Abortion Essay

Total Length: 1218 words ( 4 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 1

Page 1 of 4

The term 'abortion' is used to denote a practice of purposeful pregnancy termination to ensure a child isn't born. This social issue revolves around the aspect of personhood. Almost everybody is of the view that every individual has his/her own unique moral status; hence, depriving any individual of his/her life, except in some extreme situations, is a grave sin. A pro-lifer contends that this principle is applicable to abortion as well, since a fetus is, in essence, a person (thus the word "pro-life"). Meanwhile, a majority of pro-choicers contend that it is only at an advanced developmental stage (i.e., during birth or shortly before it) that a fetus may be identified as a person. The chief, hotly-contested issue with regard to this subject -- fetuses' moral status -- has remained the same since the passing of the 1967 Abortion Act in the UK.

Arguments for Abortion



Ethical theorist, Judith J. Thomson's 1971 publication, A Defense of Abortion, states that abortion may be considered ethically tolerable even if one accepts the argument that several months before delivery, the fetus is already an 'individual', as a person's right to live is actually a right to not have his/her life "UNJUSTLY" taken and not simply a right not to have his/her life taken. Consequently, any mother who resolves to terminate her unborn baby's life justly has not violated the baby's right to live.



The major part of Thomson's work serves to outline a few scenarios wherein an individual may be justly taking a life. One scenario would be that of music fans attaching an individual's circulatory system with an unconscious musician's system for saving his life. While the former individual had not given permission to carry this out, he is now told that if the musician is unplugged, he would die. He is pleaded with to continue to stay attached and, hence, nearly disabled, for a whole nine months.
According to Thomson, the individual would be performing an extremely kind deed indeed if he agreed to remain connected to the unconscious patient; however, he wouldn't be morally obliged to do so.

Building on Thompson



Thomson's assumption, for argument's sake, is that, right from the start, the unborn fetus is an individual. Subsequently, the theorist attempts to prove that despite its right to live, abortion is an ethically tolerable practice.



The argument against abortion may be described as follows:



(1) Every fetus is an individual.



(2) Every individual must enjoy the right to live.



(3) Hence, every fetus must enjoy the right to live.



(4) Thus, abortion is morally incorrect.



Thomson begins with the assumption that the first two statements are valid. She, however, feels it isn't a strong point to begin with, for pro-lifers. For instance, consider the most widely cited rationale. As a person's growth from conception to delivery to childhood is a continuous process, one may allow that right from the start, the unborn baby is an individual. From this point on, the argument may proceed thus: Every individual must enjoy the right to live. Hence, every fetus must enjoy the right to live. Undoubtedly, women are allowed to govern what happens to and within their bodies. However, the right to live prevails over a woman's liberty to govern what happens to and within her body. Therefore, one cannot abort the fetus. But at this juncture, Thomson claims that statement (4) is no logical conclusion developing from statement (3). The right to live doesn't imply that terminating life is immoral, as….....

Show More ⇣


     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


References


Thomson, J. J. (1971). A Defense of Abortion. Philosophy & Public Affairs, 1(1).
Related Essays

Abortion and Public Perspectives Domestic and Global Perspectives

Abortion and the Media: Domestic and Global Perspectives If anything can be agreed upon, it’s that abortion is a complex issue, one that triggers a wealth of opinions, feelings and beliefs. The way in which abortion is presented in the media is something that is also exceedingly complex, and which can both impact society and be a reflection of the beliefs of a particular society. Even in this modern era, abortion is still an issue that has the power to divide people and to cause tense debates. This paper will… Continue Reading...

Abortion and Ethics

Abortion is an important topic in society because it deals with the matter of life and death. It also deals with the matter of personal rights. Does a woman have the right to terminate a pregnancy? Or does abortion contradict ethics and moral standards that govern society and human beings? The conflict at the heart of the abortion argument is one of rights vs. ethics. On the one hand, those who support for abortion rights say that a woman has the right to choose. On the other hand, those who… Continue Reading...

Abortion

Part One According to the British Pregnancy Advisory Service, an abortion refers to the termination of a pregnancy so that it avoids the birth of a child. Abortion is one of the most intense and hot-blooded topic in society today, provoking a host of opinions, contentions and fierce dogma. It’s definitely thought provoking to determine when and how abortion became so contentious, as for much of American history it really was considered to be a standard aspect of life (Reagan, 1996). In fact, for much of America’s existence the procedure was legal and used frequently. In fact, until the last… Continue Reading...

Abortion Interview

Part One According to the British Pregnancy Advisory Service, an abortion refers to the termination of a pregnancy so that it avoids the birth of a child. Abortion is one of the most intense and hot-blooded topic in society today, provoking a host of opinions, contentions and fierce dogma. It’s definitely thought provoking to determine when and how abortion became so contentious, as for much of American history it really was considered to be a standard aspect of life (Reagan, 1996). In fact, for much of America’s existence the procedure was legal and used frequently. In fact, until the last… Continue Reading...

Abortion Pros and Cons Essay

Abstract Abortion refers to the termination of the pregnancy and most members of society tend to feel strongly and often myopically about their opinions of abortion. This paper will examine the complex and multi-faceted history that the United States has had with abortion as well as the pros and cons of this procedure. This essay will take a long look at the reasons that motivate those who support abortion and those who do not. It is hoped that this deep analysis will not only strengthen one’s ability to think critically, but… Continue Reading...

Abortion Essay

Potential Topics: The Impact of the Pro-Life Movement on Abortion Rates The Impact of the Pro-Choice Movement on Abortion Rates The Future of Roe v. Wade When Does Life Begin? Titles: [1] A Comparison of Abortion Practices in Different Countries and the United States The Current Status of the Abortion Debate in the United States How Will the Trump Administrations Stance on Planned Parenthood Affect Abortion Rates in the U.S.? How the Pro-Life and Pro-Choice Movements have Affected Americans Public Opinion about Abortion [2] Outline: I. Introduction II. The Pro-Life Movement III. The Pro-Choice Movement IV. Conclusion Abstract: Despite… Continue Reading...

Alternative Points of View on the Abortion Debate

Introduction Abortion rates have been steadily decreasing in the United States, but the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention still reports over 600,000 legal abortions per year (CDC, 2018). In spite of the landmark Supreme Court decision in Roe v. Wade, abortion remains a contentious public policy issue. The reason why this issue was selected for analysis is because it remains unresolved in public debate and reflects unfortunate schisms in American society. Rather than resort to vitriolic language, it would be more constructive to reach a consensus about abortion policy. History… Continue Reading...

Legal Status of the Fetus

in the counterfactual event. This is the point where the objector loses the point (Harman, 1999). Women have been found to regret the abortion act but not the choice to do so. This is thought to be incompatible with the full liberal view of abortion. Women are upset by abortion. This something is not about uncertainties that surround the procedure. These experiences can only be explained by the possibility that the women recognize that they have engaged in a morally significant event and have found truth that they have failed the moral test. The liberal view ignores these facts (Harman, 1999). How important is biological development and is there a non-arbitrary way of… Continue Reading...

Interpreting Biblical Text

3. Exodus 21:22-23 This verse has been used as a proof-text to prohibit abortion. Based on the text itself, the verses suggest that if a miscarriage happens and a child is lost, the adversary should simply be fined. Additionally, the context of the passage shows that if an injury occurs in this process then the penalty is determined depending on the extent of the injury. In this case, the passage is almost conclusive in forbidding against abortion. The text suggests that if a pregnant woman is forced into premature labor and accidental delivery through the actions of an antagonist, the antagonist will be… Continue Reading...

Sources of Birth Defects in Older Mothers

that actively avoid or at least procrastinate when it comes to taking those tests. While some women are averse to abortion as a means to avoid giving birth to a special needs child, it is something that women should choose with informed consent. However, many women avoid or delay this proper due diligence and this is not a new phenomenon. While general risk assessments and non-invasive screening can be useful, there are some other methods that are much more exhaustive and effective (Dunn, 2003). Another dimension that truly exists but is not commonly looked at is who precisely to target when it comes to the screening for birth defects. Rather… Continue Reading...

Ethics and Morality

division in the U.S. between those who view abortion as immoral and those who view it as a right that should not be denied a woman. This is a very polarizing issue and people tend to adopt an ethical position towards it, sometimes even saying that while they would never have an abortion themselves, they do not believe others should be denied that right. So when it comes to discussing ethics today, there are many different things to consider: there is the subjective take, the objective take, and then even many other perspectives—such as a historical take, a… Continue Reading...

Colored Girls Rainbow Shange Play Reaction

controversial issues in their stories including those related to abortion and suicide. All of the women have suffered injustice and violations including domestic violence and abuse and rape, with gender-related issues at the heart of each of their tales. They have considered killing themselves to obliterate the pain and transmute the suffering. Above all, “For Colored Girls” exemplifies intersectional oppression: the links between race, gender, and social status. Using poetic devices instead of straightforward prose is what distinguishes Shange’s play from others that address such issues with more direct language. Theirs are not stories in the traditional sense of… Continue Reading...

Muslim Women in Eastern and Western Literature

abortions in four Turkish television series: Gümü?, A?k-? Memnu, Han?m?n Çiftli?i, and Öyle Bir Geçer Zaman ki, all of which appeared on TV in the last decade or so (O’Neil, 810). “O’Neil’s study reveals that women in all four series are portrayed negatively and blamed for failing to conform to family and society’s gender expectations” (Eltantawy, 766). Essentially the literature of television and film has decided to punish these women for defying all cultural expectations of womanhood as a result of their failure and refusal to put motherhood above all… Continue Reading...

Book Trade Between China and France An Assessment

the families and the forced abortions that results from a policy of this nature. Another set of texts published in France from China seek to define Chinese history from a modernist viewpoint. In so doing, the evolution of the country is clearly brought out, while at the same time alluding to a society that is constantly undergoing some form of metamorphosis. The China of today differs very significantly from the China of yesteryears. While the country was more focused on the enforcement of policies that were largely coercive and against the wishes of the general… Continue Reading...

Genetically Modified Foods

on Bt-maize, GM cottonseed and certain biotech corn showed complications including early deliveries, abortions, infertility and also many died” (Maghari & Ardekani, 2011). This scientific data makes a clear case for how reckless it is to allow human beings to consume these products. Similarly, the testing method to assess GMO foods is not comprehensive enough. Many companies use inadequate means where the chemical analysis of the food isn’t compared completely to non-GMO foods, or there is an inappropriate use of statistics (Maghari & Ardekani, 2011). All studies assessing the safety of GMO foods need to use animals responsibly in order to determine the… Continue Reading...

Morality Relativism and Beliefs

One relativistic belief that I find that some people hold is regarding abortion. Some people say, “Well, I would never have one,” implying that there is something immoral or unjustified about the action (at least in their case), and then they will follow that up with a statement like, “But I don’t think other people should be denied the right to have one,” suggesting that there is in fact nothing immoral or unjustifiable about it. This appears to me to be a case of, “What’s not good for me is not necessarily bad for you.” While some philosophers, like Kant, might argue… Continue Reading...

Anti-Bullying Bill in Texas

abortion, migration, LGBT rights, and other contentious subjects. Wayne Faircloth, Texas State’s Republican from Galveston, when supporting the bill, claimed it was high time people began respecting one another, beginning from the House. He further added that disputing one another’s policy was fine, but offering personal rebukes wasn’t. He believes there is a need to establish an example right there in the state legislature and that it is about people’s treatment of one another, the way they speak, the way they carry themselves, and the way they pay attention and… Continue Reading...

Changing the Senatorial Leadership of Georgia

since 2014). Isakson has a strong conservative voting record on issues such as abortion, affirmative action, and same-sex marriage according to the nonpartisan website On the Issues. He also has a strong pro-business voting record. David Perdue has a similar voting record. This homogeneity in and of its self is problematic for Georgia. This does not represent Georgia's full diversity as a state, particularly given its significant urban community (which draws both business and tourism) as well as its racial diversity. The fact that the senators oppose both affirmative action and gay rights underline the fact that they do not support the rights… Continue Reading...

Morality Then and Now

today. Sure, there are technologies and other things to consider that did not exist before such as medical-induced abortions and the like, but the ability to consider and ponder moral questions has not changed even if some people have different or more malleable moral codes than others (Biography). When it comes to whether we can condemn people that engage in what would seem to be dated or barbaric practices, perhaps the answer involves the intent of the act and the liberty of the person… Continue Reading...

Federalism and States Rights Regarding Drugs

be state versus federal jurisdiction. For example, some religious conservatives vie for federally illegal abortions or restrictions on civil rights like the proposed Defense of Marriage Act. The War on Drugs was started by a Republican President, Nixon, and strengthened by Republican President Ronald Reagan. As Adler (2014) points out, "So many Republicans who believe it's federal overreach when federal law regulates health insurance or power plant emissions think its just fine when the federal government prohibits the possession of a plant, even where authorized under state law," (p. 1). The federal government has not fully clarified its position on the clash between states'… Continue Reading...

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Abortion" (2017, February 09) Retrieved November 13, 2019, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/abortion-essay

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Abortion" 09 February 2017. Web.13 November. 2019. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/abortion-essay>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Abortion", 09 February 2017, Accessed.13 November. 2019,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/abortion-essay