Ethical Decision-Making Research Paper

Total Length: 1447 words ( 5 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 1

Page 1 of 5

Ethical Decision

Ethical Dilemma and Decision Making

In the selected scenario, a therapy patient is beginning to develop a trusting relationship with his therapist after spending a fir amount of time dealing with his depression. Under-employed and under-insured, it is clear that the patient still needs help but it is less clear that he has the necessary resources to continue paying for his therapy. Insurance payments could be guaranteed by embellishing his mental condition slightly, thus allowing the therapist to receive payment and providing the care needed, but is this proper? This paper will apply the fourteen steps in the ethical decision making process to derive an answer.

The basic situation of the ethical dilemma is whether or not it is ethically proper to report a more serious mental condition to the patient's insurance company in order to keep receiving payment for services he clearly needs. In other words, is it alright to lie in order to get help for someone; do the ends justify the mean?

Step 2: The effects of a decision in this case will be far more far-reaching than might initially be thought. In addition to affecting the patient, the therapist, and the insurance company, trends in the over-reporting of certain mental conditions simply for insurance purposes could lead to much larger if subtle problems for the insurance and mental health industries and society as a whole. On the other hand, consistently failing to provide necessary care due to lack of payment abilities will also have far-reaching consequences for all parties concerned.

Step 3: There are multiple clients in this scenario, which is part of the reason the ethical dilemma is so complex. The patient is clearly the primary client, however the insurance company is in some ways a client of the therapists as well -- they have a contract (explicit or implicit) in which the therapist is held to the honest performance of his duties in regards to making insurance claims/billing.

Step 4: Knowledge in this area likewise comes in several spheres, and thus the levels of expertise and the amounts of missing knowledge that impact the various areas of this dilemma vary considerably.
It is without a doubt that continuing to receive treatment is in the best interests of the client and that continuing to be compensated for services is in the interest of the therapist, and it is likely that the funds from insurance can be disbursed without significant impact to the insurance company. More knowledge is needed in to the financial aspects of the case, but therapeutic knowledge and skills cannot be expanded much in a manner that would have a real impact on this scenario.

Step 5: Formal ethical standards also differ in their commentary on this case, sometimes in mutually exclusive manners. The tenets of a utilitarian ethical viewpoint would likely suggest embellishing the mental condition in order to keep providing services to the patient, as this would provide the greatest good without causing any noticeable harm (or arguably any harm at all) to the insurance company. Professional ethical standards, however, as well as other ethical systems, would insist that this type of dishonesty is never warranted, no matter what the outcome is expected to be.

Step 6: The relevant legal standards are fairly straightforward in this case: while therapists are bound to provide the best possible care they can for their patients, falsifying information regarding a mental condition is unquestionably illegal. No matter what the reasoning, the therapist would certainly be found guilty of an infraction if the "embellishment "came to be known by relevant parties.

Step 7: Research in this area exists, but is not necessarily especially relevant. The damage that can be done to individuals society by not treating depression is certainly extensive, but placing increased burdens on insurance companies and the health industry for services that are unnecessary or that cannot be paid for also creates problems (and the insurance company decides what is "necessary" based on what the patient can pay for the insurance). None of this impacts the decision of whether or not the ends justify the means in this case.

Step 8: There is a clear self-interest on the part of the therapist in both decisions that can be made in this scenario -- embellishing the condition has a direct monetary.....

Show More ⇣


     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


Related Essays

Hiring Practices and Ethical Legal

Abstract Human resources managers are increasingly called upon to contribute to ethical decision making in their hiring practices. Hiring policies and practices are a critical gateway to fulfilling organizational ethical commitments. Using standard screening methods like background checks or screening applicant social media accounts present ethical dilemmas, pitting the need for due diligence against the need to resist any form of discrimination in hiring. By engaging in hiring policies and practices that reflect legal ground rules and also ethical codes, human resources managers achieve critical security goals and also protect the legal and ethical rights of employees. Key issues to take… Continue Reading...

Ethics in Corrections

in the fulfilment of their day to day duties and responsibilities. Next, a number of practical work scenarios where ethical decision making is required are highlighted, with an evaluation of the relevance of theoretical perspectives to the scenarios. Finally, a code of ethics and best-practices checklist relevant for correctional officers is presented, clearly demonstrating how the code will positively impact all the stakeholders, correctional officers work with. Job Description Correctional authorities are generally involved in rehabilitating offenders. Correctional personnel play a crucial role in achieving this end. This role entails admitting inmates, delivering meals to inmates, maintaining law and order within correctional facilities, retaining the accepted standards within the… Continue Reading...

Enron Ethics and Leadership Failures

market system. Barely addressing environmental and social justice issues, the filmmakers instead choose to focus on organizational culture, leadership, and ethical decision making within the corporation. The film illustrates the core concepts of business ethics and shows how executives shape company values and behaviors. Disturbingly, the Enron case also shows how unethical corporate behavior is linked with unethical behavior in government. Summarize in one paragraph how you would explain Enron's ethical meltdown Enron's ethical meltdown is a result of two interrelated issues: unethical individuals making unethical decisions, and an organizational culture that enables unethical decisions to proliferate. The unethical decisions and behaviors mainly have to do with stock market manipulation… Continue Reading...

Business Ethics Practices Compliance Auditing

intervene, changing their business practices to become more aligned with ethical principles. The Role of Ethical Decision Making All organizations have a direct responsibility to perform ethically and to engage in ethical business practices. Ethical decision making starts with senior management, which sets the ethical tone for the entire organization. Even with strong codes of ethics, leaders have the power and ability to engage in unethical business practices. The normative environment in the organization needs to reflect the values and principles set by the leaders. Leaders become the role models for others in the organization, and with collective, collaborative decision making, all senior managers can… Continue Reading...

Adam Smith Capitalism Ethics and Business

Shteynberg, Gelfland, et al. (2012). Cojuhuarenco, Shteynberg, Gelfland, et al. (2012) also show how gender and self concept impact ethical decision making as much as the normative ethical culture in the organization. An abundance of research reveals the detrimental effects of unethical behavior in organizations (Askew, Beisler & Keel, 2015). Given the deleterious effects of unethical behavior… Continue Reading...

Cisco Ethics Idol Case Study

company developed Ethics Idol as a more engaging and exciting alternative to PowerPoint presentations in training employees about ethical decision making. Question #1. What are the advantages of Ethics Idol as an ethics training communication medium over in-person PowerPoint training? A survey of ethics and compliance issues training at Cisco found out that employees regarded the in-person PowerPoint based exercise boring, dull, and unexciting. This is more so the case given that in essence, what the company had been doing was forcing employees to cram compliance and ethics information using a standard and rigid PowerPoint presentation approach. Ethics Idol is not only exciting, but also invigorating. Unlike a… Continue Reading...

Healthcare Organization

years. This prize shows the organization’s pledge to undertake what is right, whether it is for the caregivers, the patients, the community or for the organization as a whole. Furthermore, the healthcare organization is devoted to transparency, social responsibility, environmental stewardship and also ethical decision making in all aspects of the entity. In recent years, Cleveland Clinic has set up programs that manage possible conflicts of interest, provide transparency on the industry associations of physicians and researchers, openly report clinical results and promote ecologically friendly building and sustainability programs (Cleveland Clinic, 2018). 4. Efficacious Quality Management The Cleveland Clinic has made significant endeavors to ensure there is effective quality management and patient safety. Specifically, the healthcare organization has developed a Quality and Patient Safety Institute. The institute basically lays emphasis on reconnecting quality… Continue Reading...

sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Ethical Decision-Making" (2011, October 09) Retrieved May 14, 2024, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/ethical-decision-making-46215

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Ethical Decision-Making" 09 October 2011. Web.14 May. 2024. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/ethical-decision-making-46215>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Ethical Decision-Making", 09 October 2011, Accessed.14 May. 2024,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/ethical-decision-making-46215