Political Philosophy Term Paper

Total Length: 1164 words ( 4 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 1+

Page 1 of 4

tripartite theory of political power? Compare and contrast Plato and Aristotle's political philosophy. According to Professor Dennis Dalton what is "The Break?"

Because of the American tendency to bifurcate conceptions of morality and the soul from political structures, it can be at times difficult to grasp the political philosophy of Plato, whereby the nature of the human soul and Plato's ideal political "Republic" are integrally related. For Plato the human soul was merely the state writ small. Both had the same inherent structure or form. "The just man will not be any different from the just city with respect to the form itself of justice, but will be like it" (The Republic, 435b).

Plato's idea republic or city-state thus has three classes. But every person's soul had a dominant feature. One's role in the state depended upon which quality one's soul possessed in greatest amount. For instance, the leading rulers of the state were known as the guardians. These people were protected by the auxiliaries or militia against the lower 'hands' or levels of the state apparatus in the form the craftsmen and farmers, whom represented the third and lower functions of the soul.

Thus according to Plato, there were three classes of the state because the human soul had three parts, a calculating part, a warlike or angry part (439e-441c) and a desiring or striving part. (437b-439c). The tripartite city corresponded to the tripartite soul (440d-441c). The angry parts or the army controlled the herds of the sheep-like working classes, while the army protected the calculating or ruling parts. (440d). The ability of humanity to go war thus protects the calm and ruling governance head, and controlled the base desires of the grasping hands.

Aristotelian theory in contrast said that the soul was a unified whole but had many parts.
Aristotle agreed that the soul politically structured like a society of person with each part of the soul performing some distinct function. But these functions were numerous. Also, rather than privileging certain classes of human beings, Aristotle was more inclined to stress the organic similarity of the different yet equally necessary functions of the human body, soul, and political body, rather than positing a necessary hierarchy. (Aristotle, On the Soul, 412a5-412a10)

The great break in political philosophy that Dennis Dalton speaks of is not so much between these two philosophers, but Machiavelli's decisive break with classical political philosophy, infusing realism in Plato's idealism and Aristotle's more biological analysis of the political and moral human body.

If Thomas Hobbes, James Madison, Aristotle and Machiavelli were alive today, how do you think they would advise president Bush the current situations of the American occupation of Iraq and the proposed June 30th transition of power to a new Iraqi government council?

Hobbes' world of chaos without a dominant rule of authority would seem to mirror the current political situation in Iraq. However, Hobbes, because of the instability that inevitably occurs with a change of regime, would not have supported the invasion of Iraq in the first place. Hobbes supported a strong chief executive, and chiefly feared not a world under the thumb of a tyrant, but of the potential excesses of republican or legislative governance. Thus, he would suggest that Bush forestall the transition of power and establish a new head of Iraq that would support American self-interest in the region. This was part of George Bush's duty as a leader of America -- to ensure his own stability as a leader….....

Show More ⇣


     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


Related Essays

Justice Ethics and Political Philosophy Rawls

.....ethics cannot avoid claims to universal truths, political philosophy cannot avoid the efficacy of universalism. Relativism is too convenient a response to resolving conflicts of interest and divergent views of governance. However, an alternative to the universalism versus relativism debate lies in Rawl's concept of justice as being the fundamental tenet of a constitutional democracy. Rawls also bases his concept of justice and political philosophy on the underlying importance of consensus (Baier, 1989). Interestingly, consensus implies a utilitarian ethical framework, which Rawls (1985) claims to move away from: "as a practical political matter no general moral conception… Continue Reading...

Political Beliefs Personal Reflection

learn the fundamental foundation of conservative political philosophy. People need to be motivated by a deep inner drive to do good. The government cannot impose a set of morals or values, although the government does exist to prevent me from infringing on your rights or you from infringing on mine in an egregious way. Through his research in economics, Brooks came to the conclusion that free enterprise and capitalism do drive happiness—contrary to what socialists and many more moderate liberals believe. Michael Tanner also understands the principle of… Continue Reading...

Hegel, Heidegger, and Nietzsche on Philosophy

about Reason (literally deified by the Revolution) as well as socio-political philosophy regarding fraternity, equality and liberty. Hegel came to maturity during this era and for him, philosophy consisted of a clash of forces -- and the old world concept of philosophy (the love of knowledge/wisdom) was what Hegel sought to transform in The Phenomenology of Spirit, as he clearly states in the book's Preface: "To help to bring philosophy nearer to the form of science -- that goal where it can lay aside the name of love of knowledge and be actual knowledge -- that is what I have… Continue Reading...

Locke Vs Hume on Consent

consent of their people is probably a dictatorship or something similar [footnoteRef:1]. [1: Tuckness, Alex. 2017. "Locke's Political Philosophy." plato.stanford.edu. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/locke-political/#ConPolOblEndGov.] Hume Hume took a rather different approach to consent. One example is when it comes to where someone calls their residence. Even if the moral significance of a residence area is known to all, there are some cases where it would not be free and voluntary. This is no small thing to many given that direct and free consent is seemingly necessary in a society. Hume, in one of his works, gave the example that a poor peasant or artisan cannot just pick up and move… Continue Reading...

John Stuart Mills On Liberty

Political Philosophy II: Theories of Freedom John Stuart Mill's On Liberty is one of the foundational defenses of liberal, democratic government. According to Mill, there are certain core principles "that should regulate how governments and societies, whether democratic or not, can restrict individual liberties."[footnoteRef:1] Mill wrote that regardless of whether a monarch, dictator, or even a democratic majority governed, the only reason to deprive others of their liberties was what he called the harm principle, namely, that "a harm, an action must be injurious or set back important interests of… Continue Reading...

The Declaration of Independence and Freedom

political philosophy became so important. What gave people their “freedom,” however, was still debated. The nature of freedom in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries was considered a natural right in some cases and a divine right in others. For example, when it was useful, people appealed to the idea of a Creator endowing people with certain “unalienable rights” and when nature was viewed as the source of life, the rights of man were considered something that just was. The Declaration of the Rights of Man and the Citizen shows how… Continue Reading...

How Democracy Leads to Tyranny

Political Philosophy II: Theories of Freedom To answer the questions of why De Tocqueville and Mill think that democracy is a threat to the liberty of the individual and whether they are right, this paper will show that both De Tocqueville and Mill viewed democracy as a mechanism that could easily become tyrannical and thus overwhelm one's individual liberty. Considering that democracy in its various forms (direct, representative, constitutional) is capable of being corrupted (voters and/or representatives may be bribed, coerced, misinformed, misled, subjugated, harassed, mobbed, and so on), it… Continue Reading...

Law Enforcement and Corrections

executives. Law enforcement, administration, and corrections are linked with politics on various extents and levels. Prevailing political philosophy and ideology influence the structure, organization, as well as anticipation of a society's criminal justice organization. As a result, these institutions impact the manners in which criminal law is implemented and administered and corrections put into place (Law Library, 2017). Police agencies are part and parcel of the law enforcement. In a police agency undertakes its law enforcing operations in a political system that is corrupt, then it becomes just about unmanageable to eradicate and abolish the corruption within the police agency. In particular, it has been acknowledged… Continue Reading...

Ancient Rome Timeline of Military

7 events. 200 CE: The rise of populist or democratic sentiments and political philosophy. Rome was not a democracy, although it was a Republic. By the 2nd century CE, populist tribunes started to make waves on the Roman political scene. These populist tribunes were mirrored by the uprisings by local governments and communities in Roman-acquired territories throughout the vast empire. With such a vast empire, and such a relatively weak method of centralized governance, it became increasingly impossible to achieve harmony and authoritative rule. It was not as if Rome usurped idyllic ways of life, so much as populist leaders did recognize… Continue Reading...

The Mis-Education of the Negro by Carter G. Woodson

political philosophy embedded in the United States Constitution.As a result, “Du Bois criticized Washington for not demanding equality for African Americans,” (“Booker T. Washington,” 2017). Washington remains an important figure in that he knew how important it was to build bridges and never to isolate anyone from the dialogue. Woodson falls somewhere between the DuBois and Washington in that like DuBois, he championed a more comprehensive approach to erasing the deep-seated racist beliefs in the United States. In one chapter of Mis-Education, for example, Woodson specifically criticizes the backwards mentality… Continue Reading...

Torture and Interrogation Essay

has become the increasing focus for researchers as well. For instance, Schiemann emphasizes, “To the degree that political philosophy is concerned with the proper balance between legitimate state authority, including violence, on one hand, and individual autonomy, including autonomy of the body, on the other hand, then interrogational torture is also an important problem in normative political theory.”4  Despite these growing concerns, proponents of the global war on terrorism maintain that the use of torture is justified given the potential for future terrorist attacks on the scale of those of September 11, 2001 and the need to protect the country’s interests at home and abroad. For example,… Continue Reading...

Military Tribunals or Federal Courts Terrorism

courts, in terms of procedure and also in terms of political philosophy; unlike civilian trials they can take place behind closed doors, barring access to the Fifth Estate. Therefore, when considering where terrorist suspects should be tried, the answer rests with clarifying what the intended goals of the trial are: to err on the side of caution even if it means convicting the innocent and overriding the principles of human rights; or to err on the side of human rights even if it means risking the release of a terrorist. Pros cons of each tribunal Generally, those in favor of… Continue Reading...

Fides Virtus

he started his rule, Claudius demonstrated exceedingly meticulous leadership. In particular, his objectives were outstanding, and his political philosophy was intellectual. In addition, during the course of his reign of the Roman Empire, the Romans reveled in general success and there were very minimal grievances and criticism from the provinces. Moreover, his brevity was showcased in the key achievement, which was the organized invasion and overthrow of the south of Britain (Roman Empire, 2017). Titus Flavius Sabinus Vespasian is another leader that demonstrated these qualities. In particular, Vespasian was a very practical individual; he was a man of the people. His brevity can be perceived in the… Continue Reading...

sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Political Philosophy" (2004, June 20) Retrieved May 14, 2024, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/political-philosophy-171695

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Political Philosophy" 20 June 2004. Web.14 May. 2024. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/political-philosophy-171695>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Political Philosophy", 20 June 2004, Accessed.14 May. 2024,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/political-philosophy-171695