Compensation and Benefits Essay

Total Length: 2747 words ( 9 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 9

Page 1 of 9

Compensation and Benefits

The United States Postal Service (USPS) which has been experiencing periods of stagnant or declining revenue was discovered to have a large issue with their compensation and benefits system. It was discovered that the organization provides its employees with lucrative packages which are much higher than those offered by its private sector competitors. Most of the USPS employees are unionized and the unions have been able to negotiate great packages for the employees with the USPS paying 100% of their employee life insurance premiums as compared to other federal agencies that pay about 33% and also pays 80% of their employee health benefit premiums as compared to other federal agencies that pay only 72%. It was found that an average USPS employee receives $79,000 in compensation and benefits as compared to $59,900 for employees at the same level in private agencies. This data is, however, not adjusted for factors such as skills of workers and working conditions Carbaugh & Tenerelli, 2011.

Edwards (2010)

argues that postal service unions have done extremely well in negotiating great packages for their members but these benefits for USPS workers are expected to continue increasing as a result of growing healthcare and pension costs which will lead to increased expenditure on compensation and benefits for the USPS amidst stagnant or declining profits.

The data reported by Carbaugh and Tenerelli (2011)

above is consistent to research conducted by Wachter, Hirsch, and Gillula (2001)

who found out that the USPS provides workers with a total compensation premium of 44% on wages and benefits as compared to the private sector workers. The wage only premium is 36%. Most important is that their analysis provides important controls for differences in skills and working conditions for the workers as well as other variables such as training differences, educational background and other demographic variables. The researchers also found that postal workers have low levels of unmeasured skill as compared to private sector employees. This cannot provide a justification for the wage premium paid by the USPS. However, the wage premium has helped the USPS to have a lower turnover rate than private companies as well as higher job application rates.

The ability of the USPS to find a solution for its arbitration process is greatly hampered by the legal mandates that restrict negotiations between the USPS and the postal service labor unions. Therefore, though the USPS is working out collective bargaining agreements with the labor unions that will include items such as work rules, layoff protections and cost-of-living adjustments, legal mandates prevent the reduction of wages, hiring of part-time workers or outsourcing of USPS services. This creates an even larger problem for the USPS since their expenses on employee compensation and benefits will remain high.

Literature review

Empirical evidence shows there is a link between human capital and organizational performance. Dessler (1997)

posits that for any organization to succeed, compensation of their employees must be at par with the input that the organization requires. This argument is supported by Gomez -Mejia, Dalkin, and Cardy (2006)

who state that capital investment is not as important as human resource investment for the success of the organization. Cascio, 2003()

argues that in ensuring the employees have the motivation and attitude required for the success of the organization, an effective compensation program needs to be designed. This involves both direct and indirect compensation. Direct compensation is about the wage or salary aspect while indirect compensation is the fringe benefits that the employee enjoys. By integrating the two types of compensation, the organization is able to motivate their employees towards the success of the organization. A similar compensation model is given by McNamara (2008)

who states that an effective compensation package caters for issues regarding wages or salaries such as remuneration, job descriptions, merit-based and performance-based incentives, while benefits include issues such as retirement plans, health and disability insurance, vacations, and stock plans.

Compensation in federal government and government agencies

Since the early 20th century, the U.S. government has taken an active role in ensuring its workers receive good pay and benefits. This led to various Acts such as the fair labor standards act of 1938 that dictated equal pay for equal work. Twenty years after this act was enacted, the economy was hit by recessions which made this difficult but twenty years later when the economy boomed, the government played an important role in the American workplace by enacting the equal pay act in 1963. Today, employment by federal government and other government agencies has evolved to make them more lucrative employers than the private sector.
Differences between federal compensation and private sector compensation depend largely on their highest level of education. For those whose highest level of education is a bachelor's degree, the cost of total compensation is an average of 15% more than for federal workers than for private sector employees in the same level. For employees who their high school diploma is their highest level of education, the federal government pays them 36% more than private sector employers. Lastly, for Master's and doctorate degrees, the total compensation for federal employees was 18% lower than for private sector employees at the same level. Overall, the federal government paid their employees 16% more than the private sector employees after putting into consideration the observable characteristics of employees such as education background and experience levels.

Extrinsic and intrinsic rewards

In all organizations, monetary pay is the single most important reward and it is considered to be an ever-present and significant factor in the success of the organization (Milkovich and Newman, 04). Gardner et. al 04, however, argues that monetary pay is not merely a motivation factor for employees. It is also a factor in employee retention and organization's ability to attract employees. Adams 63, however, hinted that the distribution of financial rewards in any organization may create issues related to inequity and may also destabilize the possibility of positive impact of the monetary pay given to employees thus leading to negative consequences. Herzberg et. al 57 pointed at the dichotomy of rewards as either intrinsic or extrinsic. He labeled achievement, advancement, and recognition as intrinsic rewards which motivate employees more than extrinsic rewards which include salary, job security and working environment. This led to the argument brought by Chiang and Birtch 07 that the utility of the reward system and the enticement that is entrenched in it is of great value to the organization. Zhou et. al 09 stated that extrinsic rewards have a utilitarianism value and could be used to modify employee behavior towards organizational success. His argument is that by providing employees with extrinsic rewards, their performance could be greatly enhanced. He also argues that intrinsic rewards have romanticism value. This is because they boost the innovation and creativity foe employees. Despite these two definitions of extrinsic and intrinsic rewards being difference, there is a commonality that comes in the ability to influence a person's behavior through the use of rewards.

Strategic compensation

Compensation is a key element in the relationship between employers and employees and in most organizations it is the single greatest operating cost. Scholars have thus advocated for its use as a tool to enhance organizational performance and sustain competitiveness. This has led for the development of contemporary approaches to compensation that emphasize the importance of aligning behaviors of employees to the strategic goals and objective of the organization. This has led to the adoption of strategic compensation which though limited, through the creation of managerial difficulties for implementing the compensation, has potential to push organizations forward.

It is also argued by Lawler 90 that the starting point of the design of a compensation system is the strategic direction of the organization. Therefore, it is important for the compensation design to be aligned with the organization's strategic direction which creates a powerful means for attracting and retaining desired talent. It also elicits desired behavior outcomes in terms of employee motivation, loyalty and commitment which are requirements for positive organizational performance. Thus employee compensation may be made to be contingent upon a combination of team performance, organization performance and individual performance. This performance-based compensation system creates economic value for the organization by reducing the expenditure on employee compensation and benefits during difficult economic periods while securing sustained competitive advantage for the organization. Pffeffer 94.

Job satisfaction

Job satisfaction is also an important factor in motivation of employees and the organization's ability to attract and retain employees. Herberg's duality theory made a proposition towards job satisfaction as a function for motivating employees. Job satisfaction is defined by Locke 69 as an emotional situation that is related to a positive or negative judgment on the individual's job experiences. Linda Evans 97 in her study found that job satisfaction is determined by the degree to which the job-related needs of the employee are being met by the organization. These needs include extrinsic rewards such as money, power and prestige. This argument is supported by Kreitner and Kinicki 06 who.....

Show More ⇣


     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


Related Essays

Compensation and Benefits The Modern Workplace

Crafting a Compensation and Benefits Plan: Looking Ahead in the Modern Workplace Increasingly, technologically-driven businesses have become more and more reliant upon attracting top talent to gain a competitive edge. Perhaps the most obvious example of this is the Google organization. Google’s Internet search engine is virtually synonymous with searching on the Internet itself. Google offers generous salaries and time off to its employees. It also offers many amenities, such as free food, medical care, dry-cleaning, fitness classes, and even buses from certain common location hubs in the surrounding area. This enable… Continue Reading...

Human Capital Management Using Benefits and Compensation

their competitors, which leads to reduced employee productivity. Companies need to establish a well-designed employee compensation and benefits package in order to retain its top talent and attract others. There are numerous companies that desire to attract, retain, and motivate their employees in order to meet the company's strategic objectives. Currently, employees are considered to be part of the company's assets because they have to be effectively and efficiently managed. There are numerous instruments that companies can use to attract, retain, and motivate employees. Compensation and benefits are some of the tools that companies can use. It is vital that an employer identifies and offers… Continue Reading...

IBM Supply Chain Concerns

first pertains to sustainability; the second relates to competitive advantage. Compensation and benefits packages are required to keep the personnel working for an organization. Similarly, mandates for safety and employee relations are necessary to ensure that employees are able to work together harmoniously. These areas are related to, yet considered distinct from employee retention. Employee retention is based on keeping employees which are valuable to an organization. Human resources is also tasked with staffing and organization and suitably training that staff, which is key part of remaining competitive. Performance management in the form of reviews and feedback is also part… Continue Reading...

Assessment of Corporate Culture at Zappos

of the ten core values that govern work practices. The third aspect of the firm's organizational culture is great employee compensation and benefits and a suitable working environment. Employees are required to work towards ensuring that customers are happy through providing excellent customer service. Zappos' managers ensure that culturally fit candidates are hired and work processes are carried out in a manner that is fit with this culture to ensure that employees and customers are happy at all times (Patel, 2015). McGinty/Moss Assessment of Zappos' Organizational Culture Debra Woog McGinty and Nicole C. Moss developed a short corporate culture survey that can be utilized to identify the characteristics of an… Continue Reading...

Managing Stress Brought by Self Defeating Behavior

contributing to misbehavior, stress, and conflicts are job burnout, poor compensation and benefits strategies, unsuitable organizational culture, ineffective leadership style, and poor decision-making. According to Sims (2002), managing misbehavior, individual stress, and conflicts in the workplace is a multidimensional process that requires the use of different strategies. Managers and leaders in an organization can manage these factors through several measures including the use of proper leadership styles/management techniques, teem meetings, and establishing effective communication channels (Sims, 2002). Additionally, organizations can effective manage misbehavior, stress, and conflicts through lessening uncertainties in the workplace and establishing appropriate assistance and wellness programs for… Continue Reading...

Diversity Socialisation for Newcomers

is, however, important to note that job satisfaction tends to be affected by several other factors such as working conditions, interpersonal relations, supervisory and managerial support, compensation and benefits, as well as training and development opportunities. All the same, positive employees can significantly improve organisational efficiency, productivity, and performance (Graybill et al., 2013). Nonetheless, just like employee outcomes, organisational outcomes are often driven by other factors such as leadership, resources, capabilities, and macro-environmental forces. At XYZ, the formal socialisation of newcomers takes two to six weeks depending on the position. Focus is generally on expected roles and responsibilities, the organisation's code of conduct, the organisation's mission and core values, introduction to colleagues, guidelines for workplace interactions,… Continue Reading...

Recruitment Plan and Staffing Plan at Amazon

When designing the job description and terms of the contract, Amazon will also need to investigate obligations to the worker regarding worker compensation and benefits packages, and wage disclosure laws. Using social media during the recruitment process can raise legal red flags due to the potential for conscious or unconscious discrimination based on age, race, gender, and other characteristics (Calvasina, Calvasina & Calvasina, 2014). Discrimination could also potentially impact perceptions of the candidate’s competency, impacting salary negotiations. Therefore, social media should not be relied on as an initial recruitment tool. Recruiting Plan A human resources manager’s recruitment strategy begins with needs assessment; recruiting is about first determining what the organization needs in… Continue Reading...

sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Compensation And Benefits" (2012, October 29) Retrieved May 15, 2024, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/compensation-benefits-76189

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Compensation And Benefits" 29 October 2012. Web.15 May. 2024. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/compensation-benefits-76189>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Compensation And Benefits", 29 October 2012, Accessed.15 May. 2024,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/compensation-benefits-76189