Spitzer, revealed his "stunning" charges of illegal trading in mutual funds, this industry has occupied center stage in the spotlight being shone on ethical problems in financial management (Borrus & Dwyer, 2003).

Hard on the heels of this spreading scandal, the Congressional hammer is coming down. The legislative, regulatory and market reforms that are in the works could add up to an overhaul as large as that of Sarbanes-Oxley, with an even more immediate impact on American investors.

For now, it is the state treasurers, pension fund trustees and 401(k) plan managers, with billions invested with fund companies, who are doing the most to shake up the industry (Borrus & Dwyer, 2003). Further, Congress is steaming ahead with the SEC racing Congress to the finish line. Each of these groups is acting for the benefit of the people who have invested over $7 trillion dollars in mutual fund assets.

The SEC is considering new rules to halt market-timing and other trading abuses. Between them, the SEC and Congress are also addressing measures to strengthen fund boards, to give fund investors better information about portfolio holdings, to require portfolio managers to reveal their own trades in fund (Borrus & Dwyer, 2003), to require disclosure on a semi-annual basis of "dollars-and-cents" amounts of fees and expenses that investors pay, to prohibit funds from using brokerage commissions to pay broker-dealers for selling fund shares, to prohibit individual fund managers from overseeing hedge funds, and finally, to require investment advisors to adopt and vigorously enforce codes of ethics for their employees (Hume, 2004).

There are a number of important ethical issues which have been ignored by mutual fund managers and their firms, issues that are of great concern to investors, and now legislators and regulators, as well. All of them should and must be addressed. Some new behaviors will be mandated by the new rules, some by the firms themselves and some things will only change as a result of investors being better educated and demanding greater disclosure by mutual fund firms and simply not investing in those that will not provide appropriate information.

The main areas of concern, which are addressed in detail in the following pages, include conflicts of interest, director independence (which also includes obvious conflicts of interest) and transparency of fee and expense reporting.

Conflicts of Interest

The critical conflicts of interest encompass a broad range of issues within the mutual fund industry. In order for investors to be fully informed, and therefore, able to truly understand performance of their investments, the following information should be analyzed:

Are the firm's funds closed to new investors at some set investment level? While taking in unlimited amounts of investment will raise the fund manager's fee income, it will often be detrimental to the performance of funs focusing on less liquid markets, such as junk bonds, foreign stocks or small stocks (Zweig, 2004). Closing a fund to new investment most often improves returns for the existing investors. By putting uninterrupted growth of fees ahead of the health of investor returns, firms who do not close their funds engage in a clear conflict of interest.

Does the management firm include hedge funds in its portfolio? Of major concern is the practice of allowing market timers - speculators - into a fund in exchange for deposits into hedge funds that the firm also manages. Hedge funds create a clear conflict of interest, by speculating with borrowed money and charging high fees. If a money manager comes up with a good investment idea, the temptation is to put it into their hedge fund, where it can earn a higher return (due to being able to buy on margin) and a much larger fee (Zweig, 2004). Some firms claim to minimize this conflict by not allowing the same people to run a basic mutual fund and a hedge fund. Whether this is enough to prevent the practice is questionable, but at least it is a start.

Does the firm utilize fair-value pricing to discourage market timing and forbid late (after hours) trading? Few mutual fund firms have taken any steps to curb trading abuses. Nearly all mutual fund firms say they could use fair-value pricing in non-liquid….....

Show More ⇣

     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"One Person's View On The Ethics In Financial Management" (2004, April 01) Retrieved May 8, 2025, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/one-person-view-ethics-financial-management-166269

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"One Person's View On The Ethics In Financial Management" 01 April 2004. Web.8 May. 2025. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/one-person-view-ethics-financial-management-166269>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"One Person's View On The Ethics In Financial Management", 01 April 2004, Accessed.8 May. 2025,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/one-person-view-ethics-financial-management-166269
   

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document
order custom essay example