Illegal Immigration Term Paper

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document

Total Length: 4365 words ( 15 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 1+

Page 1 of 15

Illegal Immigration

Both the United States government and individual state governments as well are concerned about the high rate of illegal immigration into our country. There are several reasons for this. Since the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, the country recognizes great need to know exactly who is in the United States. In addition, many worry that illegal immigrants take jobs that would otherwise go to people who are legally in the country. School districts struggle to educate the children of adult illegal immigrants. Some at the federal, state and local levels of governments believe that illegal immigrants put a strain on welfare programs and feel such services should go to people who are here legally. The problem is multi-faceted, and different government entities have differing concerns, making agreement about what should be done difficult.

SCOPE OF THE PROBLEM

However, most people are law-abiding residents of the United States and believe that others should obey the law as well. Although the United States has open borders, both Immigration and Customs officers attempt to make sure that people who travel or move here do so legally. In 2003, for instance, these officials arrested over 7,000 illegal immigrants between March and September, 112% more than in the same period for the year 2003. However, many more slipped through their nets, and the problem of illegal immigration into the United States continue to grow (Johnson, 2005).

In addition to the sheer volume of illegal immigrants, in spite of recent increases in staff, the United States does not have enough staff to prevent most illegal immigration (Johnson, 2005). Illegal immigrants move easily across United States borders with both Mexico and Canada, especially in the more unpopulated areas.

In addition, those who smuggle illegal immigrants continue to come up with new ways to move people across the border. Recently, federal officials forced a small plane down in Texas and found four Chinese nationals without proper documentation to enter the United States aboard (Badger, 2005).

But although the laws regarding who may and may not legally enter the United States are clear, many illegal immigrants not only enter the United States but find themselves welcome in some industries as well, because often these visitors are hired to work in agriculture, construction, and the service industries. Willing to work cheaply, they help keep costs down for a variety of public commodities including meals in restaurants and even new homes. However, since these people earn a marginal income, they often put a strain on public services as well as the public schools. Importantly, because our borders are porous and we have no real way of blocking illegal immigrants, this creates vulnerability for national security (Radelat, 2004a).

We send out mixed messages, both to the illegal immigrants and those who hire them. One of President Bush's recent nominations for head of Homeland Security had to step down after he realized that his use of an illegal immigrant in his home as a housekeeper would become public. Breaking the law tends to lead to more law-breaking; it isn't possible to pay employment taxes on someone who is living and working illegally. In the case of the nominee his situation was particularly embarrassing because as head of Homeland Security he would have been expected to enforce immigration laws and help find ways for immigration laws to be enforced more effectively (Sanchez, 2004).

CURRENT PUBLIC POLICY

At the federal level, we are unprepared to deal with illegal immigrants. The federal government has space to house only about 19,500 illegal immigrants, with every space occupied. A law passed by congress in an attempt to help future terrorism attacks passed, and this law should expand capacity, but it's not clear how quickly or completely this can be done. (Johnson, 2005) In addition, much of the information held by the United States government on illegal immigrants is out of date. So, while immigration officials estimate that there are about 400,000 illegals in the country, they can't be sure. They don't know whether that number is accurate or not (Johnson, 2005).

Because we have no way to hold all the illegal immigrants caught, the government has taken a "catch and release" approach, sort of like being released on one's own recognance after being arrested for some crimes. The problem is that most people who are released on their own recognance have roots in the community, a fairly permanent address and a job. If they don't report back to the court as required to, the court knows where to find them. The situation for illegal immigrants, however, is quite different.

Stuck Writing Your "Illegal Immigration" Term Paper?

View All Our Example Illegal Immigration Term Paper

Have A Custom Example Essay Written

But since the government is out of space to hold them, they have no choice.

Many illegal immigrants know this. As soon as they have crossed the border, they present themselves to the Border Police, knowing that they will be released if they agree to appear in court. However, five out of six skip their court dates and become fugitives. However, they are fugitives in a system that has little capability to trace their location (Johnson, 2005).

POSSIBLE SOLUTIONS

Federal

Recognizing that we don't know who is here illegally but that many illegal immigrants hold jobs, President Bush has proposed giving legal status as "guest workers" to those already here and employed. This would at least identify some of these unknown residents and provide some sort of accurate information about where they are. However, many people are opposed to this policy. They see it as rewarding people for sneaking into the country.

Another option is the "Real ID Act. This law attempts to maintain the country's willingness to welcome people from other countries while watching out for the nation's security. The law would use driver's licenses, asylum laws, a border fence south of San Diego and increased deportation. This law's supporters believe that the combination of open borders and failure to enforce immigration laws make it far too easy for terrorists to enter the country and then disappear. The law would require substantial evidence of both identity and immigration status before issuing either driver's licenses or state identity cards. The cards themselves would be made harder to forge.

The "Real ID" bill would: Establish rigorous proof of identity and immigration status requirements for all applicants for driver's licenses and state- issued identity cards, as well as strong security requirements for all cards issued (CHP, 2005). It would toughen requests for asylum, accelerate construction of a border fence between southern California and Mexico, which has run into opposition from environmental concerns, and strengthen authority to deport those suspected of being terrorists (CHP, 2005).

State

Individual states have taken steps to curb illegal immigration as well. Arizona, like California, shares a border with Mexico, and feels that its agencies and finances have been unduly impacted by the needs of people who entered the country illegally. Arizona now requires proof that an immigrant is in the country legally before the person and his or her family can receive some government services. It requires proof of citizenship in order to vote. In addition, the government workers who enforce this law are subject to fine and/or jail time if they do not report illegal immigrants who attempt to get state services (Shoren, 2004). This initiative is known as "Proposition 200." California, Colorado, Idaho and Georgia are all considering similar laws (Radelat, 2004b).

Other states are frustrated that the federal government provides inadequate support for dealing with the ever-growing numbers of illegal aliens. The National Immigration Forum says that the numbers of illegal immigrants is in the millions, and that states must find solutions to cope with the high numbers (Radelat, 2004b). Both Florida and Alabama have initiated programs that allow their local authorities to enforce federal immigration laws. Virginia and Arkansas may follow in their footsteps (Radelat, 2004b).

While some states, such as Arizona, have passed laws intended to discourage illegal immigration, other states have taken a different approach. These states have decided that many undocumented immigrants can make a contribution to society, and that some federal restrictions should be loosened (Radelat, 2004b).

Since our government reserves some areas for federal law and some are turned over to states for administration and enforcement, some friction has developed particularly around the issue of driver's license. Ten states currently allow illegal immigrants to get driver's licenses, although Tennessee marks such licenses "for driving purposes only." (Radelat, 2004b) Illinois may soon allow illegal immigrants to acquire driver's license as well, because both the insurance industry and immigration advocates have convinced the legislature of Illinois that it's much safer to make sure that people who drive have passed a driving test and are competent to do so. However, critics recognize the driver's license as an important piece of personal identification and do not think those who are here illegally should be able to acquire one (Radelat, 2004b).

Eight states go much further. They provide tuition rebates to the children of illegal immigrants who attend state colleges and universities, even though this means they lose some….....

Show More ⇣

     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


Related Essays

Illegal Immigration Essay

Abstract This illegal immigration essay example provides an examination of all the different parts of a paper of this type that you will need to know when writing your own.  Specifically, it looks at possible topics to cover related to illegal immigration, a variety of essay titles that could help to catch the reader’s interest, a sample outline of how to structure the essay, an introduction for a paper on illegal immigration, an essay hook to keep the reader invested in the paper, a possible thesis statement, and the different elements of… Continue Reading...

Immigration in America

when that foreign country is determined to address immigration issues—not only illegal immigration but also legal immigration—it can become a difficult problem for both sides of the political aisle. For a nation like the United States, that is especially true. After all, America was founded by immigrants. The early Spanish and French missionaries came in the 16th century seeking converts to Christianity. The Puritans and English followed. The Germans and Italians and Irish and Polish all came to America in the wake of Industrialization. Over time, America was host to so many different populations and groups of people that it was… Continue Reading...

Immigration Essay

   1. Background        2. Immigration Patterns      3. Social: Effects of Illegal Immigration      4. Political: Trump’s Stand Against Illegals III.  Conclusion Introduction: Immigration to the United States dates all the way back to the 1500’s with Roanoke Island and continued with British colonists, leading up to the South American, Central American, and Mexican waves of immigration that make up most immigration patterns today. Although the waves of immigration have changed throughout the history of the country, most of the same problems occur. From assimilation to a new country, to social pressures, and political reforms, being an immigrant in the… Continue Reading...

Immigration in the United Kingdom

illegal immigration.[footnoteRef:4] Since voters voted for Brexit years ago, there has been a general consensus that the motive was in part related to a desire to separate England from the open borders policy of the EU. By cracking down on immigration, Parliament believed it could potentially satisfy the public and perhaps lessen the demand for a hard or no-deal Brexit. However, what happened was that British citizens ended up being rounded up and deported to a land they had not seen in decades and that some had never seen in… Continue Reading...

National Security Impact of Immigration Policy

illegal immigration, which may be defined as a cross- border shift of individuals in violation of the destination’s migration regulation. Between the sixties and mid- seventies, illegal immigration positively influenced destination nations. However, in the two decades that followed, it began to be viewed as an unwelcome phenomenon having negative effects. After the terror attacks of 9/11, negative attitudes towards migration skyrocketed and currently, it is considered a grave security risk. Europe’s enlargement has caused its boundaries to expand farther and EU has started regarding migration as a threat to… Continue Reading...

Implementing Compassionate Immigration Reform

solution, of course, since this still leaves two enormous coasts that are highly vulnerable to illegal immigration. In other words, merely building more and higher barriers along the nation’s borders is not the answer to illegal immigration. In the business world, it is axiomatic that in order to better understand a complicated situation, it is important to “follow the money.” Applied to illegal immigration, it is reasonable to suggest that the overwhelming majority of those who seek to enter the country illegally do so for better economic opportunities compared to their countries of origin (Bender, 2010). This aspect of “follow the money” is straightforward enough… Continue Reading...

Counter Terrorism Community Policing and Changes

communication among various departments and has enabled information sharing. 2. Javier's attitude toward illegal immigration is understandable and it is helpful to have someone like him on the force. Too often, officers react in rigid ways to the perceived threat of illegal immigration because they have been told by the media and perhaps by their superior officers to take an antagonistic approach to illegal immigrants. Javier understands that the situation with immigration is too complex to warrant a knee-jerk negative response. Instead of presuming that all illegal immigrants are threats to the integrity of the community, police officers would be better off focusing… Continue Reading...

Latinos and Deportation Arrests

that some communities have is that this crackdown on illegal immigration will upset a carefully crafted balance between whites and Latinos, one that has taken years to develop. In America, race is always an issue and one that many people seek to overcome in order to promote concepts of equality and fraternity. At the same time, the agenda of the Trump Administration is nothing new, as Hernandez (2008) shows: “as a critical enforcement practice within the history of racialization and criminalization of nonwhite immigrants in the US, noncitizen detention pursuant to the deportation of immigrants has been utilized throughout… Continue Reading...

Persuasive Speech

Outline I.) Introduction a. Attention Getter: Think about the concerns tied to illegal immigration such as terrorism, lack of jobs, costs in terms of tax and how prevalent it is becoming in the present day. b. Relevance: Illegal immigration in the United States is the highest in the world compared to any other nation. c. In accordance to statistics, there were approximately 11.1 million illegal immigrants in the United States (Krogstad et al.) d. Credibility: I have done research on illegal immigration, its benefits and shortcomings from various secondary sources. e. Thesis: I am going to urge you to see the need… Continue Reading...

Strategies to Improve Collaboration and Cooperation Between the Homeland Security Agencies

DHS also targets such unethical employers. The immigration department The U.S. ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement) aims at protecting Americans from illegal immigration and crimes across the border as well as from anything that might compromise the safety and security of the public (Homeland Security, 2018).The objectives of the security department are achieved by way of enforcing the numerous federal statutes. Focus is given to the enforcement of smart immigration, alleviation of illegal transfer of goods and people, and prevention of terrorism (Homeland Security, 2018). The enforcement of immigration laws and regulations is the one most conspicuous ICE responsibility. Certain aspects of ICE duties revolve around cooperation and collaboration with the… Continue Reading...

Radical Negotiation Posturing and Political Strategies Trump and Alinsky

have little efficacy in ceasing illegal immigration or enhancing security, the ostensible purposes of building the wall. Alinsky’s Ethics: Rules Do Not Matter In Rules for Radicals, Alinsky famously declared that “One’s concern with the ethics of means and ends varies inversely with one’s personal interest in the issue, and one’s distance from the scene of conflict” (Alinsky, 2010, p.26). Alinsky stated that one man’s terrorist is another man’s freedom fighter—hence, those opposed to the Nazis regarded members of the Resistance as heroic figures, while the Nazis themselves regarded the Resistance as the enemy. Similarly,… Continue Reading...

Psychology Questionnaire

example, the separation of families to detract illegal immigration and the support of Trump fans for this action shows the level of denial supporters have for the suffering of this specific population. The supporters remove the emotional component and simply peg the parents of the illegal children as criminals that deserve such punishment for illegally crossing the border. They cease seeing illegals or asylum seekers as people, and instead, see them as deserving of such policy changes. “Such emotionally based policies can interfere with our capacity to effectively and humanely confront many problems our nation faces. The… Continue Reading...

sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Illegal Immigration" (2005, January 31) Retrieved April 28, 2024, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/illegal-immigration-61531

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Illegal Immigration" 31 January 2005. Web.28 April. 2024. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/illegal-immigration-61531>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Illegal Immigration", 31 January 2005, Accessed.28 April. 2024,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/illegal-immigration-61531
   

Open, View, and/or
Download this Document
order custom essay example