Performance Appraisals Article Review

Total Length: 1077 words ( 4 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 3

Page 1 of 4

Performance Appraisals

Jeffrey Spence's 2011 article "Conscious rating distortion in performance appraisal: a review, commentary, and proposal framework for research" discusses the relationship between managers and employees and how managers use conscious rating distortion as a means to evaluate individuals that they are in charge of. Performance appraisal is one of the principal topics that the paper relates to as the writer tests several theories with the purpose of determining the techniques that managers use and their tendency to adopt particular attitudes. In order to increase productivity, managers make use of a wide range of methods, but they are not necessarily motivated by their determination to obtain accuracy from their employees.

While managers are generally focused on influencing their employees in obtaining positive results, they are also aware that a successful company consists out of groups of individuals who have strong relations and who work as a team. It would virtually be absurd to overstress particular persons in order to have them working to their full potential. Spence prefers to support this position, but this practically means that he ignores the many cases involving managers who are solely interested in accuracy and consider that employees are easily replaceable. A great deal of managers in the contemporary society believes that it is essential for the companies to achieve success and is thus unsympathetic regarding employees. This is especially worrying, given that numerous employees end up being treated like machines and managers coerce them in performing stressing jobs. It is difficult to determine whether this is wrong, considering that conditions today are critical when concerning relations between managers and their employees.
In an era when competition is one of the most important concepts it is almost impossible for managers to ignore profits in order to develop strong relations with their Even with that, Spence describes goals that each manager is likely to consider at a certain point in his or her career with the purpose of maximizing profits without affecting the well-being of the company and its employees: "(1) achieving/maintaining a positive relationship with a subordinate, (2) achieving/maintaining a positive image of themselves and their workgroup, and (3) achieving/maintaining behavior that is supportive of organizational norms/goals" (Spence, 93).

Chapter four supports Spence's perspective in regard to the relationship between managers and employees and highlights the fact that interpersonal affect is essential within a company because it makes it possible for employees to be more efficient and for managers to work without experiencing stress. Even with this, interpersonal affect in the workplace is different from typical social likeability because it strictly focuses on the job. In order to achieve positive results, managers need to refrain from employing personal convictions in assessing an employee. Although Spence and Chapter four both relate to the importance of strong relationships between managers and their employees, they also promote the concept regarding how objectivity needs to dominate the workplace in order for these relations to have a positive effect on the company.

Through applying the regular focus theory Spence demonstrated that managers take into consideration a great deal of concepts as they assess their employees and that accuracy is not their principal goal. They apparently believe that impartiality is a key feature in assessing an….....

Show More ⇣


     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


Related Essays

Performance Appraisal Security Management

simply focusing on the negative can be disheartening from the employee’s point-of-view. Also, another function of performance appraisals is to communicate to employees the degree to which the organization takes a vested interest in their development. That is why, according to McCrie (2016), “In well-structured organizations, all employees deserve appraisals” (p.160). Performance appraisals are something employees deserve, to support their progress and to show that the organization does not regard them as disposable. Appraisals also allow employees to provide input about what they would like to see the company improve upon in terms of its support, customer relations, and how it engages in recruitment and development… Continue Reading...

Todays Strategic Human Resource Management

organization -- so it includes things like ensuring morale is high, performance appraisals, complaints and labor relations (if applicable). Employee relations is a key function in terms of reducing turnover, which is important if the organization is going to dedicate the time and energy to finding the right people and developing them. That sort of investment must be protected, which is where both employee relations and total rewards come into play. Having a workforce that is engaged with the organization will help it to grow long-term because it will not bleed talent. Safety is another key area for human resources management.… Continue Reading...

Diagnosing Change at FedEx

phenomenon. Often, organisations waste time, effort, and resources in performance appraisals, employee development, and other HR processes without a significant impact on overall goals and objectives. With more data-driven HR practice, FedEx would eliminate HR processes that do not add value to the organisation. Effectiveness is about producing a certain desired outcome. In most cases, organisations invest in HR processes, but they cannot actually substantiate the impact of those processes on the organisation's bottom line. A people analytics approach can help FedEx quantify… Continue Reading...

Development of High Potential Employees

in organizations than formal employee retention procedures. To identify high-potential employees, human resources managers may use a variety of methods including performance appraisals, performance reviews, individual development plans or career mapping, and even anecdotal data (Downs, 2015). Among organizations that do have formal high-potential employee development programs, some also have active succession planning with transparent methods of communicating intent. For example, PepsiCo has a formal leadership development center, and admission to the leadership development center is based on performance on various HR metrics (Zhu & Manjarrez, 2017). Empirical research has been demonstrating the advantages of formal identification and employee training for high-potential personnel. Research has also been increasingly focusing on the… Continue Reading...

sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Performance Appraisals" (2012, January 12) Retrieved May 11, 2024, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/performance-appraisals-48820

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Performance Appraisals" 12 January 2012. Web.11 May. 2024. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/performance-appraisals-48820>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Performance Appraisals", 12 January 2012, Accessed.11 May. 2024,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/performance-appraisals-48820