Performance Management Article Critique

Total Length: 432 words ( 1 double-spaced pages)

Total Sources: 1

Performance Management

The objective of this study is to critique and article concerning a court case or lawsuit related to discrimination or unjust dismissal by a performance management system.

Case Description

It is reported in the work of Barrett and Kernan (1987) that in "Nord v. U.S. Steel (1985) the plaintiff successfully demonstrated that she had a record of good performance appraisals before she requested a promotion. After this request her appraisals became negative, which led to her eventual termination. The court reasoned that the downgraded evaluations after her promotion request were evidence of discrimination. Employers in the remaining 37 cases successfully defended their termination decisions." (p. 6) The court emphasized the necessity of "applying performance appraisal standards equally to all employees

Purpose of Performance Management

Miller (2015) writes "A performance appraisal itself may become the target of a lawsuit. Indeed, no evaluation system is completely immune to the risk of litigation. Even a well-designed system can subject an employer to various liabilities if it is poorly implemented or applied in an inconsistent manner. If they are well written and consistent, appraisals can support disciplinary or termination decisions. However, if poorly implemented they can support the plaintiff's position.
" (p. 1)

III. Analysis of Criteria and Methods Used for Performance Management Measurement

Barrett and Kerman, in their review of performance management measurements reported six specific points including: (1) Conduction of a "job analysis to ascertain characteristics necessary for successful job performance"; (2) Incorporation of "these characteristics into a rating instrument. Although the professional literature recommends rating instruments that are tied to specific job behaviors (i.e. BARS), the courts routinely accept less sophisticated approaches such as simple graphic rating scales and trait ratings. Regardless of method, written definitive standards should be provided to all raters"; (3) Training of supervisors for proper use of the instrument for rating; (4) Train supervisors to use the rating instrument properly; (5) There should be in place "formal appeal mechanisms and review of ratings by upper-level personnel"; and (6) Evaluations should be documented by the organization in addition to documentation of reasons for termination. (Barrett and Kerman, 1987, p. 11)

IV. Legal and Ethical Issues

The legal and ethical issues are clear for the employer as failure to set in place a solidified performance measurement system that is fair and properly implemented may result in.....

     Open the full completed essay and source list


OR

     Order a one-of-a-kind custom essay on this topic


Related Essays

Performance Management and Non Profit Boards

Performance Management The governance of a corporation is the role of the board of directors and the management has the duty of running the firm on a day to day basis. The board, therefore, oversees the management and ensures the interests of the various shareholders are upheld. The executive department is made up of the top level managers and they are required to work as a team so as to deliver on the company goals. According to Wash (2002), management can only be successful in their work if they have… Continue Reading...

Performance Management

What questions does Performance Management see to answer? Performance Management sees to answer questions relating to employee work objectives and overall role within an organization. The performance manager will develop, assess and monitor a plan by which an employee's contributions to the organizational strategy and strategic objective are identified, measured and reviewed. The questions that the Performance Management will attempt to answer, therefore, are: What is the role of the employee? What is the objective of the employee? How well is the employee meeting the objective? What could be done to help the… Continue Reading...

Performance Management and Maslows Hierarchy of Needs

The Extent to Which Motivation Theory Underpins Performance Management Systems Performance Management Systems attempt to answer questions about employee work objectives and their overall role within an organization. The performance manager system is designed to assist the manager in developing, assessing and monitoring a plan by which an employee’s contributions to the organizational strategy and strategic objective are identified, measured and reviewed. The questions that the Performance Management System will are: What is the role of the employee? What is the objective of the employee? How well is the employee meeting the objective? What could be done… Continue Reading...

Performance Management Review

What issues might arise as they attempt to merge their respective performance management systems? Performance management systems play a significant part in the everyday operational success of an organization. When a firm acquires another firm, there are fundamental issues that might emanate as they try to merge their corresponding performance management systems. One of the key issues is that some of the metrics being employed by one company may not be suitable or efficacious for the other company. Majority of the organizations have a performance management practice and procedure that they utilize to measure and assess personnel on objectives delineated by… Continue Reading...

Training Program for Performance Management

Performance Management Training Program Having nonperforming employees can be frustrating for any organization. So as an employer, it is necessary to ensure that your employees receive training and development that they need to up the performance of the duties assigned to them. We shed some light on when you must train and develop your staff for effective management. Notice that effective human resource planning is important since it ensures that training needs are met individually or collectively. It also ensures that performance levels are well managed. Human resources is a… Continue Reading...

Training Program for Performance Management

Performance Management Training Program Having nonperforming employees can be frustrating for any organization. So as an employer, it is necessary to ensure that your employees receive training and development that they need to up the performance of the duties assigned to them. We shed some light on when you must train and develop your staff for effective management. Notice that effective human resource planning is important since it ensures that training needs are met individually or collectively. It also ensures that performance levels are well managed. Human resources is a… Continue Reading...

Training Program for Performance Management

Performance Management Training Program Having nonperforming employees can be frustrating for any organization. So as an employer, it is necessary to ensure that your employees receive training and development that they need to up the performance of the duties assigned to them. We shed some light on when you must train and develop your staff for effective management. Notice that effective human resource planning is important since it ensures that training needs are met individually or collectively. It also ensures that performance levels are well managed. Human resources is a… Continue Reading...

Accounting Cost and Performance Management

Q1. Explain the differences between cost-effectiveness and performance management. Which performance elements are essential for assessing financial soundness of a nonprofit? Although sound financial performance is clearly critical for an organization to flourish, cutting costs is not synonymous with performance management itself. An organization can be maximizing its cost effectiveness but not necessarily its performance. Performance management sets specific goals for employees. Goals must be measurable to be clear and effective but not necessarily tangible in nature. “Performance management is a whole work system that begins when a job is defined as needed” (Heathfield, 2018, par.3). It… Continue Reading...

Managing Quality Safety and Individual Performance in Healthcare

paper discusses the usefulness of the total quality management (TQM) model, the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) Safety Performance Management Framework, and the balanced scorecard in the health care sector. Total Quality Management TQM is a management philosophy that advocates for organization-wide and continuous improvement of an organization's products and processes. The philosophy espouses five major principles: customer focus, management commitment, employee empowerment, continuous improvement, and evidence-based decision making (Kaynak & Rogers, 2013). The element of customer-focus means that every decision an organization makes and process it undertakes is geared towards creating value for the customer. From strategic planning and personnel management to product decisions, the organization places… Continue Reading...

Performance Based Management Synthesis

monitoring and evaluation. Defining PBM can be quite problematic, with the term being often confused with performance measurement (Rivenbank, Fasiello & Adamo, 2016). In addition, performance management is often thought to involve only personnel management processes such as employee performance appraisal (Turk, 2016). Furthermore, contention exists over whether it should be considered an art or a science, or whether or not it is a discipline on its own (Brudan, 2010). Also referred to as results or outcome-based management, performance management is an umbrella term which includes a number of ongoing organisational processes: setting and clarifying objectives, establishing performance indicators, gathering and analysing data, reporting outcomes, and learning from the outcomes (Woerrlein & Scheck, 2016). This… Continue Reading...

Project Management

environment, project definition, time and cost estimation, project plan, risk management, resource scheduling, project team issues, and project performance management. Organisational Setting and Project Environment The organisational setting is a publicly listed renewable energy firm with operations in Australia and the UK. The organisation also has joint venture agreements with entities in Germany, Singapore, South Korea, Switzerland, and the Netherlands. The firm is involved in generating renewable energy, mainly from solar, wind, and water. Through strategic partnerships, the firm is also involved in the manufacturing of renewable energy equipment such as solar cells and wind turbines. The firm was established in 2006, and has made tremendous progress in… Continue Reading...

Public Sector Performance Measurement

For the public sector, performance management is a valuable process. Organizations increasingly rely on performance data to make decisions relating to various organizational processes, including strategic planning, internal management, resource allocation, reporting, as well as monitoring and evaluation. This is what performance management is all about -- continuous measurement of performance, definition of performance objectives and outcomes, communication of the outcomes, and taking action based on those outcomes. As demonstrated by literature, implementing PBM can be viewed as implementing organizational change: it requires assessment of the status quo, defining the organization's desired future state,… Continue Reading...

Healthcare Management for Eldercare Advocacy Organization

becomes very hard (Shlutz, Andre & Sjovold, 2015 p 42). This also impacts on performance management which is fast gaining popularity in the public sector as a means to improve on accountability. Unfortunately, it has been cumbered by a series of challenges in its implementation; this is in spite of the frameworks developed over the last couple of years (Nistor, Stefanescu & Crisan 2017, p.32). Healthcare is a strong indicator for how people experience quality of life. Just like economical issues, healthcare is a topic for debate in many countries. The healthcare delivery system is reflective of the government’s performance in most countries, hence… Continue Reading...

IBM Supply Chain Concerns

key part of remaining competitive. Performance management in the form of reviews and feedback is also part of this codification. One of the principal ways in which human resources correlates to management information systems and supply chain management is through the notion of strategic human resources management. Part of the strategic value found in human resources is allocating the resources needed to fulfill certain job functions and business needs. This requires both short and long term planning for various aspects of management information systems and a dependable supply chain to fulfill these objectives. Implementing strategic… Continue Reading...

Leaders Direction for Organization During Change

the following will be looked at periodically: • Operating model: this shall define the organization's operating philosophy as well as structure. • Performance management: involves risk management, metrics development, and cost/savings tracking. • Supply chain business processes: defines the structure of the organization's procurement process. • Change management: details how employees will be trained, stakeholders managed and how role transition is handled. • Value acceleration: identify and act on opportunities in the short-term that help save costs (Halm, 2014). Step 3: Aggressively Transition to the New Organization Structure New job descriptions and positions will be launched for the entire workforce. Redundant roles will be eliminated or combined so that there is a… Continue Reading...

Virtual Team Life Cycle

to a total of five different phases. Those phases, in order, are preparation, the launch, performance management, training and team development and disbanding/reintegration. There is another way to see those steps. The first two are the origin. The third and fourth steps are emblematic of the team while it is in operation. The last step, of course, is when things are tapering off, at least temporarily. It should be remembered that the cycles referenced throughout this report are cyclical and they will occur multiple times. For example, if there is a change in leadership or team membership, the steps shall start anew. The depth and… Continue Reading...

Taming the Measurement Monster

to comprehend that formal requirements will have a greater impact on the adoption of performance management in comparison to implementation. Therefore, the internal requirements have a more significant influence in contrast to external requirements. The key way in which this model is likely to influence performance measures within a healthcare organization is the sense that measures set by the government will solely be espoused for the sake of conforming to external anticipations with minimal impact on enhancing decision making. Therefore, the health care organization can be used to enhance accountability and enhance performance. In this case, not only will the healthcare fulfill external expectations,… Continue Reading...

Walmart Human Resource Practices and Change

compensation and performance management, needs to change. These elements are debated by both company critics and partners. This issue has apparently arisen due to its large, diverse associate pool – the company has roughly 1.3 million employees (in-store) across the numerous stores situated all over the US. Understandably, there is an expansive range of benefits and pay related requirements. The company understands this need to have a wide-ranging list of alternatives for personnel and addresses it (Bouffard et al. 2006). The company is not wholly effective when it comes to addressing personnel… Continue Reading...

Multinational Companies

(PWC), Unilever, and Procter and Gamble are good examples. A closer look at these firms' HRM strategies across their international operations -- from recruitment to training and development and performance management -- reveals significant similarities between practices in the home country and practices in foreign subsidiaries. On the contrary, Chinese or Korean managers are likely to favour bureaucratic and hierarchical procedures since China as a society is characterised by high power distance. Based on this premise, it would not be unusual for Samsung and Lenovo executives managing the firms' subsidiaries in Europe or North America, for instance, to make and enforce managerial decisions that exemplify the characteristics of a high-power distance society. In other words, as Samsung and Lenovo… Continue Reading...

Difference Between Correlation & Causality

as to whether the metrics chosen by the ARC as applied and used from the OPM's performance management framework are proper and best for what is being looked at and assessed. Thus, looking at whether ARC is looking at the correct items, whether they are being looked at the right way or if perhaps they should be drilling down a bit further when it comes to the depth and breadth of their analysis is important. The ARC's methodology and choice of analysis points will be compared and contrasted with the overall desired framework and list of best practices from the OPM (OPM, 2017; ARC, 2017). Answer… Continue Reading...

sample essay writing service

Cite This Resource:

Latest APA Format (6th edition)

Copy Reference
"Performance Management" (2015, March 04) Retrieved May 17, 2024, from
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/performance-management-2149858

Latest MLA Format (8th edition)

Copy Reference
"Performance Management" 04 March 2015. Web.17 May. 2024. <
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/performance-management-2149858>

Latest Chicago Format (16th edition)

Copy Reference
"Performance Management", 04 March 2015, Accessed.17 May. 2024,
https://www.aceyourpaper.com/essays/performance-management-2149858