New York Term Paper

Total Length: 1683 words ( 6 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 1+

Page 1 of 6

New York City: An Examination of Urban Design and Space Function as it Relates to Civic Participation

The objective of this study is to examine urban design and space function as it relates to civic participation in New York City. Kevin Lynch conducted systematic and scientific-based research on urban design in his exploration of the elements of urban design. Lynch stated that every individual "has had a long association with some parts of his city and his image is soaked in memories and meaning." (1960, p.2) The goal of Lynch is reported to be the study of the city's mental images held by its citizens. Lynch focused his work on the city's visual quality or the "apparent clarity and 'legibility of the city-scape." What Lynch meant was the level of ease with which the city's parts could be organized into a pattern that was of a coherent nature. The city, if visual is such that can be "grasped as a pattern of recognizable symbols." (Marling, 2008, p.3) Marling (2008) reports that the results of Lynch's studies "is that a legible city could be one of the districts, landmarks, or pathways of which are easily identifiable and grouped into an overall pattern" and in what was Lynch's interest in the city "as a communication system, communicating memories, history and identity." (2008, p.3) Lynch's study involved talking to the inhabitants of three different cities for the purpose of developing and testing his ideas relating to "imageability, and also by comparing image with reality to learn which forms make for strong images." (Marling, 2008, p.3) Lynch then went on to interview local individuals in the three cities and asked the individuals to respond to questions about what symbolizes their city and to draw a city map on a piece of paper including their route from home to work describing what they heard, saw, and smelled and their feelings. The city maps were studied and then compared with professionally prepared maps and findings included that five distinct elements existing including: (1) path; (2) edge; (3) district; (4) node; and (5) landmark. Lynch held that these five elements were useful as "building blocks for urban designers giving form to new urban projects." (Marling, 2008, p. 4) Lynch is noted as stating as follows:

"In such a whole paths would expose and prepare for the districts, and link together the various nodes. The nodes would joint and mark the paths, while the edges would bound off the districts and the landmark would indicate their cores. It is the total orchestration of these units which would knit together a dense and vivid image, and sustain it over areas of metropolitan scale" (Lynch, 1960 p.108)

In an interview with Paul Fraiolli published in Columbia University's Journal of International Affairs, Rem Koolhaas states that what is witnesses more than anything is "the inability of almost every political system to anticipate, mobilize, and take precautions for the future, even when it is obvious that cities will grow or shrink rapidly." (2012, p.1) In the case of New York City, with a population that doubled and then some in the early part of the 20th century, the city administrators were concerns with the interlacing of communication and transportation systems to create coherence within the metropolitan area." (Christian Science Monitor, 2013, p.1)

I. New York City Boroughs

The system's first segment opened in 1904 and the boroughs were all linked except that of Staten Island. The transportation system is reported to have handled in excess of two billion passengers each year. There are presently hundreds of thousands of 'outer borough' residents working in Manhattan or traveling to Manhattan each day. All the boroughs are reported to rank in the U.S.'s largest cities except Staten Island.

There are complaints from legislators in the boroughs that they concerns are not acknowledged and beliefs exist that interests of the locale are sacrificed for the welfare of Manhattan.
This resulted in Staten Island seceding from New York City in the 1990s and becoming an independent city. Problems with governing the boroughs of New York City include the aspect of civic engagement and involvement on the part of citizens of these areas. Due to the problems in New York City with transportation means and with public space availability for meeting with the public on civic and government issues, there has been a failure of engaging the individuals residing in the various boroughs of New York City.

II. Placemaking and Governance

Technology is reported to have enhanced the governing of boroughs in that NYC Votes, a public-private partnership that has sought to "promote voter registration, participation, and civic engagement in elections through technology." (Pivotal Labs, 2013, p.1) It is reported that Pivotal Labs in collaboration with Method and AppOrchard, assisted the New York City Campaign Finance Board (CFB) and its Voter Assistance Committee (VAAC) in the creation of a "mobile website that will streamline the political process for voters and candidates alike." (Pivotal Labs, 2013, p.1) The mission of VAAC is the increasing of civic engagement in all local elections through providing encouragement to New Yorkers to register and vote. However, there is still the problem of the actual governance of the boroughs but the Project for Public Space (PPS) has a model that it believes will be effective toward this end. The work of Kent (2013) reports that governance "is not set up to create great places. Indeed the current culture and structure of government and civic infrastructure may be the greatest obstacle to successful 'Placemaking'." (Kent, 2013, p.1) Kent states as follows about 'placemaking':

"When a government organizes itself around creating successful public spaces and generating Place Capital, it is often able to accomplish a broad range of existing goals more efficiently. When performing at their best, communities organize to compete to contribute to the public realm and shared value. Indeed, the most loved places were invariably created through this often informally generated culture of governance." (Kent, 2013, p.1)

Kent states that public space management is the latest in place government and both informal and formal management of public spaces ensure that the spaces are workable. Research findings show that by using the 'placemaking' process that governments are able to "self-govern, by creating a culture of engagement in the community that supports a given space." (Kent, 2013, p.1) Placemaking is reported to both identify and attract local leadership, resources, and partners on all community and governmental levels. Kent asks the question of: "What if a central focus of governance became: the building of successful places?" And states as an answer "there is general comfort and energy to make that happen, to work together in new ways. The fractured, siloed structure of contemporary government, with its myriad departments and bureaucratic processes, often directly impedes the creation of successful public spaces. Transportation departments view their mission as moving traffic; parks departments are there to create and manage open green space; community development agencies are focused on development of projects, not the spaces in between them or the organic opportunities that arise from social interactions within them." (Kent, 2013, p.1)

II. Typical vs. Placemaking Governance Structure

The typical governance structure is one that has political leadership at the top of the ladder with public administration in the middle and the community at the lower level of the rungs of the governance ladder. The typical governance structure is characterized by the following: (1) Problem-focused; (2) politically motivated; (3) a short-term focus; (4) a bureaucratic process; (5) siloed departments; (6) resistant citizens; (7) incremental change; and (8) limited participation of buy-in of citizens in the community. (Kent, 2013, p.1) The following illustration conveys this structure.

Figure 1

Source: (Kent, 2013, p.1)

The placemaking governance structure by contrast.....

Show More ⇣


     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


Related Essays

Impact of Stop Frisk Policy in New York

Racial Impacts The NYPD (NY Police Department) stop and frisk policy is a policy introduced by the New York City mandating the police officers to stop pedestrians and frisks them for contraband, and weapons. The rules are cited in the Section 140.50 in the New York criminal procedure law. In 2011, the NY police force used the frisk policy rule to stop approximately 685,724 people, however, the number reduced to 22,939 in 2015. The policy has become a controversial issue because over 5 million people were frisked during the first decade after introducing the policy. In 2002, the numbers of the reported cases were 685,724 in 2011… Continue Reading...

Tammany Hall in New York City

worse today than it was back then). Essentially, election fraud had been a huge problem in New York, what with the Tammany Hall government attempting to get its Irish Catholic supporters to register at multiple locations in order to vote early and vote often (and thus keep Tammany Hall in power). Teddy Roosevelt, as a member of the Police Board of Commissioners at the end of the 19th century had pledged to combat fraud and corruption and crack down on this type of abuse of the elections process—which is why Lawless’ crime was significant. Roosevelt had moved on from the Police Board in New York—to the… Continue Reading...

Assessment of Security at City Hall New York

Assessment of security at city hall New York, 15 Center Street Introduction The New York City hall is the seat of the New York City government. The building is located at the center of the city hall park, civic center, lower Manhattan. The New York City hall is the oldest city hall in the United States of America and it houses the mayor’s office, the staff of some of the municipal agencies (White & Willensky, 2000). Despite its age, the building has been installed with various traditional and new security systems. This essay is an analysis… Continue Reading...

Nightclub Business Plan New York

the better it is the further it will draw from. This is New York, so competition is intense. The demographic will be mixed, reflecting the population of New York. Young people of all demographics enjoy the nightclub experience, and we aim to be a safe and open space for all to have fun, so we are not specifically targeting white, black, Latin, Asian or Middle Eastern in particular. As such, we expect the demographic to be predominantly white, but maybe only 60% so, and it could end up being less. The nightclub will draw from the community of middle class and upper… Continue Reading...

New Jim Crow Mass Incarceration War on Drugs

New York: The New York Press, 2010, p. 2). ] Based on the extensive impact the War on Drugs has on American lives, mass incarceration is a civil rights issue, and a human rights issue. Mass incarceration is not at all a response to increased rates of crime; the notion that crime automatically drives incarceration rates is a myth. Alexander notes that “especially black incarceration rates have soared regardless of whether crime is going up or down in any given community or the nation as a whole.”[footnoteRef:4] In fact, the… Continue Reading...

New Jim Crow Essay

New Jim Crow Michelle Alexander, the author of The New Jim Crow, is a professor at Union Theological Seminary, a New York Times columnist, and civil rights lawyer and advocate.  I believe that the motive she had in writing her book was to explain how Jim Crow still exists in America even though people sometimes choose not to see it.  It exists today in hidden and not-so-hidden ways, as it is part of the power structure that still dominates America.  The prison industrial complex is just one example of how Jim Crow still exists, as Alexander shows.  Her aim is to draw attention to the mass incarceration system that is… Continue Reading...

Earthquakes

A) Write a summary of an article on the environment that was published in The New York Times between 1/22 and 1/28. This assignment is for 150 words. ANCHORAGE — The people of Alaska, spurred by the threat of a massive underwater earthquake which could result in a tsunami, evacuated the safety of their homes at midnight. Authorities had transformed schools into temporary evacuation units and citizens flocked there, parking their automobiles at Walmart and Safeway parking lots. Several rushed to the safe higher ground provided by Pillar Mountain. However, fortunately, the tsunami didn’t occur and in 4 hours’ time, the tsunami warning issued between… Continue Reading...

Water Conservation

Record. And That Was Without El Nino” in The New York Times focuses on how the earth’s temperature increased in 2017. What is surprising about this is that scientists at NASA ranked 2017 as the second hottest year since record-keeping began over a century ago. (The hottest year came in 2016, suggesting that a trend is shaping). More surprising still is the fact that there was no El Nino to contribute to the warm weather. In other words, the environment appears to be warming even without this considerable factor in past years. With that in mind, it is difficult… Continue Reading...

Unreasonable Searches and Seizures Article Reviews

Criminal Investigation: Article Reviews Eligon, J. (2011). Police sergeant to get jail term for perjury and illegal searches. The New York Times. Retrieved from: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/28/nyregion/nyc-police- sergeant-admits-illegal-searches-and-perjury.html This article highlights the problem of officers conducting illegal searches when they strongly suspect a suspect is guilty, even though they have no legally valid form of probable cause or a warrant to conduct such a search. These types of egregious actions are a source of mistrust and friction between members of the police force and the public. The officer’s lawyer, in an appeal for clemency, stated that the offending officer never arrested anyone who had not committed a crime after he had… Continue Reading...

Criminal Law Cases Examinations

if they hold the belief that they are in clear and present danger for severe bodily harm. 2. Consider the following: a. New York tried Goetz for attempted murder and assault. The jury acquitted him of both charges. The jury said Goetz “was justified in shooting the four men with the silver plated .38-caliber revolver he purchased in Florida.” They did convict him of illegal possession of a firearm, for which the court sentenced Goetz to one year in jail. b. Following the sentencing, Goetz told the court: “this case is really more about the deterioration of society than it is about me….I believe society needs to be protected from criminals.” Criminal… Continue Reading...

Central Park Loves and Hates

Central Park New York City is a very complex city. It is full of public spaces and areas. Examples include the subways, the sidewalks, the roads and so forth. However, something that is commonly missing is green space and massive areas of vegetation and landscaping. There is one best example of an exception to this that is also a public space. This, of course, would be Central Park. There are many good to great things to say about that area. However, there are other things that are less than positive, although it… Continue Reading...

Someone to Watch Over Me by Ridley Scott

outset of Scott's film. After a sweeping view of New York City at night, blue skyscrapers lit up by electric light, while the music that modifies the scene consists of a slow, nightclub type of song sung by a crooner -- the film settles over a view of the New York City suburbs -- and cuts to the interior of a small home, where guests are pouring in through the front door, some in civilian dress, others in their police uniform. The halls and rooms are densely packed, and many hugs, kisses and smiles are seen. The home is… Continue Reading...

Andrea Yates Case

of crime. He later claimed that he acted out of love for the then American president. According to the New York Times he stated that he was in love with Forster like Romeo and Juliet. He was later tried. He was acquitted because he was found to be insane. He was sent to a psychiatry facility for help (Biography.com Editors, 2017). The McNaughton Rule was adopted in the US and UK and was applied to judge the standard of right and wrong for many years. In fact, the rule is used as a standard of insanity test in nearly half of the states in the USA. The Durham Rule… Continue Reading...

Chesapeake Middle Colonies Georgia and the Carolinas

region lying between the Chesapeake (i.e., Virginia and Maryland) and the New England colonies encompassed New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania and Delaware (i.e., "middle colonies") which were formerly Dutch colonies. By the year 1670, the largely-Protestant migrant group from the Netherlands boasted the world's biggest mercantile fleet as well as the loftiest living standards. They were in control of trade in the northern European region and grew into one among the most liberal and multicultural European communities, in addition to being the British's fiercest rival in international trade. They welcomed and supported religious and cultural diversity unlike a majority of America's other colonizers from the European continent.… Continue Reading...

Personal Thought on Three Articles

result in young inmates being jailed for long and dying or being released when they are aged and cannot fend for themselves. New York's Broken Parole System The parole system is meant to reward inmates who have shown they have changed, grown, and are ready to rejoin society. This is the real essence of the prison system. Reforming inmates and ensuring they are ready to rejoin society after their jail term or on parole. However, this has not been the situation because most parole boards do not consider the inmate's behavior while in jail, age, education level, and what home the individual would be returning to. They seem to only focus on… Continue Reading...

Effect That Changes in Society Has Had on the Curriculum

in secondary and college. The significance of the necessity for awareness of the national heritage has led to the adoption of the New York social studies curriculum in the common core state standards (CCSS). The common core standards provide the learning objectives for students in the entire state ("New York State K-12 Social Studies Framework EngageNY", 2017). The standards are crafted to be relevant to the real world scenarios and equip students with knowledge and skills necessary for them to succeed in their career pursuits. The new social studies curriculum not only prepares the students for their careers but also prepares them with the knowledge that will be necessary for their civic… Continue Reading...

PNAC the OSP and Iraqs WMDs

of CIA operations officer Valerie Plame and former U.S. Ambassador to Gabon penned an op-ed for The New York Times entitled "What I Didn't Find in Africa" -- a piece that described how neither he nor Ambassador Owens-Kirkpatrick had uncovered any evidence of Niger uranium sales to Iraq.[footnoteRef:1] Both Owens-Kirkpatrick and Wilson, moreover, had submitted briefings to the CIA to this point. Nonetheless, the CIA along with British intelligence stood by as the narrative that Iraq had purchased uranium took hold in the Oval Office. Both British and American intelligence were wrong about Iraq's WMD program in 2003. This paper will explain why, where, when and how… Continue Reading...

Law Enforcement and Corrections

popularity. Week 3 Discussion The state in consideration is the State of New York. One of the dominant cultures of the state correction facilities and institutions in this state is that of violence. According to Rose, juvenile detainees in these institutions are subjected to routine violence not only by other inmates but also by correction officers within the institutions. For instance, statistics indicate that in 2014, more than 40% of these juvenile detainees were subjected to the use of force by institutional guards at least once, and were in need of medical assistance for a significant figure of 450 times (Rose, 2014).… Continue Reading...

World History

International Perspectives, ed. Peter N. Stearns, Peter Seixas and Sam Wineburg (New York: New York University Press, 2000), 127.] Although the abovementioned pool of information was by no means perfect by the middle, or even the end, of the last century, it increased in magnitude and reliability sufficiently enough to contribute to global historical examination endeavors. Secondly, professional world history's development suggested a novel sense of global duty and concern. The last century was witness to a couple of global-scale, colossally devastative wars, in addition to several conflicts of a smaller… Continue Reading...

Fostering a Creative Child

Child Development What follows in this brief report is a review and reaction to a New York Times article about child development. While great strides have been made when it comes to knowing about child development and how to positively move it along, there are still new theories and ideas every day on how to react to setbacks and how to make the child development process even more advanced and positive for the child as they grow and learn for the first time. The article was indeed very intriguing and for a number of reasons that will all be described in this essay. While it… Continue Reading...

sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"New York" (2013, October 12) Retrieved May 14, 2024, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/new-york-124353

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"New York" 12 October 2013. Web.14 May. 2024. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/new-york-124353>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"New York", 12 October 2013, Accessed.14 May. 2024,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/new-york-124353