Relevant Evidence Case Study

Total Length: 642 words ( 2 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 2

Page 1 of 2

Legal Concept of Relevant Evidence

Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963)

Facts: Defendants Brady and Boblit were convicted of murder by the state of Maryland, with Brady admitting participation in the crime but stating that Boblit committed the actual act of killing the victim. Boblit confirmed this fact in a written statement recording his personal confession, but during the criminal proceedings prosecutors elected to withhold Boblit's confession from the court, as well as from Brady and his attorney. Upon being convicted of the murder, Brady challenged the decision on the basis of potential violations of the Fourteenth Amendment, which guarantees those accused of criminal conduct the right to due process. The Maryland Court of Appeals affirmed Brady's conviction, but remanded the case for retrial to reassess the question of punishment.

Issues: The prosecution's choice to withhold Boblit's written confession irrevocably altered the sentencing process for Brady, as the court was never made aware that he did not actually commit the violent acts which ended the victim's life. While Brady's participation in the crime warranted a murder conviction in light of judicial precedent on the issue of accomplices to violent crimes which result in death, the court may have rendered a reduced sentence in light of the mitigating circumstances present in his case. By withholding the written confession, prosecutors violated Brady's due process right to be made aware of the evidence to be presented against him, as awareness of the written confession would have allowed Brady's attorney to seek a reduced sentence.


Decisions: The Supreme Court ultimately ruled that the prosecution's decision to withhold exculpatory evidence violated Brady's right to due process "where the evidence is material either to guilt or to punishment." Although the Warren Court found that under Maryland state law the written confession which was withheld could not have exculpated the defendant from guilt, but that the evidence was material to the degree of punitive action he would….....

Show More ⇣


     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


Related Essays

How Statistical Data Influences Evidence-Based Practice

and involves the search for and critically appraising the most relevant evidence, one\\'s clinical experience and the preferences of the patient (Fortunato, Grainger, & Abou-El-Enein, 2018). The process involved in EBP allows the practitioner to assess research, clinical guidelines, and other information resources that are based on high-quality findings and apply the results obtained to improve their practice. Since EBP heavily relies on research and searching for available evidence to support a hypothetical question in order to solve a current problem, it is vital that one understands and interprets statistical data that is presented in the research articles that they… Continue Reading...

Patient Care and the Affordable Care Act

Instead, it is essential to critically assess the searched information, select the highest ranking and most relevant evidence available relating to the query, patient’s circumstance and needs. Essentially, the highest ranking evidence article is not necessarily the ultimate go-to guide for ideal decisions. Instead, the ideal guide for decision has to be the highest ranking that depicts the patient’s attribute and through critical assessments reflects considerable best patient outcome (Sackett et al., 1996). Comparing CINAHL Keyword Search Result with Other Search Engines According to Houde (2009), the choice of a search engine in systematic reviews will significantly have an impact on Evidence Based Practice (EBP). The… Continue Reading...

Treating Allergic Patients Using Homeopathy

investigation. The observations were adequate to provide insights on the issues under investigation, which demonstrates the lack of a research question in the study. Relevant Evidence, Experiences and/or Information High-quality researches usually entail citing relevant evidence, experiences and/or information that is essential to the issue or phenomenon under investigation. Consequently, in most studies, researchers include a literature review section and/or cite sources that help in understanding the specific issue. The inclusion of literature review section provides a background for understanding the research issue/topic based on existing evidence or prior studies that have been carried out about it. The citing of relevant evidence, experiences and/or information is also crucial towards understanding the researcher's reasoning when… Continue Reading...

Feeding Intolerance Integrative Review Paper

Polit and Beck (2017), a systematic approach based on the IOWA Model of Evidenced-Based Practice was used to identify a clinical problem, develop and organize a search strategy, and disseminate the relevant evidence into an integrative review for nursing use. The following databases, PubMed, CINAHL, and Ovid were searched between September 19 and October 21, 2017, using the following search terms alone or in combination: infant massage, feeding intolerance, feeding tolerance, abdominal distention, gastric residuals, preterm infants and tactile stimulation. The search was limited to studies in English, newborn infants, and studies published in the last five years. Only original peer reviewed articles that used massage as an intervention and specifically reported feeding intolerance outcomes for preterm infants, born less than… Continue Reading...

Nursing Needs These Times

way. Instead, what is needed is a top down approach in which there are organized means of discerning relevant evidence-based practices and facilitating them in a similarly structured manner. Doing so would improve nursing and patient objectives, while utilizing the most proven methods to accomplish those outcomes. Gaps or Conflicts Between Statements and Practices The disparate implementation of evidence-based nursing practice to healthcare facilities creates some inherent gaps between organizational statements and practices. Most healthcare organizations have mission statements regarding how they are attempting to facilitate the best possible treatment to patients. Nurses are often the focal point of those treatment options, particularly since they are regularly called… Continue Reading...

Secular Humanism

years, with each school of thought vigorously defending their respective positions by citing relevant evidence and brooking no disagreements. Against this backdrop, developing a better understanding of these two worldviews has assumed new importance and relevance today. To this end, this paper provides a summary and evaluation of the human secularist worldview, followed by a corresponding evaluation and defense of Christianity. Finally, a summary of the research and important findings concerning human secularism are provided in the paper’s conclusion. [2: Alan T. Price (2007, Spring), ‘Secular Humanism vs. Religion? The Liberal Democratic Education Tradition and the Battle over Vouchers in the USA.’ Forum… Continue Reading...

sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Relevant Evidence" (2014, February 24) Retrieved June 4, 2026, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/relevant-evidence-183631

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Relevant Evidence" 24 February 2014. Web.4 June. 2026. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/relevant-evidence-183631>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Relevant Evidence", 24 February 2014, Accessed.4 June. 2026,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/relevant-evidence-183631