Water Crisis and Water Research Paper

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document

Total Length: 3059 words ( 10 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 5

Page 1 of 10

publicized Water Crisis at Michigan's Flint city, which first emerged in the year 2014. In specific, it will address associated challenges and concepts, a SWOT (strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats) analysis of the issue, and solutions and recommendations in order to resolve the issue.

Situated about 70 miles to the north of Michigan's largest city, Detroit, the city of Flint is home to 98,310 inhabitants, of which an alarming 41.6% are classified as economically underprivileged. The United States Census Bureau estimates reveal that the average household income of the city's residents is around 24,679 dollars, while the state average stands at 49,087 dollars. Over half (i.e., 56.6%) of the city's inhabitants belong to the African-American ethnic group. At one time, the city headquartered the biggest General Motors manufacturing unit in America. Flint suffered an economic downturn in the eighties, when the company decided to downsize this expansive industrial unit (Flint Water Crisis Fast Facts - CNN.com). The state government assumed responsibility of the city's finances in the year 2011 following an audit that estimated a deficit of twenty-five million dollars. Despite the city's water supply finances reflecting a deficit of nine million dollars, some of the funds were being utilized by officials to cover general fund deficits. Insolvency came to an end in April of 2015, with deficit clearance using emergency loan, by which the funds apportioned for the city's water were declared solvent. For reducing the deficit in water fund, Flint decided to switch its sources of water in the year 2014. Although the construction of a fresh pipeline that connects the Lake Huron's waters to the city of Flint was underway, city officials decided to use river water as its source in the couple of years of transition. In the past, Flint River waters downstream of the city have been proven to be of bad quality. They were severely degraded in the seventies, because of toxins like lead, fecal coliform, oil, low levels of dissolved oxygen, and plant nutrients being present in the waters. Children's exposure to lead gives rise to the following health impacts: impaired cognition, late puberty, behavioral issues, and hearing issues. Among expectant mothers, lead has been proven to decrease fetal growth. For the general population, consumption of lead impacts nerves, the heart, and the kidneys.

Concepts/Challenges Involved

Among the chief criticisms facing the New Public Management concept is that, as public officials and emergency managers are not bound by regular democratic oversight, answerability will be muddled. Accountability demands are surfacing in the city of Flint, with America holding the governor, the Department of Environmental Quality, and emergency managers as the chief blameworthy parties. New Public Management's most vexing characteristic, with respect to the Flint Water Crisis, is probably the notion that a citizen is a consumer (Flint, Lead and Public Administration's Failure -- It Ain't Necessarily So). Such management perceives the government as flexible and responsive to citizens' requirements and demands as they pay for commodities; hence, the chief executive's actions are crucial to meeting consumer needs and demands of market forces. But, contrary to the above assumption, citizens cannot be likened to consumers, and water is no commodity.

Strengths

Not many strong points may be reported with respect to the water crisis at Flint, Michigan. Weaknesses linked to it, however, are many.

Weaknesses

A financial emergency was declared in Flint in the year 2011, leading to state assumption of the city's budgetary control function. Thus, as verified by state authorities, every decision made in the course of Flint's water crisis wasn't by the city's mayor or council, but by state authorities. Dan Kildee, a Congress member from Michigan, stated when an emergency finance manager was chosen by the governor in the year 2011, the position's responsibility was only to achieve budget reductions, at all costs. According to Kildee, Flint's water crisis suggests an attitude regarding industrial cities like Flint that, during the last three decades, have seen tough times (Ganim and Tran, 2016). He claims they are usually simply forgotten. The federal EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) and Michigan Attorney have been probing into the reason for the state's neglect of federal regulation and its decision to do without the anticorrosive, as argued by the lawsuit.

Stuck Writing Your "Water Crisis and Water" Research Paper?

View All Our Example Water Crisis and Water Research Paper

Have A Custom Example Essay Written

According to Karen Weaver, Mayor of the city, this question is yet to be answered.

Opportunities

No major opportunities may be reported with regard to the water crisis at Flint, Michigan.

Threats

The EPA warns Michigan state authorities and Flint city officials that the city is faced with a number of long-term water supply-related threats, despite short-term efforts to decrease lead concentration in its drinking water. The substandard quality of water supply grew into a city-wide crisis when, following several months of complaints by residents of this predominantly African-American and poverty-ridden city, authorities acknowledged an issue and started seeking corrective measures. Gina Mccarthy, Administrator of EPA, identified no less than five areas which would need further focus and funding for guaranteeing a sustainable, safe potable water supply within an official letter addressed to Rick Snyder, Michigan State's Governor, and Weaver. In this letter, Mccarthy noted that while immediate efforts have generated heartening signs, major long-term issues persist, including a need for additional finances, choosing the city's water source for the long run, and a competent city administration (EPA warns Flint, Michigan of long-term threats to water supply). Furthermore, according to the letter, Flint's water treatment unit suffers a staff shortage, coupled with an oversized distribution system that reduces the efficiency of the chlorine utilized in treating pathogens. The Flint River's waters proved more corrosive compared to that of Detroit's system, resulting in the leaching of more lead from its old pipes. Lead has toxic effects, and child-consumers are particularly at risk. Weaver accepted a number of EPA conclusions, stated that compliance would necessitate extra state funding. She states that new infrastructure and pipelines are required, and the state ought to pay for these.

With regard to ethics, Flint's water crisis teaches us the 'don'ts' of tackling public health issues, particularly those produced (indirectly, at the least) by city authorities' actions. In spite of substantial proof of the existence of an issue, city authorities turned a blind eye to it, delaying corrective action for about 6-9 months, which will probably bring further financial losses to the city, following court-case judgments. Flint's case demonstrates the importance of timely, decisive action, and the amount of trouble likely to ensue if delays are caused (Engineering Ethics Blog: Dereliction of Duty: The Flint Water Crisis). In the event of lawsuits, ascertaining precise facts regarding the issue becomes difficult. A well -known and -established fact, however, is that the municipality failed to conduct routine tests of tap-water in city residences. Independent lead testing in drinking water cannot be expected of citizens, particularly underprivileged ones who make up a large share of the city's inhabitants. The city's water department engineers must have known the potentials issues that would arise when the Flint River's acidic waters combined with old lead pipes. However, despite most of the citizens being aware of the problem, which was proven by independent examinations of the water, the city's finance manager seemed to refuse to accept the fact. Admittedly, insolvency increased complications for a city municipality; however, citizens' safety must be given priority over fiscal considerations. This incident's fallout will haunt the city for years to come.

Governor Snyder organized a task force for investigating the city's water crisis. The unit, after analysis, has compiled a contemptuous report that is 116 pages long, explaining how governmental failure at every level resulted in drinking water contamination in the city, with lead found in high concentration. The document particularly condemns the EPA, stating that the federal body could not have enforced potable water regulations without extensive public outrage in the city. The task force claimed the EPA did not exert its authority properly before January of 2016 and that the federal agency's behavior raises doubts with regard to its readiness to assertively pursue enforcement (when extensive public outrage wasn't apparent) (Bastasch, 2016). The investigative task force further asserted that the agency was authorized to exert power under the Lead and Copper Rule's 40 CFR 141.82(i), or the Safe Drinking Water Act's sections 1414 and 1431. But media reports depict that members of the agency charged with water quality oversight….....

Show More ⇣

     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Water Crisis And Water" (2016, October 31) Retrieved May 2, 2024, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/water-crisis-water-2162381

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Water Crisis And Water" 31 October 2016. Web.2 May. 2024. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/water-crisis-water-2162381>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Water Crisis And Water", 31 October 2016, Accessed.2 May. 2024,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/water-crisis-water-2162381
   

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document
order custom essay example