Immigration Policy Term Paper

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document

Total Length: 2252 words ( 8 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 1+

Page 1 of 8

Wet Foot Dry Foot Policy

History of Cuban Immigration

Opposition to wet foot dry foot

Fidel Castro

Haitian American Activist

Elian Gonzalez

Recent Haitian Immigrants

Human Right Advocates

immigration policy has long been the center of much debate. In recent months the treatment of Haitian immigrants has come into question. Many in the Haitian American community question why Cuban immigrants are granted asylum while Haitians and other immigrants are deported. The purpose of this discussion is to explore the immigration policy of wet foot dry foot and to determine why this policy is such a controversial topic.

Defining the wet foot dry foot policy

The wet foot dry foot policy was enacted in the late 90's and permitted under the 1966 Cuban adjustment act the policy allows an individual who flees Cuba the right to stay in the United States if there feet touch the shore or the soil. ("Wet Foot Dry Foot") The Clinton administration feared an influx of Cuban immigrant so the administration voted to continue the policy. ("Wet Foot Dry Foot")

Now Bush administration has decided to continue to implement the policy. ("Wet Foot Dry Foot")

The policy is believed to reduce the amount of Cuban immigrants that enter the country. As the article states, "The policy staunched the flow of rafters, but it added another layer of inconsistency to U.S. immigration policy." ("Wet Foot Dry Foot")

The wet foot dry foot policy dictates that if an individual does not reach shore they must prove that they will face persecution if they are returned to Cuba. ("Wet Foot Dry Foot") The policy was enacted in wake of the Cold War and the mounting displeasure that the American Government had towards Cuban dictator Fidel Castro.

Cuban immigrants are the only immigrant group that benefit from this policy. Supposedly, the reason for this is because Cubans are viewed as political exiles that are fleeing harsh dictatorships. Many believe that the policy is hypocritical because it grants citizenship to one group but not to others. Others believe that the law is needed for Cubans fleeing political persecution and poverty.

History of Cuban Immigration

According to an Agenda paper created by Max Castro of the University of Miami, "Historically, the average number of Cuban immigrants entering the United States from 1960 to 1962 and from 1965 to 1973 was significantly higher than the annual average during the last decade." (Castro)

Castro goes on to explain that the ratios of Dominican, Haitian and Jamaican immigrants exceeded the number of Cubans that entered the country during the 1990's. (Castro)

There are reasons why the influx of Cuban immigrants has decreased. Castro asserts that the, reason for limited Cuban migration is U.S. policy toward Cuban immigrants, which has moved, in fits and starts, from one of nearly unconditional acceptance of all Cubans fleeing the island to a more restrictive approach. The U.S.-Cuba immigration agreement of 1994 has succeeded in substantially normalizing the migration process, but the "wet-feet/dry-feet" policy represents a significant loophole that encourages unsafe, unregulated, and unauthorized migration often carried out by smugglers of human cargo and costly in human life."(Castro)

Opposition to Wet foot dry foot

There are many who believe that the wet foot dry foot policy should not exist. On the other hand, others oppose the fact that the policy has not been extended to include all immigrant groups. Still others believe that the policy violates human rights laws.

For the purposes of this discussion we will discuss the opposition of Fidel Castro and his government. We will also discuss why Haitian Americans oppose the fact that the policy has not been extended to Haitians. In addition we will explore why some feel that the policy violates human rights laws.

Fidel Castro

Chief among the opponents of this law is Fidel Castro. Castro believes that the current U.S. policy towards Cubans encourages people to risk their lives. In an article entitled "Castro Blasts U.S. Immigration Policy for Cubans" Fidel asserted that the policy was a "diabolical killing machine."(Fletcher)The article also state that the 1967 Cuban Adjustment Act encouraged illegal attempts by Cubans to leave the communist-ruled island by sea, whether in flimsy homemade boats and rafts or with the help of U.S.-based smugglers. This had lured many Cubans to death by drowning in the Florida Straits and was continuing to do so, he added. He was speaking at the end of a meeting of Cuba's Women's Federation. (Fletcher)

Cuba has often called its citizens to protest the American Immigration policy stating that it persuades Cubans to take huge risks with their lives.

Stuck Writing Your "Immigration Policy" Term Paper?

View All Our Example Immigration Policy Term Paper

Have A Custom Example Essay Written

("Cuba calls for protests denouncing U.S. immigration policy") In September of 2000 the Cuban government persuaded the citizens to protest the policy in light of the deaths of Cuban Migrants who were attempting to leave the country and come to America. ("Cuba calls for protests denouncing U.S. immigration policy") The Cuban government also believes that the American Government can do more to prevent smuggling rings that smuggle people out of Cuba to America. ("Cuba calls for protests denouncing U.S. immigration policy")

Haitians

Much of the opposition to the Wet Foot Dry Foot Policy has come from the Haitian American Population. Many believe that the same immigration policies that have been extended to Cubans should be extended to Haitians and other immigrant populations.. It has been asserted that the current policy is racist and attempts to exclude persons with black skin. This belief isn't just confined to the Haitian community, though many activists are Haitian Americans.

The Haitian Americans have protested and lobbied congress to have the law extended to Haitian Americans. BBC News reports that,

Haitian Americans have demonstrated outside the immigration service in Miami following the expulsion of more than 400 would-be immigrants from Haiti. The activists said U.S. immigration policy was racist, highlighting the difference in the treatment of Haitian and Cuban migrants. ("U.S. immigration policy branded 'racist'")

The Haitian American Community represents the largest segment of new immigrants to Florida and most that reach Florida are deported. The government's excuse for treating Cubans differently "is that the Cubans are fleeing Fidel Castro's communist government and are assumed to face political persecution if they are returned.... most of the Haitians are economic, not political, refugees and not entitled to asylum." ("U.S. Policy Favors Cuban Refugees") The Justice Department estimates that asylum applications handled by immigration courts in during the years of 2000 through 2001 shows that courts denied 88% of the asylum applications submitted by Haitians. ("U.S. Policy Favors Cuban Refugees") Haitian activists make it clear that they do not wish to eradicate the current policy for Cubans. They only want the policy to be extended to Haitians. ("U.S. Policy Favors Cuban Refugees")

Elian Gonzalez

Many in the Haitian community use the Elian Gonzalez case as a point of reference. Elian Gonzalez was a six-year-old boy from Cuba who was found at sea when the boat he escaped from Cuba in capsized.. ("U.S. immigration policy branded 'racist'")

Gonzalez was allowed to stay in the country for a while even though his feet did not to American land under his own will.

US immigration policy branded 'racist'")

Haitian activists were hopeful that this would set a precedent if Elian was allowed to stay in the country. However Elian was sent back to Cuba where his father lived. This notwithstanding the Elian Gonzalez case was very controversial and brought into question America's immigration policies. ("U.S. immigration policy branded 'racist'")

Recent Haitian Immigrants

On October 29, 2002 a boat crowded with 200 Haitian refugees arrived in downtown Miami. ("U.S. Policy Favors Cuban Refugees")Haitian Americans are furious because if these immigrants had been Cuban they would have been allowed to stay in America until it was determined that they could qualify as exiles. In the case of the Haitian refugees they will probably be sent back to Haiti. ("U.S. Policy Favors Cuban Refugees") City councilman Jacques Despinosse stated that, "If you come here from a communist country, it's OK. If you come from a white country, it's OK. If you come here from a black country, noncommunist, it's not OK."("U.S. Policy Favors Cuban Refugees")

The article also reports that Representative Meek, a black Democrat, confronted Governor Bush during a campaign stop in October, trying to persuade him to call President Bush and urge him to free the Haitian immigrants. ("U.S. Policy Favors Cuban Refugees") Representative Meek Stated "All you have to do is call -- the wet-foot, dry-foot policy would take effect," she said. "You can do it."("U.S. Policy Favors Cuban Refugees") Reportedly Representative Meek and other activists will form a protest March that will convene on Washington in February. ("U.S. Policy Favors Cuban Refugees")

The article also asserts that the different economic situations between the Haitian American community and the Cuban American community perpetuate the differences in the immigration policy. ("U.S. Policy Favors Cuban Refugees") For Instance the "South Florida's Cuban-American community has grown into a powerful economic and political force since the first wave of refugees….....

Show More ⇣

     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


Related Essays

History of Immigration in United States

American immigration policy and population patterns have changed in response to labor demands and economic forces, as well as shifts in American identity and social norms. Global forces have also shaped immigration patterns over the past hundred years. Anti-immigration sentiments have also strongly influenced immigration policies, with the most notable examples from a century ago being the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 and the Nativist movement of the 1920s (Young 1). Similar Nativist sentiments bubbled to the surface during the Trump administration, clouding constructive discourse on the role and status of… Continue Reading...

Whether Immigration is a Problem or Not

One of the most contentious political issues today is immigration. Many countries grapple with their immigration policy, the United States included. Even though the United States was founded by settlers and has been a nation of immigrants ever since, the discourse towards immigration policy has occasionally been hostile. The hostility towards immigration is a problem, but immigration itself is not at all a problem. In fact, immigration improves overall quality of life, builds a safer and more productive society, and builds both economic and cultural capital. One of the reasons why immigration is not a problem is that it improves the overall quality of life… Continue Reading...

Illegal Immigration Essay

immigration policy needs to be improved in one way or another—either towards greater inclusivity and acceptance of immigrants (making it easier for them to enter the country) or towards more restrictive measures that prevent so many immigrants from entering (measures like a wall or the end of DACA. Titles The Problem of Illegal Immigration Protecting America’s Borders:  Ending Illegal Immigration Why Illegal Immigration is Not as Bad as They Make It Out to Be The Thin Line between Legal and Illegal Immigration Outline I.  Introduction II.  Body a.  Illegal immigration… Continue Reading...

Muslim Americans and the Impact of September 11th

both demonizing the Muslim community in America and promoting a view of American immigration policy that is anti-Muslim.[footnoteRef:3] This paper will show that the changes in U.S. immigration policy post 9-11 have negatively affected American Muslims in several ways as a result of inherently racist legislation specifically targeting all Muslims regardless of whether they are U.S. citizens or not. [1: Jigyasu, R. "Defining the Definition for Addressing the 'Reality'," in What is a Disaster?: New Answers to Old Questions, Ed. Ronald W. Perry & E.L. Quarantelli. International Research Committee on Disasters, 2005.] [2: Sheridan, L. (2006). Islamophobia pre- and post-September 11th, 2001. Journal… Continue Reading...

How Immigrants Deal with Discrimination

convince all audiences of the need for a more empathetic immigration policy. In the end, the book might best function as a fine accompaniment to other undocumented migrant-related researches and literature for scholarly audiences (Emily 470). American migrant experiences are closely associated with individual migrants’ nationalities, socioeconomic standing and race. The writer bravely tackles a few stereotypes specific to Mexican migrants, in a candid and personal manner. Migrant stereotypes have remained a grave issue, whether in the case of Second-World-War era Japanese Americans, Chinese migrants employed on Western railroad lines, or Irish migrants towards the nineteenth century’s close. A discussion… Continue Reading...

Trump Versus Hawaii

The main aim of this text is to highlight the misdeeds of the trump administration ruling on the immigration policy to the extent of the law. Legal precedence always follows facts and without that, the law is void and needs clarification. In the constrained view of the case, there is need to look at the implications on the economics, culture, outlook and psychology of the people involved. The law affects immigrants from all nations of Islam. The need to get the law right on this one is still in contention since various factions argue to differ. The law states clearly that America is land of the free but… Continue Reading...

DACA Protest

late 2017. The current protests are related to the need to resolve this issue and promote compassionate immigration policy in the United States. Observations of the Event Participation in and observation of this rally helps reveal the important role political protest plays in a democracy. The protest was peaceful, and involved hundreds of people marching with signs and chanting slogans and catchphrases. At one point, there was a speaker who delivered a short address on a temporary stage. It was evident that this event was planned and organized, and had the full support of the city because of the way the stage had been set up and… Continue Reading...

sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Immigration Policy" (2002, November 17) Retrieved April 27, 2024, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/immigration-policy-139015

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Immigration Policy" 17 November 2002. Web.27 April. 2024. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/immigration-policy-139015>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Immigration Policy", 17 November 2002, Accessed.27 April. 2024,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/immigration-policy-139015
   

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document
order custom essay example